If you drive down Route 25A on a Tuesday afternoon, you’ll see it. The Gold Coast. It’s not just a nickname from an F. Scott Fitzgerald novel; it’s a very real, very expensive stretch of land where some of the most ridiculous real estate in the world sits behind rusted iron gates and half-mile-long driveways. People talk about mansions in Long Island like they’re all Gatsby-style relics with marble fountains and ballroom floors, but honestly, that’s only half the story. The truth is way more complicated and, frankly, a bit more chaotic than the brochures suggest.
Long Island real estate is currently in a weird spot.
On one hand, you have the historic estates in Old Westbury and Muttontown that are basically crumbling under the weight of their own property taxes. On the other, you have new money pouring into the Hamptons and Sands Point, building glass-and-steel boxes that look more like Apple Stores than homes. It’s a clash of cultures. The "Old Money" crowd is trying to figure out how to heat a 20,000-square-foot limestone fortress without going bankrupt, while the "New Money" tech founders are installing literal underground car elevators.
The Reality of the Gold Coast Legacy
Most people think the North Shore is just one big neighborhood. It isn't. It’s a patchwork of villages with their own weird rules and vibes. Brookville is different from Lloyd Harbor. Centre Island is its own planet.
When you look at the legendary mansions in Long Island, you’re often looking at the remnants of the Gilded Age. Think Oheka Castle. It’s the second-largest private residence ever built in America. Otto Hermann Kahn finished it in 1919, and it has 127 rooms. But here’s what they don’t tell you: in the late 70s and 80s, that place was a wreck. It was abandoned, vandalized, and almost torn down. It took Gary Melius, a developer, to step in and spend a fortune to turn it into a hotel and event space. Most of these massive estates can't survive as single-family homes anymore. The math just doesn't work.
You have to consider the "white elephant" problem.
A 15-bedroom house in Glen Cove sounds cool until you realize you need a full-time staff of four just to keep the dust off the crown molding. Many of these older mansions are being subdivided. Developers buy a 40-acre estate, tear down the main house—which breaks the hearts of local historians—and build ten "mini-mansions" that look exactly the same. It’s a trend that’s stripping the North Shore of its architectural soul, but from a business perspective, it's the only way to make the land pay for itself.
The Hamptons vs. The North Shore
There is a massive rivalry here. The Hamptons—the South Fork—is where the celebrities go. It’s for the "see and be seen" crowd. The mansions there are focused on the beach, the ocean air, and being within walking distance of a $25 sourdough loaf in East Hampton.
👉 See also: Draft House Las Vegas: Why Locals Still Flock to This Old School Sports Bar
The North Shore? That’s for the quiet wealth.
The people buying mansions in Long Island’s North Shore are often CEOs, surgeons, and multi-generational families who want privacy. They want trees. They want a dock on the Sound where they can keep a sailboat without a paparazzi boat hovering nearby. While the Hamptons feel like a summer camp for the 1%, the North Shore feels like a permanent fortress.
What a Modern Mansion Actually Costs to Run
Let’s get real about the numbers because people love to ignore the boring stuff. If you buy a $10 million mansion in a place like Mill Neck or Kings Point, the purchase price is just the entry fee.
- Property Taxes: This is the killer. Long Island has some of the highest property taxes in the United States. It’s not uncommon for a high-end estate to have a yearly tax bill of $150,000 or $200,000. Just for the right to exist there.
- Landscaping: You can’t just mow the lawn. You have manicured hedges, specimen trees, and irrigation systems that eat water like a humpback whale.
- Staffing: Most of these properties require at least a part-time property manager. If you have a pool, a tennis court, and a smart-home system that controls 40 zones of heating, you need a pro to keep it from breaking.
I spoke with a broker who specializes in Nassau County luxury listings recently. She told me that "turnkey" is the only word buyers care about now. Nobody wants a "project." The days of someone buying a fixer-upper mansion and spending five years restoring the mahogany paneling are mostly gone. Today’s buyers want a kitchen that looks like a spaceship and a basement that has a CrossFit gym and a theater. If a house needs a new roof or has outdated plumbing, it sits on the market for years.
The Secret Neighborhoods You Haven't Heard Of
Everyone knows Montauk and Southampton. But if you're looking for the real mansions in Long Island, you look at places like Matinecock or Lattingtown. These are villages so small you’ll miss the sign if you blink. They have no downtowns. No shops. No streetlights. Just winding roads and "No Trespassing" signs.
This is where you find the equestrian estates. We're talking about properties with professional-grade stables and indoor riding rings. In Old Westbury, the horses often live better than most humans. The zoning laws in these pockets are incredibly strict—often requiring a minimum of two or five acres per house—which keeps the density low and the prices astronomical.
Why the Market is Freaking Out Right Now
The 2020s have been a roller coaster for Long Island. When the pandemic hit, everyone in Manhattan panicked and fled to the suburbs. Prices for mansions in Long Island skyrocketed. Bidding wars were happening for $5 million houses, which was unheard of.
✨ Don't miss: Dr Dennis Gross C+ Collagen Brighten Firm Vitamin C Serum Explained (Simply)
But now? Interest rates hit, and things cooled off. Sorta.
The inventory is still incredibly low. People who have these houses aren't selling because they don't want to give up their 3% mortgage rates. So, you have this weird stagnation where the houses that do hit the market are priced like they’re made of solid gold, even if they haven't been painted since 2004.
There's also the "Billionaire's Row" effect moving into the North Shore. We're seeing international buyers from Europe and Asia who see Long Island as a safe place to park their cash. They aren't even living there half the time. They’re buying these estates as "land banks." It’s a weird feeling to walk through a neighborhood of $15 million homes and realize half the lights are off because nobody is home.
Architectural Shifts: From French Chateau to Ultra-Modern
If you look at the mansions in Long Island built in the 1920s, they followed a specific script: Tudor, Georgian, or French Provincial. They were formal. They had separate "servant quarters" and tiny kitchens because the owners weren't the ones cooking.
Modern mansions have flipped that.
The kitchen is now the center of the house. It's usually a massive open space with two islands and enough marble to pave a small city. The formal living room is dead. Now, it’s all about the "Great Room." And glass. Lots of glass. Modern buyers want to see the backyard from every room in the house. This creates a funny problem: these glass houses are incredibly inefficient to heat in a New York winter. But hey, if you can afford the $12 million price tag, you probably aren't worried about the ConEd bill.
Navigating the Legal Nightmare
Buying a mansion isn't like buying a condo. You have to deal with "Covenants and Restrictions" that can be absolute insanity. Some villages have rules about what color your curtains can be if they face the street. Others won't let you cut down a single tree without a board hearing that lasts six months.
🔗 Read more: Double Sided Ribbon Satin: Why the Pro Crafters Always Reach for the Good Stuff
I know a guy who bought a gorgeous waterfront estate in Great Neck. He wanted to build a small dock for his jet skis. It took him three years and $50,000 in legal fees just to get the permits. Between the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) and the local village board, he almost gave up. That’s the reality of mansions in Long Island—you own the land, but the local government basically tells you what you can do with it.
The "Hidden" Costs of Privacy
Security is the biggest unspoken expense. When you have a high-profile property, you aren't just putting a Ring camera on the doorbell. These houses have perimeter sensors, gated entries with intercom systems, and sometimes literal panic rooms.
The landscaping also plays into security. Those giant privacy hedges (usually Privet or Arborvitae) take years to grow and cost a fortune to maintain. If one section dies, your whole backyard is exposed to the neighbors. It’s a constant battle against nature to keep that "secluded" look.
Actionable Advice for Navigating the Long Island Luxury Market
If you are actually looking at mansions in Long Island, or just dreaming of the day you can, there are a few things you need to keep in mind to avoid a total disaster.
- Check the Village Taxes First: Don't just look at the school taxes. Incorporated villages often have their own separate tax, which can add another $10k–$30k to your yearly overhead.
- Get a Specialized Inspector: A regular home inspector is used to 2,000-square-foot ranches. For a mansion, you need someone who understands commercial-grade boilers, slate roofs, and complex drainage systems. If they don't bring a drone to check the chimneys, hire someone else.
- Verify the Certificate of Occupancy (CO): This is huge. Many old estates have "extra" buildings—pool houses, cottages, or detached garages—that were built decades ago without proper permits. If the CO isn't updated, you’ll have a nightmare during the closing process.
- Water Quality Matters: Many of the more rural mansion areas (like parts of the North Shore) still rely on private wells or have very specific water issues. Get a comprehensive water test. You don't want to buy a $6 million house and find out you can't drink the water.
- Understand the "Historic" Designation: If a house is landmarked or in a historic district, you are essentially a tenant of the state. You won't be able to change the windows or the siding without approval. It’s a massive commitment to preservation that most people aren't ready for.
The market for mansions in Long Island isn't going anywhere. It’s too close to Manhattan and has too much history to ever truly fail. But the way people live in these houses is shifting. It’s less about showing off to the neighbors and more about creating a private sanctuary. Whether it’s a 1920s brick manor or a 2026 glass cube, the goal remains the same: finding a piece of the island to call your own, away from the noise of the city.
Just make sure you have a really good plumber on speed dial. You're going to need one.
Next Steps for Potential Buyers or Enthusiasts:
Start by researching the specific "Village" websites for areas like Old Brookville or Muttontown to understand their zoning laws. If you're looking to buy, secure a buyer's agent who only deals in North Shore luxury; the nuances of these estates are too complex for a generalist. For those just interested in the history, visit Old Westbury Gardens or the Vanderbilt Museum to see how these estates functioned before they became modern real estate assets.