It started with a cheeseburger. Specifically, a cheeseburger that a dorky teenager named Ethan Morgan accidentally dropped on a girl’s shoes, setting off a chain of events that led to a feature-length pilot and two seasons of the weirdest, punchiest, and most surprisingly self-aware teen horror-comedy of the early 2010s. If you grew up during the peak of the Twilight craze, you likely remember My Babysitter's a Vampire. It wasn't just another Disney Channel or Teletoon grab for views. It was different.
Most shows for that age group feel like they’re being handled with kid gloves. This one? It had decapitations. It had high schoolers being turned into "fledglings" who craved the blood of their classmates. Honestly, it was a little unhinged for a TV-G/PG rating, and that’s exactly why people are still obsessed with it over a decade after it was canceled.
📖 Related: Searching for TV Shows Like One Tree Hill: Why We’re Still Obsessed With Small Town Drama
The My Babysitter's a Vampire Vibe Check: Why it Worked
When the show first hit screens in 2011, the world was drowning in "sparkly" vampires. We were at peak Team Edward vs. Team Jacob. My Babysitter's a Vampire didn't just lean into the trend; it mocked it relentlessly. The show’s fictional Dusk franchise was a direct, biting parody of Twilight, complete with overly dramatic stares and questionable romance.
The core trio—Ethan, Benny, and Sarah—felt like actual friends you’d meet in a suburban hallway. Ethan (Matthew Knight) was a Seer, Benny (Atticus Mitchell) was a chaotic spellcaster whose Grandma was a literal Earth Priestess, and Sarah (Vanessa Morgan) was the "fledgling" vampire caught in the middle. They weren't "chosen ones" in the traditional, brooding sense. They were just kids trying to survive Whitechapel, a town that apparently had a supernatural body count higher than Sunnydale.
Short sentences matter here. The show was fast. It was loud. It was Canadian.
The humor wasn't forced. Benny Weir, in particular, was the MVP of the series. While most teen leads were busy being "relatable," Benny was busy trying to use magic to impress girls and accidentally turning his grandmother’s garden into a war zone. It felt authentic to how a teenage boy with actual powers would probably act: impulsive, a bit dumb, but ultimately well-intentioned.
The Supernatural Mechanics of Whitechapel
What most people forget about the My Babysitter's a Vampire TV show is how deep the lore actually went. This wasn't just "vampire of the week." You had a hierarchy of bloodsuckers. You had "The Council." You had the Lucifractor, a physical object that could literally vaporize vampires.
The writers, including creators Tom McGillis and Jennifer Pertsch (the minds behind Total Drama Island), understood that horror works best when there are rules. Sarah wasn't a full vampire because she hadn't tasted human blood. That was the ticking clock of the entire first season. If she bit a human, her soul was gone. That’s heavy stuff for a Saturday morning lineup.
- Vampires: They didn't sparkle. They burned. They had "vamp-vision" that looked like a thermal camera gone wrong.
- Seers: Ethan’s visions were triggered by touch, a mechanic that allowed the plot to move at a breakneck pace.
- Spellcasters: Benny’s magic was chaotic. It usually backfired. This provided the "comedy" in the horror-comedy equation.
The show managed to balance the "monster of the week" format with a serialized plot that felt like it was actually going somewhere. One week you’re dealing with a possessed doll, the next you’re fighting an ancient Mayan apocalypse. It was ambitious.
What Really Happened to Season 3?
This is the part that still stings for the fandom. If you go on any YouTube comment section or Reddit thread about the show today, the first question is always: "Where is Season 3?"
The Season 2 finale, "The Date to End All Dates," wasn't just a cliffhanger. It was a literal explosion. The Council chamber blew up. Jesse, the villain-turned-maybe-antihero, was back. Ethan and his friends were scattered. And then... nothing. Silence for over ten years.
Basically, the show was a co-production between Teletoon in Canada and Disney Channel in the US. While it was a massive hit on both, the logistics of international TV production in 2012 were a nightmare. Vanessa Morgan (who later went on to star in Riverdale) and the rest of the cast started aging out of their roles. There were rumors of a second movie that would wrap things up, but the scripts reportedly fell through or were absorbed into other projects.
It’s a classic case of a show being too successful for its own good but not "global phenomenon" enough to survive the shifting priorities of two different networks. Fans even started petitions that gained tens of thousands of signatures, but by 2014, the cast had moved on.
The Vanessa Morgan Effect and the Cast Today
It’s wild to look back at the My Babysitter's a Vampire TV show and realize how much of a springboard it was. Vanessa Morgan is a household name now, but back then, she was just the girl trying not to eat her best friend.
Matthew Knight (Ethan) essentially retired from acting shortly after the show ended, which adds to the "time capsule" feel of the series. He was the perfect "everyman" lead. Atticus Mitchell (Benny) has popped up in projects like Fargo and The Expanse, proving that the comedic timing he polished on the show was the real deal.
The chemistry between these three was the "secret sauce." You can’t fake that kind of rapport. In an era where most teen shows are cast based on Instagram followers, there was something refreshing about a group of kids who looked like they actually spent their weekends playing video games in a basement.
Why We’re Still Talking About It in 2026
Nostalgia is a hell of a drug, but it's not the only reason this show survives. It’s the "comfort food" aspect.
The show didn't take itself too seriously. In a world where every supernatural show now has to be "gritty" and "dark" (looking at you, Riverdale), My Babysitter's a Vampire was just... fun. It knew it was a show about a babysitter who was a vampire. It didn't try to be The English Patient.
The practical effects were often better than they had any right to be. The makeup for the vampires when they "vamped out"—the yellow eyes, the elongated faces—was genuinely creepy. It didn't rely entirely on shaky CGI. There was a tactile feel to the show that grounded the absurd premises.
How to Revisit the Series Right Now
If you’re looking to scratch that 2011 itch, there are a few things you should do to get the full experience. Don't just jump into the episodes.
- Watch the movie first. People often forget that the series was preceded by a 2010 TV movie. If you start with Season 1, Episode 1, you’re going to be very confused about why everyone is already friends with a vampire.
- Track down the "Behind the Scenes" shorts. There was a lot of web-only content back in the day that showed the cast's real-life friendship, which makes the show even better.
- Pay attention to the background gags. The school, Whitechapel High, is littered with references to other horror tropes and Canadian inside jokes.
The legacy of the show lives on in the "supernatural teen" genre, but nothing has quite captured that specific blend of Canadian snark and legitimate horror since. It remains a high-water mark for that specific era of television.
Next Steps for the Fandom:
To truly appreciate the series today, look for the official soundtracks. The theme song "Girl Next Door" is a quintessential piece of early 2010s pop-rock that perfectly captures the show's energy. Additionally, checking out Vanessa Morgan's more recent interviews often yields small nuggets of behind-the-scenes trivia that weren't public back when the show was airing. While a reboot seems unlikely given the time gap, the original 26 episodes and the pilot movie remain a perfectly preserved slice of supernatural history.