There is no crying in baseball. We all know the line. It’s ingrained in the cultural DNA of anyone who grew up watching Penny Marshall’s 1992 masterpiece. But honestly, finding movies like A League of Their Own is surprisingly difficult because that film captured a very specific lightning in a bottle. It wasn’t just a "sports movie." It was a period piece, a comedy, a sisterhood drama, and a bittersweet look at how society treats women when the men come back from war.
Most sports movies are about the "big game." They follow a rigid structure of the underdog finding a coach, hitting a slump, and then winning the championship in slow motion. A League of Their Own did something different. It focused on the cost of excellence and the fleeting nature of opportunity. When Dottie Hinson leaves at the end, it’s not a purely "happy" ending—it’s complicated. That nuance is exactly what makes the search for similar films so rewarding yet frustrating.
The DNA of the Female Sports Dramedy
To find a movie that actually feels like the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League (AAGPBL) story, you have to look for three specific ingredients: high-stakes competition, genuine female friendship that isn’t about fighting over a man, and a sense of historical or social weight.
Take Bend It Like Beckham (2002). On the surface, it’s about soccer. But dig deeper. It’s actually about the friction between cultural tradition and individual ambition. Parminder Nagra’s Jesminder and Keira Knightley’s Jules share that same "we’re doing this even if nobody wants us to" energy that Geena Davis and Lori Petty brought to the Peaches. It’s funny, it’s heartfelt, and it treats the sport with actual respect. The soccer scenes aren't just filler; they are the language the characters use to express themselves.
Then there’s GLOW. Yeah, I know it’s a TV show, but if we are talking about the "vibe" of A League of Their Own, nothing comes closer. It features a ragtag group of women in the 1980s wrestling scene, navigating a world run by cynical men while finding their own power. It captures that specific ensemble magic where every character, even the ones in the background, feels like a real person with a mortgage and a messy dating life.
👉 See also: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Hidden Gems and the "Second Tier" Favorites
If you want something that leans harder into the "period piece" aspect, Hidden Figures (2016) is a mandatory watch. It isn't a sports movie, obviously. But the structural beats are identical. You have women who are the absolute best at what they do, working in an environment that is designed to ignore them. Watching Katherine Johnson (Taraji P. Henson) calculate orbital trajectories is just as thrilling as a home run at Baker Bowl. Both films deal with the "invisible" history of the mid-20th century.
Why Battle of the Sexes (2017) Works
Emma Stone as Billie Jean King is a revelation here. This movie is the spiritual successor to the Peaches' story because it deals directly with the politics of being a female athlete. The 1973 match between King and Bobby Riggs wasn't just tennis; it was a referendum on gender. Like A League of Their Own, it balances the "showmanship" of the sport with the private, often lonely reality of the athletes. Steve Carell plays Riggs with a buffoonish charm that keeps it from getting too heavy, much like Tom Hanks’ Jimmy Dugan.
The Underdogs: Whip It and Stick It
For a more modern, rebellious take, Whip It (2009) directed by Drew Barrymore is the move. Roller derby is the backdrop, but the heart of the film is Ellen Page (now Elliot Page) finding a community of "misfit" women. It’s got that gritty, sweaty, DIY feel.
And don't sleep on Stick It (2006). People dismiss it as a teen gymnastics flick, but the writing is sharp, cynical, and actually quite radical in how it critiques the judging systems of competitive sports. It’s a movie about athletes who decide to play the game on their own terms, which is exactly what Dottie and Kit were doing in 1943.
✨ Don't miss: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
The Problem with Modern Sports Movies
The reason many modern movies like A League of Their Own fail to land is that they try too hard to be "inspiring."
The 1992 film wasn't trying to be an after-school special. It was gritty. The players had bruises the size of dinner plates from sliding into bases in skirts. They dealt with sexism that wasn't just a "bad guy" to overcome, but a persistent, exhausting background noise.
When you watch something like The Bad News Bears (the 1976 original, not the remake), you get that same raw, unpolished look at the game. It’s dirty, people swear, and the kids aren’t perfect. While it’s about a Little League team, the DNA of the "disruptive coach" and the "unlikely champions" is shared directly with the Peaches. Walter Matthau is essentially the blueprint for the drunken, reluctant manager that Tom Hanks later perfected.
Understanding the Real History (E-E-A-T Insights)
If you're a fan of the film, you probably know it was based on a real league founded by Philip K. Wrigley. But the movie simplifies things. In reality, the league lasted until 1954. The players had to attend charm school—that part was real. They had to wear lipstick on the field. They had to follow strict "femininity" rules or face fines.
🔗 Read more: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
The real-life Dottie Kamenshek (whom the character of Dottie Hinson is partially based on) was so good that a Triple-A men's team once tried to buy her contract. She turned them down because she thought it was a publicity stunt. This level of elite talent is often downplayed in cinema, but A League of Their Own managed to show that these women weren't just "good for girls"—they were world-class ballplayers.
When looking for films in this niche, you have to look for that respect for the craft. Million Dollar Baby (2004) has it, though it’s far darker. Chariots of Fire (1981) has it, even though it’s about men. It’s that obsession with the "purity" of the sport versus the "noise" of the world.
Why We Still Watch
We watch these movies because they remind us that talent exists everywhere, even when the world refuses to look for it. Whether it's the Rockford Peaches or the high schoolers in Bring It On (which, honestly, is a legitimate sports movie about cultural appropriation and technical skill), the core theme remains the same: the game doesn't care who you are. The ball doesn't know your gender.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans
If you've exhausted the list of movies like A League of Their Own, here is how to broaden your horizons without losing that specific feeling:
- Check out the 2022 Amazon Series: It’s also called A League of Their Own, but it’s not a remake. It’s a "reimagining" that explores the stories the 1992 film couldn't, specifically regarding Black women who weren't allowed in the AAGPBL and the queer history of the league. It stars Abbi Jacobson and is genuinely fantastic.
- Watch Documentaries: If you want the real grit, find A League of Their Own (1987), the documentary by Kim Wilson that inspired Penny Marshall in the first place. Seeing the real women, then in their 60s and 70s, talk about their playing days is more emotional than any scripted drama.
- Look into the "Ensemble Comedy" Genre: Sometimes the "sports" part is secondary. Films like Waiting for Guffman or Best in Show capture that "group of weirdos working toward a goal" energy better than many actual sports movies.
- Support Local Women's Sports: The best way to keep the spirit of the Peaches alive isn't just watching movies. Check out a local NWSL (National Women's Soccer League) game or a PWHL (Professional Women's Hockey League) match. The drama on those fields is often better than anything Hollywood can write.
The "sports movie" isn't dead; it's just evolving. We're moving away from the era of the "lone hero" and back toward the ensemble stories that celebrate the collective struggle. That’s where the real magic of the 1943 Peaches lives on. Go find it.