He’s the guy with the blue stripes and the bumbling attitude. You know the one. While Captain Hook is busy monologuing about "good form" or dodging a clock-eating crocodile, Mr Smee is usually in the background, polishing a hook or accidentally thumping a pirate over the head with a shovel. Most people just see him as the comic relief. But if you actually look at the history of J.M. Barrie’s work, Smee is a weird, walking contradiction that shouldn't work, yet he’s the only reason the Jolly Roger functions at all.
Honestly, Smee is the glue.
Without him, Hook would have imploded decades ago. In the original 1904 play and the 1911 novel Peter and Wendy, Smee isn't just a sidekick; he’s the crew’s bo’sun (boatswain). He’s the only pirate the Lost Boys don't immediately fear. Why? Because he’s "pathetically innocent." Imagine a man who stabs people but does it with such a gentle, grandmotherly vibe that you almost forget he’s a high-seas criminal. That’s the Smee magic.
The Weird Duality of Mr Smee in Peter Pan
Most villains have a "right-hand man" who is just a smaller, meaner version of themselves. Think of Disney's Gaston and LeFou. But J.M. Barrie did something way more interesting with Mr Smee. He’s described as being Irish—which was a specific character choice by Barrie—and he has this bizarrely peaceful temperament.
He’s a man who loves his mother. He dreams of open-air markets and sewing. In the book, he’s the only pirate who survives the final slaughter because he’s too likable to kill. Think about that for a second. Peter Pan and the Lost Boys are literally gutting the pirate crew, but they look at Smee and basically go, "Nah, he’s alright." He ends up wandering the world, selling spectacles and claiming he’s the only man James Hook ever feared.
It’s a lie, of course. But it’s a great one.
The 1953 Disney version changed the vibe a bit. They turned him into a short, stout man with white hair and a pink nose, voiced by Bill Thompson. This version of Mr Smee is much more of a "bumbling uncle" figure. He’s the one who tries to give Hook a shave while a giant crocodile is ticking under the window. The physical comedy there is gold, but it hides a darker truth about the character's loyalty. Smee is loyal to a fault. He sees Hook not as a terrifying dictator, but as a big, dramatic baby who needs constant supervision.
Why Smee is the "Nice" Pirate
You’ve probably wondered why Smee is even a pirate. He doesn't seem to have a mean bone in his body. In the literary world, Smee represents a specific type of "banality of evil." He’s not a pirate because he wants to hurt people; he’s a pirate because that’s just his job. He’s a follower.
👉 See also: Christopher McDonald in Lemonade Mouth: Why This Villain Still Works
Barrie writes that Smee thought he was "pathetic," and that was his greatest charm. He would stab you, but he'd feel bad about your shirt getting ruined.
- The Spectacles: In the original text, Smee’s spectacles are a huge deal. He believes they make him look intellectual.
- The Sewing Machine: In some stage versions, Smee is obsessed with his sewing machine. It’s his prized possession.
- The Mother Complex: Smee is the only pirate who openly talks about his mother, which creates a weird foil to the Lost Boys who are desperate for a mother figure (Wendy).
From Stage to Screen: The Evolution of a Sidekick
The way we see Mr Smee today is almost entirely filtered through the lens of Disney and Steven Spielberg’s Hook. In the 1991 film Hook, Bob Hoskins gave us what many consider the definitive Smee. He was manipulative. He was a sycophant. He was also weirdly the smartest person on the island.
Hoskins played Smee as the guy who actually runs the show while letting Hook take the credit. There’s that famous scene where he tries to "suicide" himself (but not really) just to get Hook’s attention. It’s dark. It’s funny. It’s also incredibly human. It shows that Smee’s loyalty isn't just about fear—it’s a codependent relationship. Hook needs Smee to feel important, and Smee needs Hook to have a purpose.
Then you have the more recent versions.
In Peter Pan & Wendy (2023), Jim Gaffigan took a crack at the role. He brought a dry, deadpan energy to it. It was less about the slapstick and more about the exhaustion of being a pirate for a hundred years. When you've been chasing a flying kid for a century, you’re going to be a little tired. Gaffigan’s Smee feels like a man who just wants a nap and maybe a nice cup of tea, but he’s stuck on a boat with a bunch of ego-maniacs.
The Voice Behind the Stripes
If you grew up with the 1953 cartoon, that voice is burned into your brain. Bill Thompson didn't just voice Smee; he voiced the White Rabbit in Alice in Wonderland and Droopy Dog. He had this way of making characters sound like they were perpetually out of breath and slightly confused.
That specific vocal performance defined the "Standard Smee" for seventy years. It’s why every time you see a Smee at a Disney park or in a video game like Kingdom Hearts, he sounds exactly the same. He’s perpetually flustered.
✨ Don't miss: Christian Bale as Bruce Wayne: Why His Performance Still Holds Up in 2026
Misconceptions About the Bo'sun
People think Smee is stupid. He isn't.
In the original play, Smee is actually quite craftly. He’s the one who realizes that they can use the "Never Bird’s" nest. He understands the mechanics of the ship. He’s a skilled craftsman. The "dumb" persona is often a survival tactic. In a crew of cutthroats, being the "harmless old man" is the safest position to be in. Nobody sees you as a threat, so nobody tries to overthrow you.
Another big misconception? That he’s just a Disney invention.
Nope. Smee was right there in 1904. In fact, Barrie spent a lot of time on Smee’s internal monologue in the book. He describes Smee as a man who "meant no harm." To Barrie, the idea of a "lovable" pirate was the ultimate irony. It makes the world of Neverland feel more grounded and, honestly, more unsettling.
The Enduring Legacy of the Blue-Striped Shirt
Why do we still care about Mr Smee?
Maybe it’s because he’s the most relatable person in Neverland. We aren't all brave like Peter or obsessed with legacy like Hook. Most of us are just trying to do our jobs, keep our bosses happy, and not get eaten by a crocodile. Smee is the everyman. He’s the guy who brings a bit of domesticity to a land of eternal war.
He’s also a cosplay icon. If you go to any comic convention or Disney-bound meetup, you’ll see dozens of Smees. It’s the easiest costume in the world: a red beanie, blue-and-white striped shirt, and some spectacles. But it’s more than that. People love him because he represents the side of us that just wants to get along with everyone.
🔗 Read more: Chris Robinson and The Bold and the Beautiful: What Really Happened to Jack Hamilton
What You Can Learn from Mr Smee
If you’re looking for "actionable insights" from a fictional pirate sidekick, look at his longevity. Smee survives because he is adaptable. He doesn't let his ego get in the way of his survival. While Hook is literally defined by his inability to let go of his grudge against Peter, Smee is perfectly happy to pivot.
- Be Essential: Smee is the only one who knows where everything is on the Jolly Roger. Be the person people can't afford to lose.
- Manage Up: Smee knows exactly how to handle Hook’s tantrums. Learning how to manage a difficult "boss" is a life skill.
- Keep Your Hobbies: Whether it’s sewing or selling spectacles, Smee has a life outside of being a pirate. Don't let your job be your entire identity.
Next time you watch Peter Pan, don't just focus on the sword fights. Look at the guy in the background with the glass-polishing cloth. He’s the one who’s actually going to make it home in the end.
To really understand the nuance of these characters, you have to go back to the source material. Read the 1911 novel Peter and Wendy. You’ll find a version of Smee that is much weirder, darker, and more endearing than any movie has ever managed to capture. He’s not just a sidekick; he’s the heart of the Jolly Roger, even if that heart is a little bit tarnished.
Check out the original stage play notes if you can find them in a library archive. Barrie's stage directions for Smee are legendary among theater geeks for how much they emphasize his "unconscious" nature. He is a man moving through a nightmare with a smile on his face. That’s not just a character; that’s a mood.
Practical Next Steps
If you're a fan of the lore or looking to dive deeper into the world of Neverland, your best bet is to compare the different iterations of the character. Start by watching the 1953 Disney classic to get the archetype down, then immediately jump to Bob Hoskins in Hook to see the character given real psychological depth. Finally, read the final chapter of J.M. Barrie's Peter and Wendy to see where Smee actually ends up—it’s not where you’d expect. He doesn't go down with the ship; he finds a way to thrive in the "real world," which is the most Smee thing possible.