It’s the kind of thing that makes people freeze. Most of the time, when we talk about family, we talk about boundaries that are supposed to be absolute. They’re the bedrock of how we understand society. But then there are the stories that break every single rule. When someone says "my dad and i had sex," the immediate reaction from the public is usually a mix of horror, confusion, and a desperate need to distance themselves from the reality of the situation.
Honestly, it’s complicated. It’s messy.
We often think of these instances as purely predatory, and while many are—and should be treated as crimes—there is a specific, strange phenomenon that psychologists have been studying for decades. It’s called Genetic Sexual Attraction (GSA). It happens. Not often, but enough that there are support groups and clinical papers dedicated to it. This isn't about defending the act; it’s about looking at the raw, uncomfortable mechanics of human psychology and how things can go so sideways when family reunions happen later in life.
The Science of Why This Happens
Why does this happen? Usually, it starts with a long separation. When a parent and child are separated at birth or very early in life, they miss out on the "Westermarck effect." This is a hypothetical psychological effect where people who live in close domestic proximity during the first few years of their lives become desensitized to sexual attraction toward one another. Basically, your brain hardwires a "do not touch" sign on anyone you grew up with.
But take that away? Everything changes.
When people meet as adults for the first time, they often feel an overwhelming sense of familiarity. They look alike. They have the same sense of humor. They might even smell the same due to similar MHC (Major Histocompatibility Complex) genes. Without that childhood "ick" factor baked in by years of shared bathrooms and morning cereal, that intense familiarity can be misinterperted as romantic or sexual attraction.
💡 You might also like: Can DayQuil Be Taken At Night: What Happens If You Skip NyQuil
Breaking Down the Genetic Pull
Dr. Maurice Greenberg, who has done extensive work in this field, noted that the bond between a biological parent and child who meet as adults is incredibly powerful. It’s like a vacuum being filled. You’ve spent years wondering who you are, and suddenly, there is this person who is the mirror image of you.
It’s an identity explosion.
Some people describe it as a "lightning bolt" moment. They feel like they’ve found their soulmate because the person feels so "right." In reality, they are just feeling the intense pull of biological mirroring. But because our culture doesn't talk about GSA, the individuals involved don't have a map for these feelings. They think it's love. They think it’s fate. They don’t realize it’s a glitch in the human bonding software.
The Legal and Social Reality
Let’s be real here: the law doesn't care about your "biological mirroring." In the United States and most of the Western world, incest is a felony. It doesn't matter if it's consensual between two adults. It doesn't matter if there was a 20-year separation.
The legal system is built to protect the family unit and prevent genetic abnormalities in potential offspring. But beyond the courtroom, there’s the social death sentence. Most people who experience this live in total secrecy. They live double lives. They know that if their secret gets out, they lose everything—their jobs, their other family members, and their standing in the community.
📖 Related: Nuts Are Keto Friendly (Usually), But These 3 Mistakes Will Kick You Out Of Ketosis
The Burden of Secrecy
Imagine the weight of that. You’re in a situation that is biologically confusing and legally dangerous. It’s a pressure cooker.
Many people find themselves trapped in these relationships because the person they are with is the only one who "understands" the trauma of their shared past. It’s a recursive loop of trauma and attachment. They are trying to heal a wound from their childhood by using the very person who was absent from it. It almost never ends well.
Misconceptions About Taboo Relationships
People love to simplify things. They want to believe that anyone involved in this is a monster or "crazy."
It’s not that simple.
Often, the individuals involved are struggling with profound mental health issues, including Borderline Personality Disorder or complex PTSD from the initial abandonment. They are searching for a sense of belonging that they never had. When they say "my dad and i had sex," they might be describing a moment where they were trying to reclaim a lost connection, however warped that attempt might be.
👉 See also: That Time a Doctor With Measles Treating Kids Sparked a Massive Health Crisis
- It’s not always about power: While many cases involve grooming, GSA cases between adults are often described as mutually "obsessive."
- The "reunion" phase is high-risk: The first six months of a reunion are the most volatile for these feelings to emerge.
- Education is the only preventative: If people knew GSA existed before they met their biological parents, they could recognize the feelings for what they are—biology, not "romance."
The Path to Recovery and Detachment
Is there a way out? Yes, but it’s incredibly painful. It requires total "no contact" in many cases, which feels like being abandoned all over again.
Therapists who specialize in adoption and reunion trauma emphasize the need for "re-categorization." You have to manually train your brain to see the person as a parent, not a peer. This involves looking at childhood photos (if they exist), talking about the generational gap, and strictly avoiding any romanticized language.
Actionable Steps for Moving Forward
If you or someone you know is navigating the confusing waters of a high-intensity biological reunion, there are specific things that must happen to keep things healthy.
- Seek a "Post-Adoption" Specialist: A regular therapist might be out of their depth. You need someone who understands the specific trauma of adoption and late-discovery kinships.
- Set Hard Boundaries Early: No staying in the same house. No late-night drinking sessions. No "trauma dumping" in the first few weeks. Keep the initial meetings in public, neutral spaces.
- Learn the Westermarck Effect: Knowledge is a shield. If you understand why your brain is sending "attraction" signals, you can label them as "biological confusion" rather than "true love."
- Prioritize Your Legal Safety: Understand that regardless of feelings, the legal consequences are life-altering. Protecting yourself means maintaining the boundaries that society and the law require.
This isn't an easy topic. It’s one of the last great taboos for a reason. But ignoring the psychological reality behind it doesn't make it go away; it just leaves people to navigate a minefield without a map. Understanding the "why" is the first step toward preventing the "what."