Wisteria Lane always had a way of making the suburban dream look like a waking nightmare, but nobody embodied that shift quite like Paul Young on Desperate Housewives. Mark Moses played the character with this eerie, stiff-collared intensity that made you want to lock your doors even if you weren't the one he was after. Honestly, if you look back at the pilot episode, Paul is the catalyst for every single thing that happens over the next eight years. Without his secrets, Mary Alice doesn't pull the trigger. Without that gunshot, we don't have a show.
Most fans remember him as the guy who spent way too much time digging up his backyard in the middle of the night. It’s a classic image. But Paul Young wasn’t just some one-dimensional bad guy or a neighborhood creep. He was a man drowning in a very specific kind of grief and paranoia. You’ve got to remember that when we first meet him, he's just a husband who lost his wife to a mysterious suicide. That's heavy. But then the show peels back the layers and you realize he isn’t just grieving; he’s covering up a literal body.
The Dark History of Paul Young on Desperate Housewives
To understand why Paul Young is so polarizing, you have to go back to the "Dana" mystery. It's the backbone of Season 1. Paul and Mary Alice (then known as Todd and Angela Forrest) basically bought a baby from a desperate addict named Deirdre Taylor. When Deirdre showed up years later to take her son back, things went south. Mary Alice killed her, and Paul—being the "devoted" husband—helped chop her up and hide her in a toy chest.
That chest was buried under their pool.
💡 You might also like: Bob Seger vs. Metallica: Why the Turn the Page Lyrics Still Hit So Hard
Think about that for a second. Every time Paul looked out his window or watched his son, Zach, swim, he was looking at the grave of the boy's biological mother. It’s twisted. Most people think he’s a villain because he’s cold, but he’s actually a man who spent decades living in a state of high-alert survival. He did terrible things to protect the life he’d built, which is a recurring theme on Wisteria Lane, but Paul was the only one who didn't get the "lovable neighbor" pass.
When Martha Huber started blackmailing Mary Alice, she didn't realize she was poking a hornet's nest. Paul’s murder of Martha Huber remains one of the most shocking moments in early 2000s television. It wasn't a calculated, cinematic hit. It was messy. It was personal. He strangled her because she destroyed his wife's peace. It’s hard to call him a hero, obviously, but in his mind, he was the vigilante of the Young household.
The Return and the Revenge Plot
After spending years in prison for a murder he didn't actually commit (the "death" of Felicia Tilman, who faked it to frame him), Paul returns in Season 7. This is where the character gets really interesting. He’s no longer the guy trying to hide; he’s the guy who wants to burn the whole street down.
He buys up houses on the lane to open a halfway house for ex-convicts. It’s a brilliant, petty move. He knew exactly how much the residents of Wisteria Lane valued their property prices and their "safety." By bringing "criminals" into their backyard, he forced them to face their own hypocrisy.
The riot in Season 7 is peak Desperate Housewives. You have Paul standing in the middle of the chaos, watching the neighbors tear each other apart. It’s a total shift from the man who was desperately trying to fit in during Season 1. By this point, he’s accepted that he’s the pariah. He leans into it. Mark Moses has mentioned in interviews that playing Paul as someone who has "given up" on being liked allowed him to find a new level of menace.
📖 Related: The Cast of NCIS Los Angeles: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Why the Neighbors Hated Him More Than the Actual Killers
Wisteria Lane is full of murderers. Susan killed people in a car accident. Bree covered up a hit-and-run. Gabrielle’s husband was... well, Carlos. So why was Paul Young on Desperate Housewives treated like the antichrist while everyone else eventually got a seat at the poker table?
- He didn't perform the "Suburban Rituals." Paul didn't do the small talk. He didn't bring over lemon bundt cakes. He was a constant reminder that the neighborhood's facade was fragile.
- The Felicia Tilman factor. Felicia was a master manipulator. She spent years convincing everyone—including the audience at times—that Paul was a monster, even while she was literally cutting off her own fingers to frame him.
- Zach Young. Paul’s relationship with his son was a disaster. Zach was clearly struggling with mental health issues and the trauma of his origins, and Paul’s "tough love" often looked like straight-up abuse.
It's actually pretty sad when you look at his final arc. In the end, Paul confesses to the murder of Martha Huber. He does it not because he's caught, but because he’s tired. He’s done. There’s a scene where he tells Susan that he just wants it to be over. It’s a rare moment of vulnerability for a character who spent seven seasons being a brick wall.
The Myth of the "Pure Villain"
A lot of people group Paul in with characters like George Williams (the creepy pharmacist) or Wayne Davis (Katherine’s abusive ex). But that’s a mistake. George and Wayne were predators. Paul was a protector who lost his moral compass.
The showrunners, including Marc Cherry, often used Paul as a mirror. When the housewives reacted with violence or exclusion toward him, they were usually projecting their own guilt. Paul was the physical manifestation of the "Secret" that the show’s tagline always promised. He didn't hide his darkness as well as Bree or Lynette did, and that made him a social liability.
If you rewatch the series today, you might find yourself feeling surprisingly bad for him. He lost his wife, his son turned into a millionaire hermit who hated him, and his second wife, Beth, was literally sent by her mother to spy on him and eventually took her own life in the same way Mary Alice did. The guy cannot catch a break.
📖 Related: You Told Me to Sing a Pink Song: The Viral Lyrics Taking Over Social Media
Practical Takeaways for Fans Revisiting the Series
If you’re doing a rewatch or diving into the lore of Paul Young on Desperate Housewives for the first time, keep these nuances in mind to truly appreciate the writing:
- Watch the eyes. Mark Moses does incredible work with his gaze. In Season 1, he looks like a man constantly scanning for threats. In Season 7, his eyes are dead. It’s a subtle shift that tracks his loss of hope.
- The Martha Huber murder is the turning point. Pay attention to how the show shifts after this. It’s the moment the series moves from a "mystery" to a "dark dramedy." It set the stakes: anyone can die, and anyone can be a killer.
- Beth Young is the key to his humanity. His relationship with Beth in Season 7 is the only time we see Paul actually try to love someone again. When he realizes she was a plant, it breaks him in a way prison never could.
- The "Halfway House" arc is social commentary. Don't just see it as a revenge plot. It’s the show’s way of critiquing "Not In My Backyard" (NIMBY) culture. Paul is the ultimate NIMBY nightmare.
To really get the full picture of the Young family legacy, you should compare Paul's confession in Season 7 to Mary Alice’s letter in the pilot. They both ended their journeys by choosing truth over the "perfect" life, though it took Paul a lot longer and a much higher body count to get there.
Instead of viewing Paul as the man who ruined Wisteria Lane, try viewing him as the only person who was ever honest about how rotten it was from the start. He didn't create the darkness; he just refused to paint his fence white and pretend it wasn't there. For a show built on secrets, Paul Young was the most dangerous thing of all: a man with nothing left to hide.
To understand the full impact of his departure, look at how the tone of the street changed once he was back behind bars—the tension didn't leave; it just became less honest. You can find similar character studies in television dramas that explore the "broken protector" trope, such as Tony Soprano or Walter White, though Paul remains unique for his specifically suburban brand of tragedy.