If you’ve spent any time at all down the British cozy mystery rabbit hole, you know the vibe. Thatch-roofed cottages. Overly polite tea parties. A body count that would make a cartel nervous. But there is something specific about Midsomer Murders Garden of Death that sticks in the brain like a burr on a wool sweater. It’s not just the gardening—though, let’s be honest, the English obsession with topiary is a bit weird anyway. It’s the sheer, cold-blooded pettiness of the motive.
The episode first aired in 2000. That’s a lifetime ago in TV years. Yet, if you browse any BritBox forum or fan group today, people are still talking about the Inkpen family. Or rather, they’re talking about how much they hated them.
The Inkpen-Thomas Feud and Why It Matters
Let's get into the weeds.
Basically, the plot kicks off with the reopening of Memorial Garden in Midsomer Deverell. It sounds lovely, right? Wrong. The Inkpen-Thomas family is old money, or at least they act like it, and they want to turn this beautiful community space into a commercial tea room. It’s a classic "town vs. gown" or "new money vs. tradition" clash that series creator Caroline Graham always excelled at.
The first body belongs to Felicity Inkpen. She’s found dead in the garden, and honestly, the list of people who didn't want to kill her is shorter than the list of people who did. But it’s not just a whodunit. It’s a study of a dysfunctional family dynamic that makes Succession look like a sitcom. You've got Naomi Inkpen, the matriarch who treats everyone like dirt, and her daughter Elspeth, who is basically a walking nerve ending.
What people often forget about Midsomer Murders Garden of Death is how it used the "hidden child" trope before it became a cliché. The revelation that Elspeth was actually Fliss’s daughter—and that the entire family tree was a gnarled mess of lies—was a genuine gut-punch back in the day. It wasn't just about a garden. It was about legacy. It was about who "owns" the land and who "owns" the history of a village.
Why the Gardening Theme Hits Different
British people and their gardens. It's a whole thing.
In this episode, the garden isn't just a setting; it's the weapon. Not literally (though people do get bludgeoned), but psychologically. The destruction of the garden represents the destruction of the village's soul. When the Inkpens decide to bulldoze the history of Midsomer Deverell for a tea shop, they aren't just building a business. They are erasing the memory of the men who died in the war, the very men the "Memorial Garden" was built for.
💡 You might also like: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
That’s why the motive feels so heavy.
Usually, in these shows, someone dies because of a secret affair or a stolen inheritance. Here, it’s about the arrogance of the upper class thinking they can rewrite the landscape. Barnaby—the GOAT, Tom Barnaby, played by John Nettles—is at his best here. He’s cynical but respectful. He hates the snobbery, but he loves the order of the law.
And Troy? Sergeant Gavin Troy is... well, he's Troy. He’s a bit bigoted, a bit clumsy, and a perfect foil for Barnaby’s sophisticated investigative style. Their chemistry in this specific era of the show was lightning in a bottle.
The Cast That Made It Iconic
You can’t talk about this episode without mentioning the guest stars.
- Anthony Benson: Played by David Bamber. You know him from Pride and Prejudice as Mr. Collins. He brings that same oily, uncomfortable energy here.
- Naomi Inkpen: Played by Margaret Tyzack. She was a titan of British acting. She makes Naomi so incredibly unlikeable that you’re almost rooting for the killer. Almost.
- Elspeth Inkpen: Anna Calder-Marshall delivers a performance that is genuinely haunting. She looks like someone who has been suppressed for forty years and is finally starting to crack.
The acting elevates it from a standard procedural to a gothic tragedy. When you watch Elspeth, you don't see a "character"; you see a woman broken by a village that refuses to change.
Honestly, the pacing of the 2000s episodes was so much better than the modern ones. They took their time. They let the camera linger on a dead rose or a suspicious look over a teacup. There’s a scene where Barnaby is just walking through the garden, looking at the layout, and you can see him putting the pieces together without a single line of dialogue. That’s peak television.
Common Misconceptions About the Ending
A lot of people get confused about the final reveal. No, it wasn't just about the money.
📖 Related: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
The motive was revenge for a life stolen. When you realize that the killer was acting out of a sense of profound, multi-generational displacement, the "Garden of Death" takes on a new meaning. It’s not just where people die; it’s where the Inkpen family buried their secrets for decades.
Some viewers argue that the killer was "too obvious." I disagree. In a good Midsomer, the killer should be the person who has the most to lose emotionally, not financially. The financial stuff is just a distraction. The real "Garden of Death" is the family tree itself.
How to Spot the Clues Early
If you’re rewatching, look at the way the characters interact with the plants. It sounds silly, but it’s a massive tell.
The people who truly love the village treat the garden with a sort of sacred reverence. The Inkpens treat it like an asset. There’s a specific moment involving a spade—pay attention to who handles the tools. In the world of Midsomer, how you treat the earth is a direct reflection of how you treat people.
Also, watch the background characters. Midsomer Deverell is full of people who are "just watching." The local priest, the shopkeepers—they all know the Inkpen secrets. They just don't say anything until Barnaby starts poking around. This episode perfectly captures that "omerta" of a small English village.
Actionable Insights for Mystery Fans
If you want to get the most out of your next Midsomer binge, specifically this episode, try these steps:
Map the family tree as you watch. Don't just listen to names. Write them down. The Inkpen-Thomas lineage is intentionally confusing to hide the twist. By the time you get to the forty-minute mark, if you haven't figured out who is related to whom, the ending won't hit as hard.
👉 See also: Jack Blocker American Idol Journey: What Most People Get Wrong
Observe the "Class Warfare" markers. Notice the difference between Barnaby’s home life (Joyce’s cooking, the modest house) and the Inkpen estate. The show uses these visual cues to tell you exactly why the tension is rising in the village.
Watch for the "Red Herring" of the Commercial Development. The tea room is a classic distraction. In 90% of Midsomer episodes, the thing everyone is arguing about in public (the business deal, the new road, the bypass) is never the real reason for the murder. The real reason is always something that happened twenty years ago.
Pay attention to the score. Jim Parker’s music in this episode is particularly heavy on the woodwinds. It creates this pastoral yet sickly atmosphere. It’s the sound of a beautiful summer day with a rotting corpse hidden in the bushes.
Visit the Real Locations. If you’re ever in Buckinghamshire, many of the filming locations for Midsomer Deverell are real. The village of Denham and the gardens at Chenies Manor were used extensively. Seeing the real-life "Garden of Death" (without the murders) gives you a huge appreciation for the location scouting of the early seasons.
Understand the "Caroline Graham" Factor. While this episode was an adaptation, it sticks close to the DNA of Graham's novels. Her focus was always on the "unpleasantness" behind the lace curtains. If you enjoy this episode, you absolutely need to read The Killings at Badger's Drift. It provides the foundational logic for why the Midsomer universe works the way it does.
The longevity of Midsomer Murders Garden of Death isn't an accident. It’s a perfect storm of casting, a genuinely cruel motive, and the primal fear that even in the most beautiful places on Earth, something nasty is waiting under the soil.