You know the ones.
They sit at the bottom of the plastic pumpkin on November 1st, long after the Snickers and Reese’s have been inhaled. They are the orange and black wrapped peanut butter candy staples of every suburban Halloween in history. Some people call them "those weird taffy things." Others call them "molasses globs." If you look at the wrapper, you might see the name Mary Jane, or you might see nothing at all—just a waxy piece of paper twisted at the ends, color-coded for a spooky season that seems to have forgotten them.
Honestly, it’s a miracle they’re still around. In a world of high-tech aerated chocolate and sour-filing-filled gummies, these dense, tooth-shattering nuggets feel like a relic from a different century. Because they are.
The Identity Crisis of the Orange and Black Wrapper
What exactly are you eating when you unwrap one of these? It depends.
There are two main culprits behind the orange and black wrapped peanut butter candy phenomenon. First, you’ve got the Mary Jane. Created in 1914 by Charles Miller, these were named after his aunt. They use a distinct combination of molasses and peanut butter. They’re rectangular. They’re stiff. They have a very specific "old-timey" vibe that feels like something a gold prospector would keep in his pocket.
Then there are the "Peanut Butter Kisses." These are the ones usually found in those massive, generic bags at the grocery store. They aren't Hershey's Kisses. Not even close. They’re blunt-edged, circular dollops of molasses-flavored taffy with a hidden (and often dry) peanut butter center. Necco—the now-defunct New England Confectionery Company—was the king of these for decades. When Necco went bankrupt in 2018, the world briefly panicked. Or, well, the three people who actually love these candies panicked.
✨ Don't miss: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
The Spangler Candy Company eventually swooped in to save the recipe, which is why your teeth can still experience the structural integrity of a brick disguised as a treat.
Why Does Everyone Hate Them? (Or Do They?)
It’s a trend to hate on these. Every year, various "Worst Halloween Candy" polls put these right next to Circus Peanuts and Candy Corn. People complain that they're too hard. They complain that the wrapper sticks to the candy so badly you end up eating 10% wax paper.
But here’s the thing: they sell.
Companies don't produce millions of pounds of candy just for the sake of tradition. There is a silent majority of people who actually crave that savory-sweet hit. It’s not a sugar rush; it’s a slow burn. The molasses provides a deep, smoky undertone that you just don't get from a Milky Way. It’s a sophisticated flavor profile if you’re willing to look past the fact that it looks like something you’d use to seal a leaky pipe.
The texture is the real barrier to entry. If you try to bite it immediately, you’re looking at a potential dental emergency. You have to be patient. You have to let it warm up. It’s a commitment. In our current culture of instant gratification, a candy that requires a five-minute "warm-up period" in your cheek is a tough sell.
🔗 Read more: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
The Physics of the "Old School" Taffy
Technically, these are aerated taffies. The process involves boiling sugar, corn syrup, and molasses, then pulling it to incorporate air. This should make it light. However, the addition of peanut butter changes the fat content, leading to that signature "tug" that makes you wonder if your fillings are securely attached.
- The Molasses Factor: Most modern candy uses high fructose corn syrup for sweetness. These candies rely on molasses, which contains minerals like calcium and iron. It’s basically a health food. (Note: It is definitely not a health food).
- Shelf Life: These things are indestructible. You could probably find a bag from 1994, and it would taste exactly the same as one bought yesterday. This makes them a favorite for "budget-conscious" neighbors who buy their Halloween stash three months in advance.
The Cultural Longevity of a "Boring" Treat
There is something deeply nostalgic about the orange and black wrapped peanut butter candy. They represent a time before branding was everything. Today, candy is a lifestyle. You’re a "Skittles person" or a "Twix person." These taffies don't care about your lifestyle. They don't have a TikTok strategy. They just exist in their plain orange and black wax paper, fulfilling their duty as the filler of bowls.
When you see that orange wrapper, you know exactly what’s inside. There’s no mystery. No "limited edition" flavor. It’s just peanut butter and molasses, doing their best.
Interestingly, after Necco folded, the "Peanut Butter Kiss" became a bit of a cult item. Absence made the heart grow fond. When Spangler brought them back to the market, they saw a surge in interest from people who realized they actually missed the weird, salty-sweet chewiness. It’s the "Ugly Duckling" effect. You don't appreciate the reliable, weird taffy until it’s gone and you’re left with nothing but generic chocolate bars that melt if you look at them too hard.
How to Actually Enjoy Them (A Practical Guide)
If you find yourself with a handful of these after a night of trick-or-treating or a clearance-aisle binge, don't just toss them. There is a technique to the orange and black wrapped peanut butter candy.
💡 You might also like: How is gum made? The sticky truth about what you are actually chewing
- The Temperature Check: Never eat these cold. If they’ve been sitting in a cold garage or a chilly mailbox, they are essentially rocks. Put one in your pocket for ten minutes. The ambient body heat softens the molasses.
- The Slow Melt: Don't chew. Just let it sit. The peanut butter center is the reward. If you rush it, you’ll just get frustrated by the stickiness.
- The Pairing: Believe it or not, these go incredibly well with a sharp cheddar cheese or a cup of bitter black coffee. The saltiness of the peanut butter and the bitterness of the coffee cut through the heavy molasses.
The Real Future of the Orange and Black Wrappers
As we move further into the 2020s, the candy industry is consolidating. Smaller brands are being swallowed by giants. Yet, the orange and black wrapped peanut butter candy persists. It’s a niche product that survives on pure nostalgia and the fact that it’s incredibly cheap to produce.
It’s also one of the few candies that remains relatively "simple." Look at the ingredient list on a Mary Jane. It’s short. It’s recognizable. In an era where people are increasingly wary of "ultra-processed" foods (even though candy is, by definition, processed), there’s a weird comfort in a recipe that hasn't changed since the Wilson administration.
We’re likely to see these continue to haunt the bottom of candy bowls for another century. They are the cockroach of the confectionery world—impossible to kill and strangely impressive in their resilience.
Next time you see an orange or black wrapper, don't roll your eyes. Appreciate it for what it is: a tiny, wax-wrapped time capsule. A piece of American history that asks very little of you, other than a bit of patience and a strong set of molars.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Check the Label: If you're buying these, look for the Spangler or Atkinson’s brand names to ensure you’re getting the "authentic" high-quality molasses version rather than a generic knock-off that uses artificial flavoring.
- Don't Freeze Them: Unlike many chocolate bars which are great frozen, freezing these candies creates a literal shatter-hazard for your teeth. Keep them at a steady room temperature of about 70 degrees.
- Use Them in Baking: If you truly can't stand the texture, chop them up and fold them into a basic cookie dough. The heat of the oven melts the taffy into little pockets of peanut-butter-caramel that are actually quite incredible.