Honestly, if you grew up in the late 90s or early 2000s, your backpack probably smelled like a chaotic mix of pencil shavings and the spicy, sweet scent of Lip Smacker Dr Pepper. It wasn’t just a lip balm. It was a lifestyle. You’ve probably spent hours scouring the aisles of CVS or Target lately, looking for that specific maroon tube, only to realize something is... different.
The rumors are true, and they're kinda heartbreaking for the purists. The original formula—the one that actually tasted like the 23 flavors of the legendary Texas soda—is effectively a ghost. While "Dr Pepper" flavored balms still exist in various multipacks, the heavy-hitter status of the Lip Smacker Dr Pepper we all loved has shifted significantly since the brand changed hands.
💡 You might also like: Yes or No Horoscope: Why Your Quick Answer Might Be Written in the Stars
The Day the Fizz Went Flat
Back in 1975, Bonne Bell did something wild. They partnered with Dr Pepper to create the world’s first soda-flavored lip balm. It was a massive gamble. Most people at the time thought putting soda on your face was weird, but Jess A. Bell, the trailblazer behind the brand, saw the vision.
It worked. Oh, did it work.
For forty years, this specific flavor was the "it girl" of the drugstore beauty world. It gave your lips this perfect, sheer reddish-brown tint that wasn't quite a lipstick but was way better than a clear balm. It was the "black honey" of the middle school set.
Then came 2015.
That was the year Markwins Beauty Brands acquired Bonne Bell and Lip Smacker. For a while, things seemed okay. But around 2020, the licensing agreements shifted, and the "Biggy" tubes and standalone Dr Pepper sticks started vanishing from major retailers.
What Really Happened to the Flavor?
If you buy a tube today, you might notice it doesn't hit the same. You're not crazy.
Collectors and longtime fans have noted that the post-acquisition formula often leans more "generic cherry cola" than the complex, spicy Dr Pepper profile. The original Bonne Bell version actually contained collagen peptides early on (weirdly ahead of its time!) and had a richer, waxier texture that stayed put.
"It basically became a flat, generic flavor that didn't resemble Dr Pepper at all when the manufacturing changed," says one devotee on a popular collector forum.
The tint changed too. The OG gave you a "just bitten" look. The new stuff? Sometimes it's too pink, or sometimes it's barely there at all.
👉 See also: The Semitic Language Family Tree: Why Arabic and Hebrew Are Closer Than You Think
Why We Are Still Obsessed
Why do we care so much about a three-dollar stick of wax?
Nostalgia is a hell of a drug. Lip Smacker Dr Pepper is tied to specific memories for millions: the first day of high school, sleepovers, the smell of a specific era. It’s one of the few beauty products that has a "cult" following spanning three generations.
- The Tint: It was the perfect low-effort makeup.
- The Scent: It actually smelled like the soda, not just sugar.
- The Status: Having the "Biggy" size was a flex before "flexing" was a word.
How to Find the Real Deal (Or the Best Dupes)
If you're desperate for that hit of 1975 nostalgia, you have a few options, but they aren't all great.
- The Secondary Market: You can find "vintage" Bonne Bell tubes on eBay or Etsy. Be warned: they are expensive. We’re talking $30 to $50 for a single tube of expired lip balm. Is it worth it? For the scent, maybe. For your skin? Probably not.
- The Taste Beauty Alternative: Sometimes you'll see Dr Pepper balms made by a company called Taste Beauty. They hold some licensing now. It's... fine. It's a balm. But it lacks that specific Bonne Bell "grip" and the deep tint.
- The Glossier "Cherry" Connection: For a while, people swore Glossier’s Cherry Balm Dotcom was the spiritual successor. It had the tint and the medicinal cherry vibe. But then Glossier reformulated (and then reverted), making the hunt even more confusing.
The Actionable Verdict
If you are looking for that classic Lip Smacker Dr Pepper experience in 2026, don't just grab the first soda-themed multipack you see at a discount store. Look closely at the packaging. If it doesn't have the classic Lip Smacker logo and the specific Dr Pepper branding, it's a knockoff that will likely smell like floor cleaner and disappointment.
Your best bet today? Look for the Lip Smacker Soda Pop variety packs that specifically list Dr Pepper. While it might not be the exact 1975 recipe, it’s the closest "official" version left on the market.
Next Steps for the Nostalgic:
- Check the Batch: If you find a tube in the wild, look for the Markwins vs. Bonne Bell branding on the back to know which "era" of flavor you're getting.
- Store It Right: If you do find an original Bonne Bell tube, keep it in a cool, dark place. The oils in the original formula can go rancid over time, losing that spicy scent we all crave.
- Vote With Your Wallet: Brands like Markwins do listen to social media trends. If the demand for the "Original 1975 Formula" stays high enough on TikTok and Instagram, "heritage" re-releases are always a possibility.
The original Lip Smacker Dr Pepper was a lightning-in-a-bottle moment for beauty marketing. It proved that a product didn't have to be expensive to be iconic. It just had to be "original"—and as the old Dr Pepper slogan says, it truly was the most original soft drink (and lip balm) ever.