You’re eating everything in sight. Or at least, you think you are. You’ve probably heard the classic advice: "just eat a peanut butter sandwich before bed" or "drink a gallon of milk a day." Honestly, most of that advice is garbage. If you’re a "hardgainer," your body is basically a furnace that incinerates calories before they can ever turn into muscle or even a little bit of healthy fat. It’s frustrating. You look in the mirror and see the same lanky frame despite hitting the gym three times a week.
The truth about how to gain weight for guys isn't just about "eating more." It’s about biological math and hormonal signaling.
Most guys fail because they overestimate their intake. Research published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition consistently shows that people are terrible at tracking what they actually eat. You might have a massive 1,200-calorie dinner, feel stuffed, and then realize you skipped breakfast and had a tiny salad for lunch. You ended the day at a deficit. That's why you aren't growing.
The Caloric Surplus Myth vs. Reality
You need a surplus. Period. But how much?
If you jump straight into a 1,000-calorie surplus, you’re just going to get soft and lethargic. You want quality weight. This is where the "clean bulk" vs. "dirty bulk" debate gets messy. A dirty bulk—eating pizza and ice cream to hit your numbers—works for weight, but it feels like hell. Your skin breaks out. Your energy levels crater.
A smarter approach is the "lean gain" method. Aim for about 300 to 500 calories above your Total Daily Energy Expenditure (TDEE).
Calculating your TDEE is a bit of a guess, though. You can use the Mifflin-St Jeer equation, but even that is just a starting point. If you’re active—maybe you play pickup basketball or have a job where you’re on your feet—your "maintenance" might be way higher than an online calculator suggests.
Why Liquid Calories are Your Best Friend
Chewing is work. Seriously.
When you’re trying to hit 3,500 calories a day with chicken, rice, and broccoli, you’re going to hit a wall of "gastric bypass" signals. Your brain tells you you’re full long before you’ve hit your macros. This is where shakes come in. But don't buy those overpriced "Mass Gainer" buckets filled with maltodextrin and filler sugars. They make you bloat.
Make your own. Throw this in a blender:
✨ Don't miss: Horizon Treadmill 7.0 AT: What Most People Get Wrong
- Two cups of whole milk (or oat milk if dairy messes with your stomach)
- Two tablespoons of natural peanut butter
- A cup of raw oats (blend them into flour first)
- A scoop of whey protein
- A frozen banana
That’s an easy 800 calories you can drink in five minutes. It doesn't trigger the same "I'm stuffed" reflex as a solid meal.
Resistance Training: Giving the Calories a Purpose
If you eat a surplus and sit on the couch, you’ll gain weight, but it won't be the kind you want. You need to tell your body where to put those nutrients.
Heavy compound movements. That’s the secret.
Forget the bicep curls and the calf raises for a second. If you want to move the scale, you need to trigger a systemic hormonal response. This means squats, deadlifts, overhead presses, and rows. These movements recruit the most muscle fibers and stimulate the release of testosterone and growth hormone.
Dr. Brad Schoenfeld, a leading researcher in muscle hypertrophy, has shown that volume is a primary driver of growth. But for guys struggling with weight, intensity matters just as much. You can't just go through the motions. You have to lift heavy enough that the last two reps of your set feel like a genuine struggle.
The Recovery Gap
Guys often overtrain. They think more gym time equals more growth.
Wrong.
You grow while you sleep. When you’re at the gym, you’re actually tearing your muscle fibers down. If you don't sleep 7-9 hours, you’re leaving gains on the table. Lack of sleep spikes cortisol. High cortisol is the enemy of weight gain because it encourages muscle breakdown and fat storage around the midsection.
Stop staying up until 2 AM playing games or scrolling. It’s killing your progress.
🔗 Read more: How to Treat Uneven Skin Tone Without Wasting a Fortune on TikTok Trends
The Protein Obsession and Macro Ratios
Protein is the building block, yeah, we get it. But most guys overdo the protein and ignore the carbs.
Carbohydrates are protein-sparing. This means that if you eat enough carbs, your body uses them for energy instead of burning your precious protein (or your muscle tissue) for fuel. If you’re trying to figure out how to gain weight for guys, you should be looking at a ratio that looks something like 50% carbs, 25% protein, and 25% fats.
Fats are the easiest way to "cheat" your way to a surplus. Fats have 9 calories per gram, while protein and carbs only have 4.
- Put olive oil on everything.
- Eat avocados.
- Snack on almonds.
A handful of walnuts is nearly 200 calories. It’s tiny. You won’t even feel like you ate anything, but your scale will notice.
Digestion: The Overlooked Factor
You aren't what you eat; you're what you absorb.
If you’re eating 4,000 calories but you’re constantly bloated or running to the bathroom, you aren't gaining weight. Your gut microbiome plays a massive role here. Incorporate fermented foods like kimchi or Greek yogurt. If your digestion is trashed, your body is in a state of inflammation, and inflammation is the antithesis of growth.
Why Consistency Trumps Everything
You’ll have days where you aren't hungry. You’ll have days where you miss a workout.
The "weight gain" journey for men is often a multi-year project, not a six-week transformation. The "newbie gains" phase is real—you might pack on 5-10 pounds in the first couple of months—but after that, it slows down. This is where most guys quit. They think they’ve hit a "plateau."
Usually, it's not a plateau; it's just the reality of human biology. Your body wants to stay the same. It likes homeostasis. To break it, you have to be relentless.
💡 You might also like: My eye keeps twitching for days: When to ignore it and when to actually worry
Tracking is Non-Negotiable
If you aren't gaining weight, you aren't eating enough. It sounds blunt, but it’s the truth.
Use an app like Cronometer or MyFitnessPal for just two weeks. Don't change what you're doing; just track. You’ll probably be shocked to find you’re eating 500 calories less than you thought. Once you have the data, you can adjust. If the scale doesn't move for two weeks, add 200 calories. Repeat until the needle nudges.
Real-World Obstacles: Stress and Metabolism
Stress is a weight-gain killer.
When you’re stressed, your sympathetic nervous system is flared up. This "fight or flight" mode suppresses appetite and ramps up your metabolic rate. If you’re a high-strung guy, you’re basically running a marathon in your head every day.
Mindfulness sounds "woo-woo," but lowering your baseline stress can actually help you keep weight on. Relaxed bodies digest food better. Relaxed bodies sleep deeper.
A Note on Supplements
Creatine monohydrate. That’s really the only one you need.
It’s the most researched supplement in history. It helps your muscles retain water (intracellularly, so you don't look bloated, just "fuller") and aids in ATP production, which lets you squeeze out those extra reps in the gym.
Everything else—testosterone boosters, "anabolic" herbs—is mostly marketing fluff. Save your money for high-quality steaks and whole eggs.
Your Step-by-Step Action Plan
Don't try to change everything tomorrow. You'll burn out.
- Find your baseline. Track your normal eating for 3 days. Average the calories.
- The "Plus One" Rule. Add one extra meal or one high-calorie shake to your current routine. Don't overhaul your whole diet; just add to it.
- Prioritize the Big Three. Focus your gym time on Squats, Bench Press, and Deadlifts. Do them first when your energy is highest.
- The 10-Minute Walk. After a big meal, take a short, slow walk. It helps with glucose disposal and digestion, preventing that "comatose" feeling after eating.
- Weekly Weigh-ins. Weigh yourself every morning and take a weekly average. Daily fluctuations (water, salt, glycogen) don't matter. The weekly trend is the only thing that's real.
If the weekly average isn't going up by at least 0.5 pounds, you need more peanut butter. It’s really that simple. Stop overthinking the "perfect" workout split or the "optimal" protein timing. Eat more than you burn, lift heavy things, and get some sleep. The rest is just noise.