You’re driving through Perry County and honestly, it feels like you've stepped back about fifty years. The roads wind past old farmhouses and rolling hills that look exactly like a postcard from the 1970s. Then, you see the sign. Most people just blow right past it on their way to the bigger parks like Ricketts Glen or Pine Creek Gorge, but they’re missing out. Little Buffalo State Park isn't just another patch of woods with a lake. It is a weirdly perfect blend of industrial history, massive swimming pools, and some of the quietest hiking trails in the mid-state.
I’ve spent a lot of time talking to locals about this place. They’ll tell you the same thing: it’s the "locals' park." While the tourists are fighting for parking spots at the bigger parks, people here are just hanging out by the grist mill.
The Massive Pool vs. Holman Lake
Let's get the obvious stuff out of the way first. Most families come here for the pool. It’s huge. We are talking about a half-acre swimming pool with two water slides and a sprayground. It’s the kind of place where you can actually find a spot for your towel without accidentally sitting on a stranger’s lap. But here is the thing—the pool is only open from Memorial Day to Labor Day. If you show up in October thinking you’re going for a dip, you’re out of luck.
Then there’s Holman Lake.
It’s about 88 acres. Not huge, but big enough. It’s a "Big Bass" lake, which means there are strict regulations on what you can keep. If you're looking to catch a monster largemouth, this is your spot. I’ve seen people pull out some genuinely impressive fish near the dam. You can’t use internal combustion engines here. It’s electric motors only. This keeps the lake quiet. It’s peaceful. You don't have the constant whirrr of jet skis ruining the vibe.
Kayaking here is top-tier. You can rent them right there at the boat rental near the East Shore. Pro tip: go early in the morning when the mist is still sitting on the water. The way the light hits the lily pads on the western end of the lake is basically a religious experience.
✨ Don't miss: Taking the Ferry to Williamsburg Brooklyn: What Most People Get Wrong
History You Can Actually Touch
Most state parks have a little plaque that says "a guy built a shed here in 1802." Little Buffalo is different. It’s home to Shoaff’s Mill. This isn't a replica. It’s a real, honest-to-god water-powered grist mill built around 1840.
The coolest part? It still works.
If you visit during one of the Apple Festival weekends in October, you can watch them grind corn into cornmeal using the massive water wheel. It's loud, it smells like wet wood and grain, and it's fascinating. The mill was powered by a "breast-shot" water wheel, which is a bit of a nerd detail, but it basically means the water hits the wheel at the center rather than the top or bottom.
The Blue Ball Tavern
Just up the road from the mill is the Blue Ball Tavern Museum. It’s located on the site of an original tavern that served travelers on the road between Newport and Landisburg. The Perry County Historical Society runs it now. It’s full of artifacts that show how rugged life was back then. It wasn't all cozy fires and quilting bees; it was hard labor and mud.
Trails That Don't Kill Your Knees
If you’re looking for vertical climbs that make your lungs burn, go to the Adirondacks. Little Buffalo is for the "stroller and sandwich" crowd, and I mean that in the best way possible.
🔗 Read more: Lava Beds National Monument: What Most People Get Wrong About California's Volcanic Underworld
- The Little Buffalo Creek Trail: It’s about a mile long. It follows the old Newport and Sherman’s Valley Railroad bed. It’s flat. It’s easy. It’s beautiful.
- The Middle Ridge Trail: This one is a bit longer, maybe 2.5 miles. It gives you some elevation so you can actually see the lake through the trees.
- Fisherman’s Path: Exactly what it sounds like. It hugs the shoreline. Great for finding those little hidden fishing holes that aren't on the official maps.
The wildlife here is surprisingly bold. I’ve had white-tailed deer just stand there and stare at me from twenty feet away. If you’re into birding, keep your eyes peeled for ospreys and the occasional bald eagle. They hunt the lake constantly.
What People Get Wrong About Little Buffalo
People think it’s just a "day-use" park.
Wrong.
The campground is actually one of the best-maintained in the Pennsylvania state park system. There are about 40 sites. Some have electric hookups; some are just for tents. They even have these "glamping" cottages if you hate sleeping on the ground. But you have to book them months in advance. If you try to do a walk-in on a Friday night in July, the ranger is just going to laugh at you—politely, of course.
Another misconception is that the park is boring in the winter. Honestly, winter might be my favorite time there. When Holman Lake freezes over (and the rangers confirm the ice thickness), the ice fishing is incredible. There’s something deeply satisfying about sitting on a bucket in the middle of a frozen lake with a thermos of coffee.
💡 You might also like: Road Conditions I40 Tennessee: What You Need to Know Before Hitting the Asphalt
The Covered Bridge Obsession
You can't talk about Perry County without talking about covered bridges. Clay’s Covered Bridge is right there in the park. It was moved there to save it from being destroyed when they built the dam for the lake back in the early 70s. It’s a Burr Truss bridge.
It’s 82 feet long and painted that classic barn red. It’s the centerpiece of about a million engagement photos every year, but for good reason. It’s a stunning piece of engineering that reminds you how much effort people used to put into things that were basically just "roofs for roads."
Why It Actually Matters
In a world where everything is "optimized" and "disrupted," Little Buffalo State Park is just... there. It doesn't try to be a theme park. It doesn't have Wi-Fi (well, the signal is spotty at best, which is a blessing). It’s a place where you can teach a kid to tie a fishing knot or show them how a water wheel turns grain into flour. It’s a physical link to a Pennsylvania that is slowly disappearing.
The park covers about 923 acres. It’s not the biggest. It’s not the wildest. But it’s the most accessible version of the Pennsylvania outdoors you can find. Whether you are there for the history, the swimming, or just to sit on a bench and look at the water, it delivers.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
If you are planning a trip, do these three things to make sure it doesn't suck:
- Check the Mill Schedule: If you want to see the water wheel turning, call the park office first. It doesn't run every day. It’s usually seasonal and dependent on water levels and volunteer availability.
- Bring Your Own Gear: The boat rentals are great, but they can get pricey if you have a big family. If you have your own kayak, there are two easy-access launch points on the lake.
- Explore the "Back" Side: Most people congregate near the pool and the mill. If you want actual solitude, head to the western end of the park near the Black Rock area. The trails there are much quieter and the woods feel deeper.
- Download Offline Maps: Cell service in Perry County is notoriously flaky. Don't rely on your GPS to get you back to the highway. Download the area on Google Maps before you leave home.
Little Buffalo is the kind of place that grows on you. It’s not flashy, but it’s consistent. It’s the reliable friend of the Pennsylvania State Park system. Go for the swimming, stay for the history, and don't forget to grab some local ice cream in Newport on your way out.