Hollywood has a weird obsession with the "before" picture. You know the one. For decades, if you wanted to watch plus size romance movies, you usually had to sit through a grueling montage of a protagonist sweating on a treadmill or crying into a salad before they were deemed "worthy" of the hot lead actor. It’s exhausting. Honestly, it’s also just bad storytelling.
We’re finally seeing a shift. People are tired of seeing their bodies treated as a "problem" that needs a third-act resolution.
The slow death of the "Body as a Burden" narrative
Remember Puffy Chair or those early 2000s indies? They were grainy and raw, but they still often tiptoed around weight like it was a ticking time bomb. Fast forward a bit. We got Dumplin’ (2018) on Netflix, and suddenly, the vibe changed. Danielle Macdonald played Willowdean Dickson not as someone waiting to be thin, but as someone demanding space in a beauty pageant-obsessed Texas town.
It wasn't just about the pageant. It was about the fact that Bo, the "hot" guy at the diner, liked her exactly as she was. No gym montage required. That’s the core of what makes modern plus size romance movies actually work—the romance isn't a reward for weight loss. It’s just... romance.
The industry used to think that "relatable" meant "miserable." They assumed that if a character was fat, their entire personality had to be about being fat. If they weren't trying to lose weight, they were the "funny best friend" who gave sage advice while the thin leads did all the making out. That's a boring way to live and a boring way to write.
Why Last Holiday is a sleeper hit for plus size representation
Let's talk about Queen Latifah in Last Holiday (2006). If you haven't seen it recently, go back and watch.
Georgia Byrd is a department store clerk who thinks she’s dying, so she blows her savings on a luxury trip to Europe. While the plot is a bit of a "bucket list" cliché, the romance with LL Cool J is incredibly grounded. He’s been in love with her from page one. He doesn't love her "despite" her size. He just loves her. Georgia is stylish, she’s a phenomenal chef, and she carries herself with a quiet dignity that the movie never undermines for a cheap laugh.
It's one of those plus size romance movies that actually lets the protagonist be glamorous. She wears the designer dresses. She eats the expensive food. She wins the guy.
The Netflix effect and the "Tall Girl" controversy
Netflix has been a bit of a mixed bag here. We saw Sierra Burgess Is a Loser, which... wow. That movie had some issues. Between the catfishing and the weirdly tone-deaf ending, it didn't really land the "plus size win" people were hoping for. It felt like the writers were still stuck in that 90s mindset where the "unconventional" girl has to trick the guy into liking her.
But then you look at something like Survival of the Thickest. While technically a series, it functions like a long-form rom-com. Michelle Buteau is a force of nature. Mavis Beaumont is messy, talented, and her romantic interests are diverse and genuinely attracted to her. It’s a far cry from the days of The Mirror Has Two Faces, where Barbra Streisand had to undergo a massive physical transformation to get Jeff Bridges to notice her.
🔗 Read more: Islands in the Stream Lyrics: The Weird Truth Behind the Greatest Duet Ever
Breaking down the tropes that need to go
- The "Wait, You Like Me?" Shock. It’s okay for a character to be surprised by a crush, but when the surprise is rooted in "But I’m fat and you’re not," it gets old.
- The Supportive Best Friend Syndrome. Plus size characters deserve to be the ones getting the grand romantic gestures, not just the ones helping the lead pick out a dress.
- The Hidden Beauty Reveal. This is when the character takes off glasses or wears a corset and suddenly everyone realizes they're human. Let's just skip to the part where they're hot from the start.
Real-world impact and the E-E-A-T of representation
According to a 2021 study by the Geena Davis Institute on Gender in Media, fat characters are significantly less likely to be depicted in romantic relationships than their thinner counterparts. When they are in relationships, those relationships are often the butt of the joke or portrayed as "unrealistic."
This matters because movies shape our social scripts. If you only ever see people who look like you getting dumped or being the punchline, it affects how you move through the world. Expert film critics like Angelica Jade Bastién have frequently written about the "visual language of desire" and how Hollywood often fails to apply that language to bodies that aren't a size 2.
What about the indie scene?
If you're looking for the best plus size romance movies, the indie world is often where the real gems hide. Plus One (the 2019 one with Maya Erskine) isn't strictly "plus size" focused, but it treats body diversity with a casualness that big blockbusters lack.
Then there’s Brittany Runs a Marathon. Now, this one is controversial. Some people hate it because it is about weight loss. But others argue it’s a realistic look at how fitness can be a tool for mental health rather than just "getting skinny." It’s a nuanced take, and whether or not it counts as a "romance" is up for debate, but the relationship she builds with Jern is one of the most honest depictions of "dating while changing" you'll find.
How to find movies that don't suck
It’s getting easier to filter out the garbage. You want to look for movies where the costume designer actually knows how to style a curve. If the protagonist is stuck in baggy flannels for the whole film while the "mean girl" is in Chanel, that's a red flag.
- Look for diverse creators. When plus size women write and direct, the romance feels different. It feels lived-in.
- Check the lighting. Seriously. If the love scenes are shot in shadows or cut away quickly, the director is uncomfortable with the body they're filming.
- The "Food Test." Does the character eat normally? Or is every scene involving food a moment of "guilt" or "cheating"?
Movies like Falling for Figaro or even the recent Patsy & Loretta biopic elements show that chemistry isn't size-dependent. It's about eye contact, timing, and that weird, unexplainable spark.
The future of the genre
We’re moving toward a place where "plus size" isn't a genre. It's just a casting choice.
Imagine a world where a rom-com stars a size 18 woman and the plot is about her trying to save her family’s bakery or winning a high-stakes legal case—and the romance is just a natural part of that journey. No one mentions her weight. No one "bravely" loves her. She’s just a woman in love.
We aren't quite there yet. Hollywood still likes to pat itself on the back for "diversity" every time they cast someone over 140 pounds. But the audience is smarter now. We have TikTok creators and film essayists calling out the "Fat Suit" era (looking at you, The Whale and Friends reruns) and demanding better.
Actionable steps for the savvy viewer
If you want to support better representation in plus size romance movies, your views are your vote. Stream the ones that get it right.
- Watch Dumplin' on Netflix for a masterclass in "coming of age" romance that respects the lead.
- Revisit Last Holiday. It’s a mood booster and LL Cool J is at his peak charming self.
- Seek out Real Women Have Curves. It’s a classic for a reason, focusing on the intersection of culture, body image, and burgeoning romance.
- Follow critics like Roxane Gay. She has written extensively on the "fat protagonist" and offers a sharp, necessary perspective on what Hollywood gets wrong.
- Support indie projects on platforms like Mubi or Bright Wight TV. These platforms often host short films and features that take bigger risks with casting than Disney or Warner Bros.
Stop settling for movies that make you feel like a project. Romance is about being seen, and you deserve to see characters who look like you being adored without any caveats or "before" photos. The shift is happening; we just have to keep showing up for it.
Next Steps for Better Viewing:
Start by auditing your own "Watch Next" list. If every romantic lead in your queue looks exactly the same, use the search terms "body positive romance" or "plus size leads" on your favorite streaming app. Platforms like Netflix and Hulu have improved their tagging systems significantly over the last year, making it easier to find stories where the "happily ever after" isn't contingent on a dress size. If a movie starts leaning into the "sad fat girl" trope within the first ten minutes, turn it off. Your time is too valuable for 1990s leftovers.