If you think you know the story of The Princess and the Pea, you're probably picturing a delicate, fragile girl who can’t sleep because of a tiny legume. Forget that. Once Upon a Mattress Broadway history is built on the exact opposite of "delicate." It’s loud. It’s brassy. Honestly, it’s a little bit unhinged in the best way possible.
The show first crashed onto the scene in 1959, and it didn't just give us a funny story—it gave us Carol Burnett. Imagine being a casting director and seeing this whirlwind of a woman audition for Princess Winnifred the Woebegone. She didn't just walk on stage; she dominated it. That’s the DNA of this show. It’s a subversion of every "perfect princess" trope you’ve ever been fed.
The Recent Surge in Popularity
Why are we talking about this now? Because the 2024-2025 Broadway season decided it was time to bring the chaos back. Sutton Foster, a literal titan of the stage, stepped into the swampland as Winnifred. This wasn't some stale museum piece. The production, which moved from the New York City Center Encores! series to the Hudson Theatre, proved that audiences are absolutely starving for musical comedy that doesn't take itself too seriously.
People crave joy. Real, messy, physical-comedy-driven joy.
When you look at the landscape of modern theater, everything is so... heavy. We have incredible, soul-crushing dramas and high-concept experimental pieces. But sometimes? You just want to see a princess swim a moat because she’s impatient. You want to see a mute King (Sextimus the Silent) try to explain the "birds and the bees" to his son through frantic pantomime. It’s ridiculous. It works because it’s ridiculous.
Why the "Simple" Plot is Actually Genius
The plot is straightforward. Queen Aggravain is a nightmare mother-in-law who has decreed that no one in the kingdom can get married until her son, Prince Dauntless, finds a "true" princess. The catch? She rigs every test so they fail. Enter Winnifred. She’s not "refined." She’s from the swamps. She’s loud. She’s strong.
Mary Rodgers, the composer (and yes, daughter of the legendary Richard Rodgers), didn't write a "pretty" score. She wrote a funny one. Marshall Barer’s lyrics are sharp, biting, and surprisingly modern for 1959. When Winnifred sings "Shy," it’s an ironic masterpiece because she is the least shy person in the room. She’s practically shouting it.
📖 Related: Dragon Ball All Series: Why We Are Still Obsessed Forty Years Later
The Carol Burnett Legacy vs. Modern Interpretations
You can’t mention Once Upon a Mattress Broadway without acknowledging the shadow Carol Burnett casts. It’s huge. For decades, every actress playing Fred had to decide: do I imitate Carol, or do I do something else?
- Sarah Jessica Parker (1996): She brought a wiry, energetic, almost cartoonish vibe to the role. It was divisive but undeniably her own.
- Sutton Foster (2024): Foster leaned into the athletic, clownish side of the character. She’s a dancer by trade, so her physical comedy is precise. Every trip, every leg kick, every facial contortion is calculated for maximum laughter.
The 2024 revival also updated the book. Amy Sherman-Palladino, the mind behind Gilmore Girls and The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, was brought in to punch up the script. It was a smart move. She kept the heart but sharpened the wit, making the Queen’s overbearing nature feel a bit more like a modern helicopter parent gone wrong.
The Supporting Cast: The Secret Sauce
Everyone focuses on the Princess. Fine. But the show lives or dies by the ensemble and the secondary leads.
The subplot involving Lady Larken and Sir Harry is actually quite scandalous for its time. Larken is pregnant. Out of wedlock. In a "fairy tale" musical from the 50s! That’s why the stakes for finding a princess for Dauntless are so high—if he doesn't marry, they can't marry, and Larken’s reputation is ruined. It adds a layer of desperation that keeps the comedy from feeling too light.
Then there’s the Jester, the Minstrel, and the King. Their trio, "The Very Soft Shoes," is a masterclass in vaudeville-style performance. It’s a breath of fresh air that reminds you Broadway used to be deeply rooted in variety show traditions.
Fact-Checking the "Mattress" Myth
Let's talk about the mattresses. In the original story, there’s one. In the musical, there are twenty.
👉 See also: Down On Me: Why This Janis Joplin Classic Still Hits So Hard
Wait.
Usually, the staging uses a stack of brightly colored mattresses that look like a giant Club Sandwich. In the most recent revival, they played with the scale of the set to make Winnifred look even more overwhelmed by the task. The "test" isn't just about the pea; it’s about the Queen’s psychological warfare. Aggravain spends the whole night making sure there’s noise, lights, and distractions so Winnifred can’t sleep.
The irony? Winnifred doesn't stay awake because she's "delicate." She stays awake because she's counting sheep and the Queen is literally sabotaging her rest.
Production Challenges and Technicalities
Mounting a show like this isn't just about finding a funny lead. The costumes have to be vibrant but movable. Winnifred needs to be able to climb things. The Queen needs a wardrobe that looks like it could kill a man.
In the Hudson Theatre run, the set design was intentionally "storybook-on-acid." It wasn't trying to be realistic. Why would it? It’s a world where a bird can sing a lullaby and a prince can be "Dauntless" but also a total mama’s boy.
Is It "Dated"?
Some critics argue that the gender dynamics in Once Upon a Mattress Broadway are stuck in the past. I’d argue the opposite. Winnifred is a proto-feminist icon. She doesn't change who she is to fit the Prince's expectations. Instead, she changes the kingdom. By the end, Dauntless finally stands up to his mother—not because he found a "perfect" wife, but because he found someone who gave him the courage to be himself.
✨ Don't miss: Doomsday Castle TV Show: Why Brent Sr. and His Kids Actually Built That Fortress
The Queen's silencing of the King is also a fascinating power dynamic. She’s the one with the political power. She’s the one making the laws. In 1959, having a female villain who was the undisputed head of state (and a female protagonist who was a total tomboy) was actually pretty radical.
What Audience Members Should Know Before Going
If you’re catching a local production or hoping for a national tour of the recent revival, keep a few things in mind. This isn't Wicked. It’s not Hamilton. It’s a musical comedy in the purest sense.
- Expect slapstick. If you don't like physical humor, this might not be your jam.
- Listen to the lyrics. The wordplay in "The Queen’s Lament" or "Sensitivity" is incredibly dense and funny.
- Watch the King. Since he can't speak, the actor playing Sextimus has to be one of the best physical performers on the stage.
The Enduring Appeal of "Happily Ever After"
Ultimately, the show works because it’s relatable. Who hasn't felt like an outsider? Who hasn't dealt with a difficult parent or felt like they didn't fit the "standard" of beauty or grace? Winnifred is all of us on our worst hair day, still demanding to be seen and loved.
The music is infectious. "Spanish Panic" is a sequence that, when choreographed well, leaves the audience breathless from laughing. It’s a frantic, nonsensical dance meant to exhaust the Princess, but it usually just ends up exhausting the ensemble in the most entertaining way possible.
Actionable Next Steps for Theater Fans
If you're looking to dive deeper into the world of this musical, don't just stop at the soundtrack.
- Watch the 1964 or 1972 TV Specials: Both star Carol Burnett. The 1972 version is in color and features Bernadette Peters as Lady Larken. It’s a historical document of comedic timing.
- Compare the Cast Recordings: Listen to the 1959 original Broadway cast and then jump to the 2024 New York City Center Encores! recording. You can hear how the orchestration and vocal styles have shifted over sixty years.
- Look for Licensing: If you're involved in community theater or school drama, this is one of the most frequently produced shows for a reason. It has a flexible cast size and roles for every type of performer.
- Check the Hudson Theatre Schedule: If you are in New York or planning a trip, verify the current status of the production or its subsequent tour dates, as Broadway runs for limited engagements often transition to national tours or international stagings.
The story of the princess and the pea might be old, but as long as people keep finding ways to make it loud, messy, and hilarious, Once Upon a Mattress Broadway will never truly go out of style. It's a reminder that being "royal" has nothing to do with how you sit in a chair and everything to do with the strength of your character—even if that strength involves swimming a moat in your good dress.