Internet history is weird. It’s a messy, chaotic archive of things that shouldn't be funny but somehow define an entire generation’s sense of humor. If you were scrolling through your phone around 2014, you likely encountered a six-second clip that felt like a fever dream. A guy walks down a sidewalk, filming himself. He passes a woman talking on her phone. She says, with genuine, hushed intensity, "And they were roommates." The guy turns the camera toward his own shocked face and whispers, "oh my gosh they were roommates."
That’s it. That is the whole thing.
But it didn't just disappear when Vine died in a corporate fire. It stayed. It evolved. It became a cultural shorthand for something much deeper than a random eavesdropped conversation. To understand why this specific phrase still pops up in TikTok comments and Twitter threads today, you have to look at the intersection of accidental comedy and the way the internet handles queer subtext. It isn't just a joke; it's a linguistic tool.
The accidental genius of Matt Post
The creator behind the camera was Matt Post. At the time, he was just another teenager with a smartphone and a penchant for the absurd. He didn't script the woman on the phone. He didn't know her. He just happened to be filming at the exact moment she dropped a piece of information that sounded, to his ears, like the climax of a juicy drama.
The brilliance of the clip is the timing. Comedy often relies on the "rule of three" or elaborate setups, but Vine forced creators to find the "punch" in under seven seconds. Post’s reaction—the wide eyes, the breathless repetition—turned a stranger’s private conversation into a shared public irony. It felt like we were all in on a secret.
Honestly, the "oh my gosh they were roommates" meme succeeded because it captured a universal human experience: hearing just enough of a stranger's conversation to be life-alteringly curious about the context. We never find out who "they" were. We never know why being roommates was so scandalous. The vacuum of information is exactly what allowed the internet to fill in the blanks.
📖 Related: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
Sappho and her friend: The deeper meaning
While the meme started as a simple reaction to a funny moment, it quickly took on a second life within the LGBTQ+ community. There is a long-standing historical phenomenon often referred to as "erasure." For decades—centuries, really—historians and journalists would describe clearly romantic same-sex couples as "very close friends" or, more famously, "roommates."
Think about it. You see a vintage photo of two women who lived together for 50 years, shared a bed, and were buried next to each other, and the caption says they were "devoted companions."
The internet picked up on this.
Suddenly, "oh my gosh they were roommates" wasn't just about a lady on a sidewalk in California. it became a way to poke fun at the refusal of mainstream society to acknowledge queer relationships. If a movie featured two male characters with intense chemistry who lived together but never kissed on screen, the comments section would be flooded with the phrase. It became a sarcastic weapon against "queerbaiting" and historical revisionism.
Digital scholars like those at the Internet Archive or writers for Know Your Meme have noted that this specific crossover—from a random joke to a tool for social commentary—is what gives a meme longevity. It moved from being a soundbite to being a metaphor.
👉 See also: Why La Mera Mera Radio is Actually Dominating Local Airwaves Right Now
Why 2014 was the perfect year for this to explode
Vine was a lightning bottle. Unlike TikTok, which uses sophisticated AI to feed you what you want, Vine was a bit more of a wild west. You followed people, you revined things, and content spread through a sort of digital osmosis.
In 2014, the culture was shifting. We were moving away from the highly produced "YouTube Star" era and into something more raw. We wanted "relatable" content. Matt Post wasn't trying to sell us a lifestyle; he was just a kid walking down the street. That authenticity is why people still quote it. You can't manufacture that kind of "lightning in a bottle" moment in a marketing meeting.
The anatomy of a perfect Vine:
- The Hook: A voice from off-screen creates instant intrigue.
- The Punchline: A reaction that mirrors the audience's feelings.
- The Loop: Because it’s so short, you watch it five times before you even realize it.
- The Sound: It’s "earwormy." The cadence of his voice is musical.
The legacy of a six-second clip
Is it still relevant? Yes. But it’s changed. Nowadays, the phrase is often used as a "post-ironic" joke. People use it to describe things that have nothing to do with roommates at all. It’s become a part of the "Gen Z" and "Millennial" shared vocabulary, a secret handshake that identifies you as someone who "was there."
Matt Post himself has acknowledged the meme's staying power over the years, often with a mix of bewilderment and appreciation. He didn't get rich off it—Vine wasn't great at monetization—but he secured a spot in the digital Hall of Fame.
The interesting thing is how the meme bridges the gap between different corners of the internet. You have the "stan" accounts on Twitter using it to talk about their favorite TV pairings. You have historians using it to talk about the poet Sappho. You have teenagers who weren't even born when Vine launched using the sound on TikTok because it just fits the vibe of a shocking revelation.
✨ Don't miss: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
What we can learn from the "Roommates" phenomenon
If you're trying to understand how digital culture works, this meme is a case study in "organic reach." You can't force something to become a "roommates" level meme. It requires a specific set of circumstances: a genuine moment, a relatable reaction, and a community that finds a way to make the joke their own.
It also highlights the power of the "unsaid." The reason the lady on the phone is so funny is that we don't know the rest of the story. Mystery is a powerful engagement tool. When you leave gaps in a narrative, the audience will fill them with their own creativity, humor, and politics.
Actionable insights for digital creators and observers
If you're looking to understand or leverage this kind of cultural impact, keep these realities in mind:
- Watch the fringes. The best memes don't come from the center of culture; they come from the edges—the random sidewalks, the weird subreddits, the accidental recordings.
- Lean into subtext. People love to feel like they are "in" on a joke. If your content has layers that only a specific community understands, they will be your biggest advocates.
- Keep it brief. The six-second constraint of Vine was a gift. It forced clarity. In a world of short-form video, the "less is more" rule still applies.
- Embrace the evolution. Don't get upset if people use your content in ways you didn't intend. The "roommates" meme became legendary because the LGBTQ+ community repurposed it. That's not a loss of control; it's a gain in relevance.
- Listen to the background noise. Sometimes the most interesting thing in a video isn't the person talking to the camera, but the world happening behind them.
The next time you hear someone whisper those five words, remember that you're not just hearing a quote from a dead app. You're hearing a piece of linguistic history that managed to survive the death of its platform, the change of the guard in social media, and the shift from "random humor" to "socially conscious commentary." It is, quite literally, the little meme that could.