Independent cinema is often a gamble of ego versus empathy. Usually, the ego wins. But every so often, a film arrives that feels less like a polished product and more like a raw nerve exposed to the air. That’s exactly what happened when Like You Mean It first started making waves in the festival circuit. It didn’t have a Marvel budget. It didn’t have A-list stars. What it had was a level of emotional honesty that felt almost intrusive to watch.
Relationships are messy. We know this. Yet, movies usually give us the "movie" version of a breakup—the dramatic rain-soaked speeches and the perfectly timed tears. This film skipped all that. Philipp Karner, who didn't just star in the thing but also wrote and directed it, seemed interested in the quiet, ugly parts of falling out of love. It’s a film about the moments between the fights. It’s about the silence in a car when you realize you have nothing left to say to the person sitting three inches away from you.
The Raw Reality of Mark and Jonah
At its core, Like You Mean It follows Mark, an actor living in Los Angeles who is basically spiraling. His career is stalling, which is a trope we’ve seen a thousand times, but here it feels grounded. It isn't "glamorous" struggling; it’s the kind of struggle that makes you bitter at your partner's success. He’s in a long-term relationship with Jonah, played by Denver Milord. On paper, they should be fine. In reality, they are vibrating on completely different frequencies.
Mark is struggling with his father’s declining health. He’s struggling with his own identity. And most painfully, he’s struggling to feel anything for the man he lives with.
Have you ever tried to force yourself to feel an emotion that just isn’t there anymore? It’s exhausting. The film captures that exhaustion perfectly. It isn't about some massive betrayal or a secret affair. It’s about the slow, agonizing erosion of intimacy. You watch them navigate a dinner party or a simple conversation in the kitchen, and the tension is so thick you want to look away.
Karner’s direction is intentionally claustrophobic. He uses tight shots. He lingers on faces long after the dialogue has stopped. It makes you feel like an accidental voyeur in a crumbling apartment.
✨ Don't miss: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
Why the Queer Narrative Matters Here
It is worth noting that while this is a "gay film" by classification, it refuses to be a "Gay Movie" by trope.
There’s no coming-out trauma. No one is dying of a tragic disease. The conflict isn't about their sexuality; it’s about their humanity. By 2015, when the film was making its rounds at festivals like Outfest, this felt like a massive step forward for representation. It allowed queer characters to be just as bored, selfish, and emotionally stunted as anyone else.
The specificity of the Los Angeles setting adds another layer. L.A. is a city built on artifice. Everyone is "performing" something. Mark’s job as an actor serves as a heavy-handed but effective metaphor for his personal life. He’s performing the role of a loving partner because he doesn't know how to stop.
Technical Choices and the "No Budget" Aesthetic
A lot of people ask how a film this small gets noticed. Honestly? It's the performances. When you don't have money for cranes and explosions, your actors have to carry the entire weight of the narrative.
Philipp Karner took a huge risk by casting himself. Usually, that’s a recipe for a vanity project. But Karner is surprisingly unsparing with himself. Mark is not always a likable guy. He’s prickly. He’s dismissive. He’s self-absorbed.
🔗 Read more: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
- The Cinematography: It’s grainy. It’s naturalistic. It looks like life, not a commercial.
- The Dialogue: People talk over each other. They mumble. They leave sentences unfinished.
- The Pacing: It’s slow. Some might say too slow. But the pacing mimics the feeling of a relationship in limbo—where days bleed into weeks and nothing changes, yet everything is different.
Critics often compared it to the works of Andrew Haigh, specifically Weekend. There’s a shared DNA there—the idea that the most profound things happen in the mundane. But where Weekend was about the beginning of something, Like You Mean It is firmly about the end.
The Logistics of Indie Distribution
Let's talk about the reality of making a film like this. It didn't have a 2,000-screen theatrical release. It relied on the "long tail" of digital distribution and the prestige of the festival circuit. Winning awards at places like the Florida Film Festival or getting a nod at Outfest isn't just about the trophy; it's about the distribution deals that follow.
For an independent creator, this film is a case study in "write what you know." Karner clearly pulled from a deep well of personal experience. You can't fake the specific kind of sadness found in this script.
The film also features solid supporting work from people like Kelly Schumacher and Sheila Shaw. They provide the "outside world" perspective that highlights just how insulated and toxic Mark and Jonah’s bubble has become. When they interact with friends, you see the masks go on. It’s a relatable bit of social theater that anyone who has been in a dying relationship will recognize instantly.
Common Misconceptions About the Film
- It’s a "Boring" Movie: If you need a plot-driven thriller, yeah, you’ll be bored. If you like character studies, it’s riveting.
- It’s Depressing: It’s heavy, sure. But there’s a certain catharsis in seeing the truth on screen.
- It’s Only for a Queer Audience: While it’s a staple of LGBTQ+ cinema, the themes of career anxiety and emotional disconnection are universal.
What We Can Learn from Mark’s Journey
Watching Mark navigate his grief—both for his father and for his relationship—is a masterclass in avoidant behavior. He tries to fix things by not talking about them. He tries to move forward by standing still.
💡 You might also like: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
There is a specific scene involving a phone call that gut-punches most viewers. It’s simple. No music. Just a man realizing that the support system he thought he had is actually just a ghost.
The film’s title, Like You Mean It, becomes a haunting refrain. It’s a plea. It’s a demand. Touch me like you mean it. Talk to me like you mean it. Stay with me like you mean it. When those actions become chores, the relationship is already over; the characters just haven't signed the paperwork yet.
Key Takeaways for Aspiring Filmmakers
If you're looking at this film as a blueprint, take note of the economy of storytelling. You don't need a lot of locations. You need one location that feels lived-in. You don't need 50 actors. You need two people with genuine chemistry—or in this case, genuine anti-chemistry.
The sound design is also worth a mention. Or rather, the lack of it. The "room tone" of their apartment becomes a character. The hum of the refrigerator, the distant sound of traffic—it all adds to the feeling of being stuck.
The Legacy of the Film
Is it the greatest film ever made? No. But it is a deeply sincere one. In a world of algorithmic content designed to please everyone and offend no one, a movie that is willing to be uncomfortable is a gift.
It reminds us that the "mid-budget" or "low-budget" drama is a vital part of the cultural ecosystem. These are the films that explore the nuances of the human condition that blockbusters simply don't have time for.
Next Steps for the Viewer:
- Watch for the subtext: Pay attention to what Mark and Jonah don't say. The best parts of the script are the silences.
- Compare with modern indies: Look at how films like Passages (2023) or All of Us Strangers handle similar themes of intimacy and see how the language of queer cinema has evolved since Karner's film.
- Support independent creators: Seek out the film on VOD platforms or through specialized distributors like Wolfe Video, who often carry these kinds of gems.
- Reflect on the "Performance": After watching, think about the areas in your own life where you might be acting "like you mean it" instead of actually feeling it. It’s an uncomfortable exercise, but that’s exactly what the film intends.