You’re driving down Route 3, past the typical South Shore sprawl, and suddenly the trees get taller. The air feels a little saltier. You’re heading toward Plymouth, but you aren't here for the Rock or some touristy pancake house. You're here because you want to play a course that feels like it belongs in the high-end private world of the Hamptons, but you don't want to pay a $100,000 initiation fee to do it.
That’s the magic of Pinehills Golf Club Plymouth. Honestly, it’s a bit of a freak of nature in the New England golf scene. Most daily-fee courses in this part of the country are either cramped, rocky, or feel like they were squeezed into a housing development as an afterthought. Not here. At Pinehills, the homes are there, sure, but they’re tucked away behind massive ridges of sand and pine. It’s pure golf. It’s quiet.
If you’ve played there, you know the feeling of pulling up to that Shingle-style clubhouse. It’s intimidating. You start wondering if you’re actually allowed to be there. But then the bag drop guys greet you, and you realize that while it looks like a billionaire’s playground, it’s actually one of the most welcoming spots for anyone who cares about the game.
The Tale of Two Courses: Jones vs. Rees
Most people just say "I'm playing Pinehills," but that’s like saying "I’m eating at a restaurant" without mentioning if it’s steak or sushi. You have two distinct personalities here. You’ve got the Jones Course, designed by Rees Jones’ brother, Rees (wait, no—it was Rees and Nicklaus... actually, let's get the lineage right). It’s Rees Jones and Nicklaus Design.
The Jones Course is the one that usually beats people up. It’s classic Rees. He’s the "Open Doctor," right? He likes to frame everything. You stand on the tee, and you see exactly where you aren't supposed to hit it. Huge bunkers. Forced carries. It’s a brawny layout that demands you actually think about your club selection rather than just "grip it and rip it."
Then you have the Nicklaus Design course. It’s different. It feels more "natural" in a rugged way. While the Jones course feels architecturally "built," the Nicklaus course feels like they just found the holes in the woods. The greens are notorious. If you find yourself on the wrong tier of a Nicklaus green at Pinehills, you might as well just pick up and move on to the next hole. Your three-putt percentage is going to skyrocket.
Which one is better? Ask ten locals, and you’ll get ten different answers.
💡 You might also like: What Channel is Champions League on: Where to Watch Every Game in 2026
The Jones course has more of that "championship" feel, where every hole looks like a postcard. The Nicklaus course is more of a ground game. It’s "finessy." You’ve got to use the slopes. If you like seeing your ball disappear over a ridge and reappear ten yards closer to the hole because you used the topography correctly, Nicklaus is your play.
Why the "Public" Label is Kinda Misleading
Let’s be real. Calling Pinehills Golf Club Plymouth a public course is like calling a Porsche a "commuter car." Technically true, but it misses the point.
Most public tracks have slow play, bumpy greens, and a snack bar that hasn't seen a fresh sandwich since the Clinton administration. Pinehills operates on a different level. They have a massive practice facility—we’re talking 300+ yards of grass tees, not those annoying rubber mats—and a short game area where you can actually practice 40-yard bunker shots.
The maintenance is where they really flex.
Because the soil in Plymouth is so sandy—thank the glaciers for that—the drainage is incredible. You can have a literal monsoon on Tuesday, and by Wednesday morning, you’re getting roll on the fairways. Most courses in Massachusetts turn into a swampy mess the second it rains. Not here. That’s why the rates stay high. You aren't just paying for the name; you’re paying for the fact that the bunkers aren't filled with standing water and the greens are rolling at a 10 or 11 on the stimpmeter.
The "Hidden" Difficulty: It's the Wind, Stupid
People talk about the bunkering. They talk about the elevation changes. But nobody talks about the wind.
📖 Related: Eastern Conference Finals 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
Plymouth sits right on the edge of Cape Cod Bay. You might be a few miles inland at the course, but that Atlantic air doesn't care. It whips through those corridors of pines. A 150-yard shot that’s usually an easy 8-iron suddenly requires a choked-down 6-iron because the wind is "heavy." It’s a coastal-style wind without the ocean view.
If you aren't playing a "low" ball flight, Pinehills will eat you alive.
There’s also the psychological factor of the pine needles. If you miss the fairway, you aren't necessarily in deep tall grass. You’re on a bed of pine needles. It looks easy to hit off of. It isn't. Your club will slide right under the ball, or you'll thin it into the next county. It’s "Pinehurst-lite" in that regard.
Pro Tips for Your First Round
- Don't Buy the Yardage Book: Just use a GPS app. The elevation changes are so dramatic that a flat yardage number is basically useless anyway.
- The Grille is Legit: Don't just leave after your round. The Rye Tavern is nearby and great, but the clubhouse grille at Pinehills makes a steak tips dish that is arguably better than the golf.
- Check the Wind at the Clubhouse: If it’s breezy at the putting green, it’s going to be a gale on the back nine of the Jones course.
- Aim for the "Fat" of the Green: Both courses reward conservative approach shots. If you pin-hunt here, you’ll end up in a six-foot-deep bunker wondering where your life went wrong.
Managing the Cost and the Hype
Is it expensive? Yeah. For a Saturday morning, you’re looking at over $150, sometimes pushing $200. In the world of "affordable" golf, that’s a tough pill to swallow.
But here’s how you justify it. If you go to a cheaper course, you’re probably looking at a 5.5-hour round, terrible turf, and a starter who treats you like a nuisance. At Pinehills, the pace of play is actually policed. They want you off the course in 4 hours and 15 minutes. They value your time.
Plus, there’s the Pinehills Academy with guys like Bill McInerney. If you’re serious about your game, this isn't just a place to whack a ball; it’s a place to learn how to play. The instruction there is top-tier, and they have all the tech—Trackman, video analysis, the whole nine yards.
👉 See also: Texas vs Oklahoma Football Game: Why the Red River Rivalry is Getting Even Weirder
What Most People Get Wrong About Plymouth Golf
A lot of golfers think you have to cross the bridge into Cape Cod to find "real" vacation golf. That’s a mistake. The traffic on the Sagamore Bridge is a nightmare. You can stay on the "mainland" side in Plymouth and get a better experience at Pinehills than you will at 90% of the courses on the Cape.
The "Pinehills" development itself is actually a massive master-planned community. It won awards for a reason. It doesn't feel like a subdivision. It feels like a village in the Cotswolds that somehow got teleported to New England. This creates a weirdly serene atmosphere. No sirens. No highway noise. Just the sound of your ball rattling around in the cup (hopefully).
Final Reality Check
Look, Pinehills Golf Club Plymouth isn't perfect. If you’re a beginner who struggles to get the ball in the air, you are going to have a miserable time. There are too many forced carries. You’ll lose two dozen balls and want to quit the sport.
But if you can break 100 and you appreciate course architecture, it’s a bucket-list spot for the Northeast. It’s the closest most of us will ever get to playing a place like Pine Valley or Shinnecock Hills without an invite from a CEO.
The greens are fast. The bunkers are deep. The pines are thick. It’s exactly what golf in Massachusetts should be.
Your Actionable Move-Forward Plan
- Book in Advance: Don't try to walk on. Use their online portal at least 10–14 days out if you want a morning slot.
- Pick the Right Course: If you want a visual masterpiece, play Jones. If you want a strategic, "chess-match" round, play Nicklaus.
- Warm Up Properly: Arrive 45 minutes early. Use that grass range. It’s included in your fee, so don't waste the opportunity to find your swing before the first tee.
- Watch the Slope: The greens break more toward the ocean than you think. Even if it looks flat, it’s probably pulling toward the coast.
Don't overthink it. Just drive down, pay the greens fee, and enjoy the fact that for four hours, you’re playing on some of the best dirt in the country.