Stop trying. Seriously. If you’re a manager, a coach, or a parent currently banging your head against the wall because your "inspiring" speeches are met with blank stares, there’s a reason for that. You’re fighting a losing battle against human biology and psychology. Most leadership seminars and "hustle culture" influencers have been selling us a lie for decades. They treat motivation like a gas tank you can fill up for someone else. But humans aren't cars.
The reality is that why motivating people doesn't work comes down to the fundamental difference between pushing someone and creating an environment where they want to move themselves.
Think about the last time someone tried to "pump you up." Maybe it was a mandatory corporate retreat with a high-energy speaker or a pep talk from a boss who uses too many sports metaphors. You might feel a temporary jingle of excitement. It’s a dopamine spike. But by Tuesday morning, that feeling is gone, replaced by the same old inertia. You can't "motivate" another person any more than you can "grow" a plant by pulling on its leaves.
The Science of Why You're Doing it Wrong
Edward Deci and Richard Ryan, two psychologists from the University of Rochester, spent years developing what we now call Self-Determination Theory (SDT). Their research basically nuked the old-school idea of "carrots and sticks." They found that when you try to motivate someone using external rewards—like bonuses, gold stars, or even the threat of a Performance Improvement Plan—you actually undermine their natural drive.
It's called the overjustification effect.
If I love painting, and you start paying me $50 for every canvas I finish, I eventually stop painting because I love it. I start painting for the fifty bucks. My "internal" engine gets replaced by your "external" one. Once you stop paying, I stop painting. You've effectively broken my natural curiosity.
This happens in offices every single day. We wonder why employees "lack initiative" after we’ve spent years training them to only move when there’s a financial incentive or a deadline looming over their heads.
The Autonomy Gap
People don't want to be managed. They want to be led, sure, but mostly they want to be trusted. When you try to "motivate" someone, you are often subtly (or not-so-subtly) telling them that their current effort isn't good enough. It feels like control. And humans, by nature, resist control.
Psychological reactance is a real thing. It’s that visceral "No" you feel when someone tells you what to do, even if you were already planning on doing it. By trying to force motivation, you trigger this resistance. You create a power struggle instead of a partnership.
Susan Fowler, author of Why Motivating People Doesn't Work... and What Does, argues that people are always motivated. They just might not be motivated by your goals. A "lazy" employee is actually highly motivated to protect their peace or avoid a task they find meaningless. The trick isn't to give them motivation; it's to help them find the "why" that already exists within them.
The Three Nutrients of High Performance
If we accept that traditional motivation is a bust, what actually works? According to the SDT framework, humans need three basic psychological nutrients to thrive. Without these, no amount of "Monday Morning Motivation" emails will matter.
Autonomy is the big one. It’s the need to be the agent of one's own life. At Atlassian, they famously tried "FedEx Days"—24 hours where developers could work on anything they wanted, as long as they delivered something overnight. The result? Huge bursts of innovation that regular "motivated" work hours never produced. When people have a say in how they do their work, they don't need a cheerleader.
Competence matters just as much. Nobody likes doing something they’re bad at. If a task is too hard, we get anxious. If it's too easy, we get bored. High-performing environments find that "Goldilocks" zone of challenge. It’s about mastery. We are wired to enjoy the feeling of getting better at stuff.
Relatedness is the final piece. We need to feel connected to others and to a purpose. If I’m just a cog in a machine, I’m going to do the bare minimum. But if I feel like my work helps my teammate Sarah, or makes a customer’s life slightly less annoying, I’m far more likely to engage.
The "Incentive" Trap
Let's talk about money. Everyone thinks more money is the answer. It isn't.
In a famous study by Dan Ariely, people were asked to perform tasks that required even a tiny bit of cognitive skill. Those offered the highest financial rewards actually performed the worst. Why? Because the pressure of the reward created "choking" anxiety.
Money is a "hygiene factor," a term coined by Frederick Herzberg. If you don't pay people enough, they will be de-motivated. But once you pay them enough to take the issue of money off the table, adding more cash doesn't magically make them more creative or committed. It just makes them more focused on the cash.
Why Your "Vision" Isn't Landing
Most leaders think they need to provide the vision. They stand at the front of the room and paint a picture of the future. But if the team didn't help paint it, they don't own it.
Real engagement—which is what people actually mean when they talk about motivation—is a bottom-up process. It’s about asking questions instead of giving answers.
Instead of: "We need to hit these numbers to be #1 in the market!"
Try: "What’s the most frustrating part of your job right now, and how can we fix it so you can actually do the work you’re good at?"
The first one is a "push." The second one is a "pull."
Stop Being a Cheerleader and Start Being an Architect
If you want a high-performing team, stop trying to change the people. Change the environment.
You can't talk someone into being passionate. You can, however, remove the bureaucratic nonsense that is killing their passion. You can give them better tools. You can give them more time to focus. You can stop micromanaging their lunch breaks.
Think of it like a garden. A gardener doesn't grow the tomatoes. The tomato plant knows how to grow. The gardener just makes sure the soil is nutrient-rich, the weeds are pulled, and there’s enough water.
Actionable Steps for Real Engagement
If you're ready to stop the "motivation" charade, here is how you actually move the needle. These aren't quick fixes; they are shifts in how you interact with the people around you.
1. Conduct "Stay Interviews"
Don't wait for an exit interview to find out why someone is unhappy. Ask your best people right now: "What keeps you here? What would make you leave? What parts of your job feel like a waste of time?" This builds relatedness and shows you value their autonomy.
2. Audit Your Choice Architecture
Look at the tasks you assign. How much "how" are you dictating? Try giving a clear "what" (the outcome) and letting the individual decide the "how" (the process). If you can't trust them to do that, you have a hiring problem or a training problem, not a motivation problem.
3. Kill the Annual Review
The annual performance review is the ultimate "carrot and stick" relic. It creates fear and defensiveness. Move to "check-ins" focused on growth and competence. Ask, "What skills do you want to learn next?" and "How can I help you get there?"
4. Connect the Dots to Real People
Stop talking about "shareholder value" or "Q4 targets." Those are abstractions. Share a letter from a customer who was helped. Bring in a person from a different department to explain how your team’s data helped them finish a project. Make the work human.
5. Focus on Progress, Not Just Results
Teresa Amabile’s research on the "Progress Principle" shows that the single most important thing that boosts "inner work life" is making progress in meaningful work. Celebrate the small wins. Clear the roadblocks that prevent people from finishing things.
The Nuance of Resilience
Is there a place for a pep talk? Sure. In the heat of a crisis or the final minutes of a game, a burst of external energy can help. But that’s "state" motivation—it’s temporary. It’s a shot of adrenaline.
For the long haul—the "trait" motivation that sustains a career or a long-term project—external "pumping up" is useless. In fact, it's often counterproductive because it creates a dependency. People start waiting for the "push" before they start moving.
📖 Related: Clay Johnson the Closer: Why This Real Estate Pro Is All Over Your Feed
The most "motivated" people I know are actually just people with very clear values and very few obstacles in their way. They aren't being cheered on by a boss. They are being pulled forward by a sense of purpose and the freedom to pursue it.
Moving Forward
If you want to see a change in your team or yourself, stop looking for the right words to say. Start looking at the system. Look at the "soil."
- Remove the de-motivators: Is there a toxic person in the group? Is there a process that takes five hours but should take ten minutes?
- Increase transparency: People feel more autonomous when they understand the "why" behind a decision, even if they don't agree with it.
- Prioritize learning over performing: When a mistake happens, is the first reaction "Who did this?" or "What can we learn?"
True drive is an inside job. You can't install it. You can only invite it out. Stop trying to motivate, and start trying to understand. That is where the real performance lives.