March 2020 was a weird time for everyone. Everything stopped. The world went quiet, stadiums were empty, and for baseball fans, the sudden lack of a season felt like a gut punch. Right in the middle of that chaos, MLB The Show 20 dropped. It wasn't just another yearly roster update. It became a lifeline. Honestly, it was the only way to see a 162-game season that year.
You’ve probably played the newer versions on PS5 or Xbox by now. The graphics are shinier, and the frame rates are smoother. But there’s a specific magic to the 2020 edition that often gets overlooked. It was the end of an era. It was the last time the franchise was a true PlayStation exclusive before it went multi-platform.
People still talk about it. Why? Because it hit that sweet spot between legacy mechanics and modern depth.
The Year of the Magician and Minor League Dreams
Javier "El Mago" Báez was the cover athlete, and he fit the vibe perfectly. He was flashy, unpredictable, and fun. But the real "magic" wasn't on the box art. It was in the rosters.
Before this specific game, if you wanted to play as a real-life prospect in MLB The Show, you had to download a custom roster from some dedicated fan in the "Vault." It was a mess. Names were misspelled. Faces looked like potatoes. In MLB The Show 20, Sony San Diego finally got the full Minor League Baseball (MiLB) license.
Suddenly, you had 1,500 real minor leaguers. You could actually take a 19-year-old kid from Single-A and guide him to the Hall of Fame with his real face and stats. It changed the "Road to the Show" mode forever. It made the grind feel authentic.
✨ Don't miss: Sex Fallout New Vegas: Why Obsidian’s Writing Still Outshines Modern RPGs
Why MLB The Show 20 Gameplay Felt Different
If you ask a hardcore player about hitting in this game, they’ll mention "Perfect-Perfect" contact. This was the year they introduced that feedback loop.
When you timed a swing perfectly and squared up the PCI (Plate Coverage Indicator), the controller would give this specific, satisfying rumble, and the sound of the bat was like a gunshot. It didn't always mean a home run—which is realistic, even if it's frustrating—but it told the player exactly why they succeeded.
Fielding got a massive overhaul too. They added an extreme catch indicator and a revamped throwing meter.
- It made the outfield feel dangerous.
- High-skill players could finally "rob" home runs with some level of consistency.
- Attributes actually mattered for once; putting a slugger with "bronze" fielding in center field was basically a death sentence for your ERA.
The Showdown Struggle
Then there was Showdown. This was the new, polarizing addition to Diamond Dynasty. Basically, it was a mini-roguelike mode. You’d draft a squad, play "moments," and build up to a final boss—usually a dominant closer like Aroldis Chapman or a prime Justin Verlander.
You had 15 or 20 outs to score a bunch of runs. If you failed? You lost everything. The progress, the entry fee (stubs), the rewards. It was brutal. People hated it. People loved it. But it gave solo players a way to earn top-tier cards without having to sweat against online goons in Ranked Seasons.
🔗 Read more: Why the Disney Infinity Star Wars Starter Pack Still Matters for Collectors in 2026
A Moment in History: The COVID-19 Impact
We can’t talk about MLB The Show 20 without mentioning the "MLB The Show Players League." Since the real season was on ice, 30 actual MLB players—one from each team—competed in an online tournament.
Blake Snell ended up winning the whole thing, but it did something more important. It bridged the gap between the virtual game and the real sport. Fans were watching Joey Gallo and Amir Garrett talk trash on Twitch while playing as themselves. It gave the game a cultural relevance that no other sports sim has really captured since.
For a few months, this wasn't just a video game. It was the "official" season for many fans.
The Sad Reality of Online Servers
Now, here is the part that sucks. If you’re looking to fire up the old PS4 and jump into Diamond Dynasty, you’re out of luck.
Sony officially decommissioned the online servers for MLB The Show 20 in early 2024. This means:
💡 You might also like: Grand Theft Auto Games Timeline: Why the Chronology is a Beautiful Mess
- Multiplayer is dead.
- The Community Market is gone.
- You can’t earn new Diamond Dynasty rewards.
- Stubs can only be used for the offline stuff you already have.
It’s the standard lifecycle for sports games, but it still stings because the card art that year was arguably some of the best the series ever saw. Those "Prestige" cards were a status symbol. Now they're just digital ghosts.
Is It Still Worth Playing in 2026?
Honestly? Yes, but only for specific reasons.
If you want a pure, offline Franchise experience on the PS4, this is a peak entry. The gameplay is stable. The "March to October" mode is fast and snappy. It’s also one of the last years where the menus didn't feel cluttered with a thousand different "Seasons" and "Sets" that expire every two months—a trend that has annoyed a lot of modern players in the newer titles.
Basically, it’s a time capsule. It represents a year when we needed baseball more than ever, and a developer that actually tried to innovate despite the world falling apart.
What to do next
If you still have your copy, don't trade it in for pennies. Keep it for the local co-op. The "Legacy" rosters are great for a quick game with a friend on the couch. If you're looking for a more modern experience with active rosters and servers, you'll need to jump to the current year's version, but don't expect the same "vibe" that 2020 had. To get the most out of your offline play now, try digging into the Custom Leagues or the Roster Vault if you managed to download any classic rosters before the servers went dark.