If you’ve ever stood in the middle of Pennsylvania Station New York City during rush hour, you know the feeling. It’s that specific brand of subterranean claustrophobia where the ceiling feels two inches from your scalp and the air smells faintly of Auntie Anne’s pretzels and desperation. For decades, the running joke—originally coined by architectural historian Vincent Scully—was that back in the day, you entered the city like a god, but now you scuttle in like a rat.
He wasn't wrong.
But things are changing. Honestly, if you haven’t been through the complex in the last year or two, you’re missing a massive shift in how New York handles its most hated transit hub. We aren't just talking about a fresh coat of paint. We’re talking about a multi-billion dollar identity crisis that is finally starting to resolve itself in favor of the commuter.
The Ghost of 1963 and Why Everyone is Still Mad
You can't talk about Penn Station without talking about the original McKim, Mead & White masterpiece. It was pink granite. It had 84 Doric columns. It was, by all accounts, one of the most beautiful public spaces ever built on American soil. Then, in 1963, they tore it down to build Madison Square Garden and the current underground labyrinth.
It was a civic crime.
The destruction was so egregious it literally birthed the modern landmark preservation movement in New York. If Penn Station hadn’t been demolished, we probably wouldn't have the Landmarks Preservation Commission today. Grand Central Terminal was saved specifically because New Yorkers looked at the concrete basement of Pennsylvania Station New York City and said, "Never again."
Today, the "new" Penn Station (which is now over 60 years old) handles more than 600,000 passengers a day. That is more than all three major New York area airports—JFK, LaGuardia, and Newark—combined. It was designed for 200,000. You do the math. The math says it’s crowded.
👉 See also: US States I Have Been To: Why Your Travel Map Is Probably Lying To You
Moynihan Train Hall: The Light at the End of the Tunnel
For a long time, the solution was just "deal with it." But the opening of the Moynihan Train Hall in 2021 changed the vibe. Technically, Moynihan is part of the Pennsylvania Station New York City complex, even though it’s across 8th Avenue in the old James A. Farley Post Office Building.
It’s stunning.
It has an acre of glass skylights. The trusses are original steel from the early 1900s. When you walk in there to catch an Amtrak or a Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) train, you actually feel like a human being again. It’s got a curated food hall with places like Magnolia Bakery and H&H Bagels, which is a far cry from the sad, damp slices of pizza found in the lower concourses.
However, there is a catch. Moynihan doesn’t serve New Jersey Transit. If you’re a commuter from Jersey, you’re still largely stuck in the "pit." This creates a weird class divide in the station. Amtrak riders get the cathedral; NJ Transit riders get the basement.
The LIRR Concourse Glow-Up
While everyone was looking at Moynihan, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) was quietly fixing the main LIRR concourse under 33rd Street. It used to be a dark, cramped hallway. Now? The ceilings have been raised to 18 feet. They installed massive LED screens that mimic the sky.
It's weirdly effective.
✨ Don't miss: UNESCO World Heritage Places: What Most People Get Wrong About These Landmarks
They also doubled the width of the corridor. It’s gone from a 30-foot-wide choke point to a 57-foot-wide thoroughfare. Does it solve everything? No. But it means you aren't shoulder-to-shoulder with a stranger while trying to find out if the 5:14 to Babylon is on Track 18.
What’s Actually Happening with the Redesign?
There is a lot of political bickering over the future of Pennsylvania Station New York City. Former Governor Cuomo had one plan, Governor Hochul has another, and the neighborhood residents have a third. Basically, the state wants to build a bunch of office towers around the station to fund a total overhaul.
Critics, including groups like the Tri-State Transportation Campaign and Rebuild Penn Station, argue that we should just move Madison Square Garden.
Moving the Garden is the "Holy Grail" of NYC urban planning. If the arena moved, you could open up the station to natural light. You could have a grand entrance again. But MSG is a private entity, and James Dolan isn't exactly known for being easy to negotiate with. So, for now, the plan is to work around the Garden.
We are looking at a "single-level" station concept. The idea is to get rid of the confusing multi-level maze and create one massive, high-ceilinged hall. It would cost billions. It would take a decade. But honestly, what choice is there? The current setup is a bottleneck for the entire Northeast Corridor.
Navigating Penn Like a Local
If you’re visiting or just haven't been in a while, here is how you survive Pennsylvania Station New York City without losing your mind.
🔗 Read more: Tipos de cangrejos de mar: Lo que nadie te cuenta sobre estos bichos
First, ignore the 7th Avenue entrance if you can. It’s always a mess. Use the West 31st Street entrances or go through Moynihan if you’re on Amtrak. If you are meeting someone, do not say "meet me at the clock." There are several. Meet at the "Cloud" sculpture in Moynihan or the new LIRR entrance on 7th Avenue and 33rd Street.
Second, the food. The new food hall in Moynihan is great, but it’s pricey. If you want a classic NY experience, Rose's Pizza in the LIRR concourse is a legendary (if slightly chaotic) staple.
Third, the tracks. In Penn, they don't announce tracks until about 10 minutes before departure. This leads to the "Penn Station Sprints." Everyone stands staring at the monitors, and the moment a number pops up, a stampede begins.
Pro tip: Use the Transit app or the NJ Transit/MTA apps. Sometimes the track number hits the app 30 seconds before the big board. That 30 seconds is the difference between a seat and standing for an hour to Ronkonkoma.
The Logistics of the Future
Gateway Project. That’s the phrase you’ll hear experts like Vishaan Chakrabarti or groups like the Regional Plan Association mention constantly. It’s the plan to build a new tunnel under the Hudson River.
Right now, if a single bird gets stuck in a wire in the existing 110-year-old tunnels, the entire East Coast rail network grinds to a halt. Pennsylvania Station New York City is only as good as the tunnels leading into it. Federal funding has finally been secured, and work is actually happening. This isn't just "talk" anymore.
Is it perfect? Hardly. But for the first time in sixty years, the trajectory of the station is upward. We are moving away from the "rat" era and slowly, painfully, back toward something that resembles a gateway to the greatest city on earth.
Actionable Steps for the Modern Traveler
- Download the "TrainTime" App: If you are using the LIRR or Metro-North (which now has access via Penn Station Access projects), this app is lightyears ahead of the old paper schedules. It shows you exactly where the train is in real-time.
- Check the Moynihan Departure Board First: Even if you think you’re departing from the old "pits," if you’re on Amtrak, your life will be 100% better if you wait in the Moynihan Train Hall and only head to the platform when necessary.
- Use the West 33rd Street Entrance: The new glass canopy entrance is easy to find and much less claustrophobic than the older subway-style stairwells.
- Monitor the Gateway Development: Keep an eye on local news regarding the "Penn Station Area Redevelopment." It affects everything from property values in Midtown to how long your commute will be in five years.
- Explore the Neighborhood: Don't just sit in the station. With the High Line nearby and the new Manhattan West plaza just a block away, there are actually nice places to wait for a train that don't involve a concrete bunker.
Pennsylvania Station New York City is a work in progress. It’s loud, it’s confusing, and it’s quintessentially New York. But the light is finally starting to reach the platforms.