It almost didn’t happen. Honestly, if you look at the state of U2 in 1990, they were basically a band on the verge of a messy, public divorce. They had retreated to Hansa Studios in Berlin—a cold, cavernous place still echoing with the ghosts of David Bowie and Iggy Pop—to "chop down The Tree," as Bono famously put it. They wanted to kill their own myth. But the sessions for Achtung Baby were a total disaster. Adam Clayton and Larry Mullen Jr. wanted to stay true to the rock roots that made them global superstars, while Bono and The Edge were obsessed with the industrial, electronic grit coming out of the European club scene. They were fighting. They were stuck. And then, during a tedious jam session for a different song called "Sick Puppy," a miracle occurred. The Edge started playing two different chord progressions on his guitar, and suddenly, the room changed. That moment gave birth to One, a track that didn't just save the band's career; it redefined what a rock anthem could be in the 1990s.
The Berlin Breakdown and the Birth of One
Berlin was supposed to be inspiring. The Wall had just fallen. The city was in a state of chaotic rebirth. But inside the studio, the atmosphere was toxic. Longtime producer Daniel Lanois and the legendary Brian Eno were trying to guide a ship that was actively sinking. You’ve probably heard the stories of bands "struggling" in the studio, but this was existential. They couldn't agree on a direction. They couldn't even agree on what sounded good.
Then came the bridge.
The Edge was working on a bridge for "Sick Puppy" (which eventually became "Mysterious Ways") and stumbled onto a sequence of chords that felt heavier, more soulful. Lanois heard it and told him to play it again. Then again. He told the rest of the band to join in. Within fifteen minutes, the skeleton of One was there. It was a gift from the universe. It provided a singular point of focus for a group of men who were currently despising each other’s creative instincts. It’s funny how tension creates the best art. Without the genuine threat of U2 breaking up, the raw, bleeding heart of this song probably would have stayed hidden.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Lyrics
People play this song at weddings. Seriously. They play it while cutting the cake or for their first dance, thinking it’s this beautiful, romantic tribute to togetherness. It’s actually kind of dark if you really listen. Bono has said repeatedly that the song isn't about "oneness" in a hippie, "let’s all hold hands" kind of way. It’s about the struggle to stay together when you don't even like each other.
✨ Don't miss: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
"We're one, but we're not the same. We get to carry each other."
That "get to" is the most important part of the lyric. It’s a choice. It’s a burden. It’s not a breezy, effortless love. It’s the heavy, exhausting work of a relationship—whether that’s a marriage, a friendship, or a four-piece rock band from Dublin. Bono wrote the lyrics during a time when his own marriage was solid, but his relationship with his bandmates was fraying, and his father, Bob Hewson, was a constant source of complicated emotion. The lines "Did I disappoint you? / Or leave a bad taste in your mouth?" aren't just romantic fluff. They’re biting. They’re an interrogation.
The Sound of Soul and Industrial Grit
Musically, the track is a masterclass in restraint. Larry Mullen Jr.’s drumming on this record is famously sparse. He wasn't thrilled with the direction at first, but his steady, unflinching beat provides the anchor for the whole thing. Then there’s Adam Clayton’s bass line. It’s deep, warm, and deceptively simple.
The production by Lanois and Eno is what really elevates it, though. They added these subtle layers of "sonic atmosphere" that make the song feel like it’s breathing. If you listen closely with good headphones, you can hear the textures—the slight hiss, the way the guitar echoes off the studio walls. It doesn’t sound like a polished radio hit from 1991. It sounds like a prayer whispered in a concrete basement.
🔗 Read more: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
The song went through several versions. At one point, it was much more "rock." They stripped that back. They wanted it to hurt. They wanted the listener to feel the space between the notes. That’s why it stands the test of time while other hits from that era sound like dated relics of the early nineties.
The Impact and the Three Music Videos
Usually, a hit song gets one big-budget video. One got three. And they couldn't be more different.
First, there was the Anton Corbijn version. Shot in Berlin, it features the band in drag and Bono’s father. It’s grainy, surreal, and moody. The band actually hated it at first because they thought it was too weird for a lead single.
Then came the "Buffalo" video directed by Mark Pellington. This one is pure art. It’s just footage of buffalos running in slow motion, interspersed with images of the word "One" in multiple languages and shots of sunflowers. It was a tribute to the artist David Wojnarowicz, who was dying of AIDS. It captured the era's grief and the burgeoning activism that would eventually define Bono’s later career.
💡 You might also like: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
Finally, they made a more "traditional" video in a bar (Nell’s in New York) because the label wanted something they could actually play on MTV without confusing everyone. Bono sits at a table, smokes a cigar, and looks directly into the lens. It’s intimate. It’s simple. It worked.
Why It Still Matters Decades Later
You can’t talk about the legacy of U2 without centering on this track. It became the template for their "second act." It proved they could evolve. More importantly, it became a vessel for charity and social change. When the band performed it at the 1992 "Stop Sellafield" concert or later during the PopMart tour, it took on new meanings. It became about the Irish Troubles. It became about the AIDS crisis. It became about debt relief in Africa.
The song has been covered by everyone. Mary J. Blige turned it into a powerhouse R&B anthem. Johnny Cash stripped it down to its barest, most haunting bones on American III: Solitary Man. Even Joe Cocker gave it a go. Each cover proves the same thing: the songwriting is bulletproof. You can change the genre, the tempo, or the singer, and the core truth of the lyrics remains intact.
Technical Breakdown: The Chords of Conflict
If you’re a guitar player, you know the progression. It starts on Am, moves to D, then Fmaj7, and G. It’s a classic downward movement. But it’s the way The Edge uses the "sus" chords and the way he lets the strings ring out that creates that signature shimmer.
- The opening acoustic guitar is dry and close-mic'd.
- The electric overdubs are drenched in a specific type of delay that creates a rhythmic "gallop."
- The solo isn't a show-off moment. It’s melodic. It follows the vocal line.
Actionable Insights for the Modern Listener
To truly appreciate One, you have to stop listening to it as a "greatest hit" on a loop and look at it as a historical artifact.
- Listen to the Johnny Cash version immediately after the original. It highlights the desperation in the lyrics that Bono’s soaring vocals sometimes mask.
- Watch the "Buffalo" video on a large screen. In an age of fast-cut TikTok edits, the slow, meditative pace of that video is a reminder of how visual art used to support music.
- Read about the Hansa Studio sessions. Understanding the friction between the band members makes the harmony of the final track feel like much more of a victory.
Next time you hear it at a wedding, don’t just smile and nod. Think about the fact that you’re listening to a song about the difficulty of loving someone who is fundamentally different from you. It’s a song about the "unbearable lightness" of being in a group. It’s about the fact that we don't have to be the same to work together, but we do have to carry each other. That’s the real legacy of U2’s most famous song. It’s not a celebration of unity; it’s a realistic acknowledgement of the cost of it.