Beauty trends move fast. One week everyone is obsessed with "clean girl" aesthetic and barely-there lashes, and the next, we're all trying to look like 1960s icons with clumps of jet-black pigment. But through the noise, one specific tube has stayed in the makeup bags of professional artists and college students alike: L'Oreal Voluminous Waterproof Mascara. It’s not new. It’s not "disruptive." It’s just remarkably consistent.
Honestly, the makeup aisle is a nightmare of over-promising packaging. You see tubes shaped like rockets or vibrating wands that claim to grow your lashes while you sleep. Most of it is just marketing fluff. L'Oreal Voluminous Carbon Black—and specifically the waterproof variant—succeeds because it does the one thing a mascara actually needs to do. It builds mass without making you look like you have spiders living on your eyelids.
The Chemistry of the L'Oreal Voluminous Waterproof Mascara Formula
What’s actually inside that gray and gold tube? It isn't magic. It's a precise balance of Panthenol and Ceramide-R.
Most people ignore the ingredient list on a five-dollar mascara, but these two matter. Panthenol is a provitamin of B5. It acts as a humectant. It keeps the lashes from getting that "crunchy" feeling that usually leads to breakage when you're trying to remove waterproof makeup at midnight. Ceramide-R is basically a synthetic version of the natural ceramics found in hair. It smooths the scales of the lash hair, allowing the pigment to stick more evenly.
The "waterproof" part comes from a high concentration of Isododecane and various waxes like beeswax and carnauba wax. Isododecane is a solvent that evaporates quickly. Once you swipe it on, it sets. Fast. This is why you can’t really "build" this mascara ten minutes after the first coat. If you try, it'll flake. You have to work while it’s wet.
Why the Brush Shape Actually Matters
We need to talk about the brush. It’s a classic, dense, natural-bristle brush. In an era where every brand is pivoting to molded plastic "spiky" combs, this felt-like brush is a relic.
But it works.
Plastic combs are great for separation, sure. But they are terrible at depositing volume. The soft fibers of the Voluminous brush hold a significant amount of product in the "valleys" between the bristles. When you wiggle it at the base of your lashes, it dumps that product right where you need it—at the root. This creates the illusion of a thicker lash line without weighing down the tips.
🔗 Read more: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
Breaking Down the "Waterproof" Promise
Is it actually waterproof? Yes. Mostly.
If you go for a swim in a chlorinated pool, it’s going to hold up better than 90% of its competitors. However, the real test isn't water—it's oil. If you have very oily eyelids or you use a heavy eye cream in the morning, you might see some smudging by 4:00 PM. This is because oil is the natural enemy of waterproof wax.
But for sweat? Tears? A humid July day in New Orleans? L'Oreal Voluminous Waterproof Mascara is a tank.
Makeup artist Sir John, who has worked extensively with Beyoncé (and we all know her stage shows are a literal sweat-fest), has frequently cited L'Oreal mascaras as staples for their reliability. When a performer is under stage lights for two hours, they can't have "raccoon eyes."
The Color Payoff: Is Carbon Black Necessary?
L'Oreal offers a few shades, but "Carbon Black" is the one that people hunt for. It contains twice the pigment of their standard black shade.
If you have very fair hair or you’re going for a "no-makeup" look, Carbon Black might be too aggressive. It’s deep. It’s moody. It creates a high-contrast look that defines the eyes instantly. For most people, "Black" or "Black Brown" provides a softer, more natural shadow. But if you want drama, you go for the darkest one.
Common Mistakes People Make with This Mascara
Most people hate waterproof mascara because they don't know how to use it. Or remove it.
💡 You might also like: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong
First, stop pumping the wand. You know that "thump-thump-thump" sound people make when they’re trying to get more product on the brush? Stop. All you’re doing is forcing air into the tube. This dries out the waxes and introduces bacteria. If your mascara is clumping after only three weeks, it’s probably because you’re a pumper. Instead, swirl the wand gently inside the tube.
Secondly, the "wiggle" technique is non-negotiable here. Because the formula is thick, if you just pull it straight through your lashes, you’ll end up with three giant clumps. You have to start at the root, wiggle horizontally to coat the base, and then pull through to the tips.
The Removal Nightmare
You cannot remove this with a regular water-based cleanser. You just can’t. If you try, you’ll end up scrubbing your delicate eye skin and pulling out three lashes in the process.
You need an oil-based remover or a dedicated micellar water for waterproof makeup (the one with the blue cap, usually). Soak a cotton pad. Press it against your closed eye for thirty seconds. Do not rub. Let the oil break down those carnauba waxes. Then, gently wipe away.
How it Compares to High-End Alternatives
I've tried the $40 mascaras from Chanel and Dior. They’re lovely. The packaging is heavy and feels expensive. But here’s the thing: mascara has a shelf life of three months.
Bacteria loves the dark, moist environment of a mascara tube. Spending $40 every twelve weeks is a lot for most people. L'Oreal Voluminous Waterproof Mascara usually sits around the $9 to $12 range.
- Compared to Too Faced Better Than Sex (Waterproof): The L'Oreal version is less "flaky." The Too Faced brush is an hourglass shape which some people love, but the formula tends to dry out much faster in the tube.
- Compared to Maybelline Great Lash: Great Lash is the "pink and green" classic, but it’s very thin. If you want length, Great Lash is fine. If you want volume, L'Oreal wins every time.
- Compared to Luxury Brands: You're mostly paying for the scent and the tube weight. The actual pigment payoff in Voluminous is often superior.
Addressing the "Dryness" Complaint
A common critique of this mascara is that it feels "dry" straight out of the box.
📖 Related: 100 Biggest Cities in the US: Why the Map You Know is Wrong
That’s actually intentional.
Wet mascaras are a mess. They get all over your lids and take forever to set. A "drier" formula allows for more control. If you find your tube is too dry, a pro tip is to stick the closed tube in a cup of warm water for two minutes before you apply it. The heat softens the waxes and makes the application buttery smooth.
Real-World Performance: The Wedding Test
I recently spoke with a bridal makeup artist who refuses to use anything else on her clients' bottom lashes. Why? Because brides cry.
Even if she uses a luxury mascara on the top lashes for "prestige," she sticks to the Voluminous Waterproof on the bottom. It doesn't budge. It doesn't flake into the undereye concealer. It's the "insurance policy" of the makeup world.
Is it Safe for Sensitive Eyes?
L’Oreal claims this is allergy-tested and ophthalmologist-tested. It’s generally safe for contact lens wearers because it doesn't have those tiny "fibers" that some lengthening mascaras use. Those fibers often fall into the eye and cause irritation. However, because it is waterproof, the removal process can be harsh if you aren't careful, which is usually what causes the irritation, rather than the product itself.
Practical Steps for Best Results
If you're ready to pick up a tube, here is how you actually get the most out of it without ruining your lashes.
- Curl first. This formula is heavy. If you don't curl your lashes before applying, the weight of the wax might pull them down. Use a curler, hold for ten seconds, then apply.
- One eye at a time. Don't jump back and forth. Finish two coats on the right eye, then move to the left. If the first coat dries completely, the second coat will be a clumpy mess.
- Check the "Discard" date. There is a tiny icon on the back of the tube that looks like an open jar with "3M" or "6M" inside. Follow it. If the mascara starts to smell like vinegar or gets excessively chunky, toss it.
- Invest in a lash comb. If you do go overboard, a metal lash comb can save the day. Swipe it through while the mascara is still tacky to separate any "twinned" lashes.
- Nightly Maintenance. Since waterproof mascara is taxing on lashes, use a tiny drop of castor oil or a lash serum on your clean lashes before bed to keep them conditioned.
L'Oreal Voluminous Waterproof Mascara isn't a trend. It’s a tool. It’s the hammer in your toolbox—reliable, effective, and worth the space in your drawer. While other brands try to reinvent the wheel every season, this formula just keeps doing what it was designed to do in 1992: make lashes look thick and stay that way until you decide otherwise.