Watching Allison DuBois wake up screaming in the middle of the night became a weekly ritual for millions of us back in the mid-2000s. It was a specific kind of vibe. You had the procedural grit of a crime drama mixed with this domestic, almost mundane suburban reality, and then—bam—a ghost is standing in the kitchen while Joe is just trying to make toast. Medium wasn’t just another show about a psychic. Honestly, it was a show about a marriage that just happened to involve dead people.
When it premiered on NBC in 2005, the landscape was already getting crowded with the supernatural. Ghost Whisperer was right there. But while Jennifer Love Hewitt was wearing vintage dresses in a cozy antique shop, Patricia Arquette’s Allison was wearing oversized t-shirts, dealing with laundry, and looking genuinely exhausted. She looked like a mom who hadn't slept in three years. Because she hadn't. That groundedness is why the show still hits differently today.
The Real Allison DuBois and the Phoenix Connection
Most people know the show is "based on a true story," but the reality of the real Allison DuBois is actually more interesting than the Hollywood version. She wasn't just a consultant; she was a catalyst. Glenn Gordon Caron, the creator of the show (and the guy behind Moonlighting), didn't want a "spooky" show. He wanted a family show. He spent time with the real DuBois in Phoenix, Arizona, observing how her "gift" affected her husband and three daughters.
The real-life Allison has always been a polarizing figure. Skeptics, including those from the James Randi Educational Foundation, have spent years trying to debunk her claims. They point out that her "hits" are often vague or that her work with law enforcement is exaggerated. But the show didn't really care about the skeptics. It leaned into the emotional truth of her experience. In the series, Allison works for District Attorney Manuel Devalos, played with a perfect, weary dignity by Miguel Sandoval.
The dynamic was simple. Allison would have a dream. The dream would be a fragmented, confusing mess of metaphors. She’d spend forty minutes trying to figure out if the man in the red hat was the killer or the victim. Usually, she was wrong the first two times. That’s what made it feel "real"—the fallibility. She wasn't a superhero. She was a woman with a very stressful, very confusing job.
Joe DuBois: The MVP of Marital Patience
Let’s talk about Joe. Jake Weber’s portrayal of Joe DuBois is, frankly, the gold standard for TV husbands.
📖 Related: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
Joe was an aerospace engineer. He lived in the world of math, physics, and empirical data. Yet, he lived with a woman who talked to the ceiling. Most shows would have made the husband a bumbling idiot or a constant naysayer. Joe wasn't either. He was a scientist who accepted that his wife had a biological anomaly he couldn't explain. He charted her dreams. He timed her episodes. He was her anchor.
Their marriage was the heart of Medium. They fought about money. They fought about the kids. They fought because Allison woke him up at 3:00 AM for the fourth night in a row because she "felt" something was wrong in a warehouse three towns away.
"It’s not just a dream, Joe!"
That line became a meme before memes were a thing. But Weber played it with such a tired, loving grace that you believed they stayed together. Their chemistry was the secret sauce. Without the domesticity, the show would have just been another "freak of the week" procedural.
The Kids and the Genetic Curse
The show also did something brave by making the daughters—Ariel, Bridgette, and Marie—psychic too. It turned the "gift" into a hereditary condition, sort of like diabetes or high blood pressure.
👉 See also: Why La Mera Mera Radio is Actually Dominating Local Airwaves Right Now
Watching Ariel (Sofia Vassilieva) navigate high school while seeing the future of her classmates was heartbreaking. It wasn't cool or fun. It was isolating. Bridgette (Maria Lark) provided the comic relief, often seeing things in a more literal, childlike way that usually ended up being the key to the whole mystery. By the time little Marie started showing signs, the audience felt the same weight Allison did: the realization that her children were never going to have "normal" lives.
Why the Writing Style Broke the Rules
Medium used a nonlinear storytelling method that was pretty experimental for network TV at the time. You’d get a dream sequence that looked like a 1950s sitcom, or a black-and-white noir film, or even a cartoon. These weren't just gimmicks. They represented how the subconscious processes trauma.
The show was also surprisingly violent. Because it aired at 10:00 PM, it could get away with some genuinely disturbing imagery. But the violence was never stylized. It was ugly and jarring, which emphasized Allison's empathy. She felt the victims' pain. That’s a heavy burden for a lead character, and Arquette won an Emmy for it because she never played it as "cool." She played it as a chronic illness.
The Controversial Ending (Spoilers, Obviously)
People still argue about the series finale, "Goodbye." After seven seasons—five on NBC and two on CBS—the show ended in 2011.
Most procedurals end with a "life goes on" montage. Medium didn't. It killed Joe in a plane crash. Then it showed Allison living a long, lonely life, only to be reunited with him in the afterlife as an old woman. It was a gut-punch. Fans were furious. Why kill Joe? Why break up the best couple on television?
✨ Don't miss: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
Looking back, it was the only way the show could end. The entire series was about the thin veil between life and death. If the show ended with them just eating breakfast, it would have ignored the central theme: that love is the only thing that crosses over. It was messy. It was polarizing. It was very Medium.
The Legacy of Medium in the Streaming Era
If you go back and watch it now on platforms like Paramount+ or Pluto TV, it holds up surprisingly well. The fashion is very 2006 (lots of bootcut jeans), but the family dynamics are timeless. It paved the way for shows like The Haunting of Hill House, which also used the supernatural to explore family trauma.
Interestingly, the show also featured a revolving door of guest stars before they were massive. Octavia Spencer, Emma Stone, and Morena Baccarin all popped up in Phoenix.
Common Misconceptions
- Is it a sequel to The Sixth Sense? No, but Patricia Arquette’s performance is often compared to the grounded tone of that film.
- Did the real Allison DuBois solve crimes? The real Allison claims she has, though many police departments are hesitant to officially credit psychics on the record.
- Why did it switch networks? NBC canceled it after season five due to declining ratings, but CBS picked it up because it performed well in its time slot and had a loyal, older demographic.
How to Revisit the World of Allison DuBois
If you're looking to dive back in or watch for the first time, don't just binge the whole thing. The "dream-of-the-week" format can get repetitive if you watch ten episodes in a row.
Pro-tip for watchers: 1. Start with the Pilot to see the chemistry immediately.
2. Skip to Season 3's "Four Dreams" (Parts 1 and 2)—it's arguably the peak of the show's creative powers.
3. Watch "Death Takes a Policy" in Season 2 for a great example of the show's darker, more philosophical side.
The show reminds us that even if you can see the future, you still have to live in the present. You still have to pay the mortgage. You still have to raise your kids. That’s the most "medium" thing about it.
To get the most out of a rewatch, pay attention to the sound design. The show used silence and ambient noise to signal the shift between Allison's "real" world and her dream state. It’s a subtle masterclass in building tension without jump scares. Once you notice the shift in audio, you'll start to feel the "dream" coming before it even appears on screen. Keep an eye out for the subtle ways Joe’s engineering projects often mirror the logic Allison needs to solve her cases; the writers were incredibly consistent with those parallels.