Honestly, the elevator pitch for Murdered Soul Suspect is one of the coolest things I’ve ever heard. You play as a detective. You get murdered in the first five minutes. Then, you have to solve your own homicide as a ghost. It sounds like a slam dunk, right? It’s basically Ghost meets L.A. Noire, but with more fedoras and a lot more tattoos.
When Airtight Games released this back in 2014, people didn't really know what to do with it. Critics kind of shredded it. It currently sits with a Metacritic score in the high 50s or low 60s depending on the platform. But here’s the thing: despite the clunky combat and the somewhat linear world, there is a cult following for this game that refuses to let it die.
The Salem Vibe is Unmatched
The game takes place in Salem, Massachusetts. If you’re going to make a game about ghosts and historical trauma, you pick Salem. It's a no-brainer. The developers did a fantastic job of layering the "ghost world" over the real world. You see these shimmering, blueish remnants of old buildings—gallows, horse carriages, and walls from the 1600s—intersecting with modern-day apartments and streets.
It creates this sense of "Dusk," a purgatory where the past refuses to stay buried. You aren't just walking through a town; you’re walking through layers of time. You can’t walk through "consecrated" walls, which is a clever, if slightly annoying, way the game keeps you from just flying everywhere. It makes the world feel solid even though you're literally transparent.
Ronan O'Connor: The Dead Man with a Past
Our protagonist is Ronan O'Connor. He’s a guy with a "checkered past," which is video game shorthand for "he has a lot of tattoos and used to be a criminal." Every tattoo on his body represents a life event, which you can actually inspect in the menu. It's a neat bit of character building.
When the Bell Killer—the game’s hooded antagonist—throws Ronan out of a window and shoots him with his own gun, Ronan doesn't just pass on. He's stuck. He meets the ghost of his late wife, Julia, who tells him he can't move on until he finishes his business. This sets up the central mystery. Who is the Bell Killer? Why is he targeting people in Salem? And what does it have to do with the historical witch trials?
How You Actually "Investigate"
Investigation in Murdered Soul Suspect is different from your typical detective game. Since you can't pick up physical evidence, you have to "influence" the living.
✨ Don't miss: Mass Effect Andromeda Gameplay: Why It’s Actually the Best Combat in the Series
You can possess people.
Not in a shove-them-off-a-cliff way, but in a read-their-thoughts way. You can peek at their notebooks through their eyes or "trigger" a memory by pointing at a specific object in the room. It’s a bit simplistic by today’s standards. You basically find a handful of clues in a room, then press a button to "conclude" and pick the three clues that actually matter. If you get it wrong, Ronan just sighs and you try again. There’s no real penalty for being a bad detective, which is one of the game's bigger flaws.
But the writing carries it. The internal monologues and the snippets of conversation you overhear from the living residents of Salem are genuinely well-done. You feel like a fly on the wall in a town that is grieving and terrified.
The Demon Problem
We have to talk about the demons. This is the part of Murdered Soul Suspect that everyone—and I mean everyone—hates.
To add "stealth" and "tension" to the game, Airtight Games added these shrieking, orange-glowing demons that patrol certain hallways. They are the absolute worst. They don't add anything to the mystery. They just force you to hide in "soul residues" (conveniently placed ghost clouds) and wait for them to turn around so you can teleport behind them and "execute" them.
It feels like a mechanic from a completely different game that was forced in because someone at the publisher thought a game without combat wouldn't sell. If you’re playing this today, just know that these segments are short. Don't let them stop you from seeing the story through.
🔗 Read more: Marvel Rivals Emma Frost X Revolution Skin: What Most People Get Wrong
Why It Failed (And Why It’s Still Worth It)
Airtight Games actually closed its doors just weeks after Murdered Soul Suspect launched. That’s the tragic reality of the mid-tier "AA" game market. It wasn't a massive blockbuster like Call of Duty, and it wasn't a tiny indie darling. It was stuck in the middle.
The game was also caught between console generations. It launched on PS3/Xbox 360 and PS4/Xbox One simultaneously. This meant the graphics weren't quite "next-gen" enough for 2014, and the performance on the older consoles was a bit choppy.
But looking back, the game’s focus on a singular, narrative-driven mystery is refreshing. In an era where every game is a 100-hour open-world RPG with 4,000 map markers, a tight 8-hour ghost story is actually kind of a relief.
The Bell Killer Twist
Without spoiling the ending, the resolution to the Bell Killer mystery is actually pretty smart. It ties the modern murders back to the historical 1692 trials in a way that feels earned. It deals with themes of generational trauma and the way history repeats itself.
The game handles the "medium" character, Joy, really well too. She’s a teenager who can see Ronan, and their relationship evolves from mutual annoyance to a genuine partnership. She provides the "physical" interaction Ronan lacks, and he provides the protection she needs from the living and the dead.
Is it Factually Accurate to Salem?
The game takes massive liberties with the layout of Salem, but the "feel" is right. They reference real historical elements, like the Old Burying Point cemetery and the concept of "spectral evidence"—which was a real legal term used during the witch trials where a witness claimed a person’s spirit attacked them.
💡 You might also like: Finding the Right Words That Start With Oc 5 Letters for Your Next Wordle Win
It’s this grounding in real-world occult history that makes the supernatural elements feel more "authentic" than your average horror game.
Technical Performance in 2026
If you’re picking this up on Steam or modern consoles today, it runs like a dream. The stylized art direction—lots of shadows, heavy fog, and glowing effects—has actually aged better than games that tried for hyper-realism in 2014. You can usually find it on sale for about $2.00. For two bucks, it is a steal.
What to Do If You Want to Play
If you're going to dive into Murdered Soul Suspect, here’s how to get the most out of it:
- Ignore the demons. Seriously. Just stealth past them as fast as possible. Don't try to make it a combat game.
- Read the collectibles. Most games have boring collectibles. In this game, finding the "Ghost Stories" unlocks fully narrated short stories about other spirits in Salem. They are genuinely creepy and better than the main plot sometimes.
- Talk to every ghost. There are dozens of NPCs standing around Salem with their own "unfinished business." Some are funny, some are heartbreaking (like the guy who doesn't realize he's dead and is still waiting for his date).
- Play it in the dark. The atmosphere is the game's strongest suit.
Murdered Soul Suspect is a flawed gem. It’s a reminder of a time when developers were allowed to take weird risks on high-concept ideas. It isn't perfect, but it's memorable. And in a sea of generic sequels, "memorable" counts for a lot.
Check the digital storefronts on PlayStation, Xbox, or Steam. Because of its age, it is frequently discounted by 90%. Grab it when it's cheap, clear an afternoon, and solve your own murder. It’s a weirdly satisfying way to spend a weekend.