You’re sailing through a storm near the edge of the map, the Jackdaw’s hull creaking under the pressure of rogue waves, when a massive silhouette cuts through the fog. It isn't just another Spanish Man o' War. It's something much worse. If you’ve spent any real time in Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag, you know that pit-in-your-stomach feeling. We're talking about the legendary ships black flag enthusiasts still swap horror stories about over a decade after the game launched.
These aren't your standard naval encounters. Ubisoft designed these four encounters (technically five ships) to be the ultimate skill check for Edward Kenway. They sit in the four corners of the Caribbean, waiting for players who think they’ve mastered the sea. Honestly, most people go in overconfident and end up as shark bait within ninety seconds. It’s a humbling experience.
The gap between a fully upgraded Jackdaw and these leviathans is massive. You can’t just broadside your way to victory. Each one requires a specific, almost rhythmic strategy that forces you to use every tool in your arsenal, from mortars to heavy shot.
The Twin Terrors: Fear the Brothers in Arms
Most players agree the hardest encounter is the northeast corner of the map. It's the Brothers in Arms. You aren't fighting one ship; you're fighting two maneuverable Man o' Wars, the Sovereign and the Fearless.
They flank you. That’s their whole thing. While you’re trying to line up a shot on one, the other is raking your stern with heavy shot. It’s chaotic. If you sink one too early, the remaining brother goes into a literal rage mode. It catches fire, gains a massive speed boost, and tries to ram you into oblivion. It's terrifying. To survive, you have to wear them both down simultaneously. Get them both to a sliver of health, then finish them off back-to-back. If you don't, that final "suicide charge" from the survivor will end your run before you can even celebrate.
El Impoluto: The Juggernaut of the North
Then there’s El Impoluto. Located in the northwest, this Spanish beast is essentially a floating battering ram. It’s faster than it has any right to be. In a game where positioning is everything, El Impoluto cheats. It will turn on a dime and charge at you with a reinforced prow that can take off half your health bar in a single hit.
✨ Don't miss: The Hunt: Mega Edition - Why This Roblox Event Changed Everything
The trick here is the chain shot. You have to stun it. If you aren't hitting those front sails to slow its momentum, you're dead. It’s a high-stakes game of chicken. You’ll find yourself desperately turning the wheel, praying the Jackdaw’s upgrades are enough to scrape by as that massive hull whistles past your ears.
Many players make the mistake of trying to distance themselves. Don't. El Impoluto is actually more dangerous at mid-range because it has room to build up speed for a ram. Stay close, use your fire barrels to discourage the charge, and never, ever let it get a straight line of sight on your broadside.
The Ghostly Resilience of La Dama Negra
Down in the southwest, you’ll find La Dama Negra. She’s different. While the other legendary ships black flag features rely on speed or numbers, this one is a tank. Her side armor is practically invulnerable. If you fire your cannons at her hull, you’ll just see sparks and a lot of wasted ammo.
The only way to hurt her is from the back. Her stern is her only weakness.
The catch? She has mortars that don't behave like yours. There are no "red circles" on the water to show you where the shells will land. You have to look up. You have to watch the sky and judge the trajectory while simultaneously trying to maneuver behind a ship that is constantly trying to turn away from you. It’s a slow, agonizing fight of attrition. It’s about patience. If you get greedy and try to stay behind her for too long, she’ll drop fire barrels that act like sea mines, blowing your bow apart.
🔗 Read more: Why the GTA San Andreas Motorcycle is Still the Best Way to Get Around Los Santos
HMS Prince: The Fog of War
Finally, there’s the HMS Prince in the southeast. Compared to the others, the Prince feels like a more "traditional" fight, but the environment is the real enemy. The area is perpetually shrouded in thick fog. You’ll hear her before you see her.
The Prince uses long-range mortars and heavy broadsides. Because visibility is so low, you often find yourself sailing directly into her line of fire without realizing it. It’s a ghost story come to life. The key here is the mini-map. In this specific fight, your eyes will lie to you, but the radar won’t. Keep track of her red icon and try to keep the wind at your back. Speed is your only defense against her mortar spam.
Why These Fights Still Matter Today
Why are we still talking about these ships? Because Black Flag’s naval combat hasn't really been topped. Even later titles like Assassin's Creed Rogue or the more recent Skull and Bones struggle to capture the same weight and tension.
The legendary ships black flag encounters represent a peak in "boss design" for open-world games. They aren't just bigger versions of regular enemies. They are mechanical puzzles. They force you to stop playing the way you’ve played for forty hours and learn a new language of naval warfare.
Winning these fights isn't just about the 20,000 Reales reward. It’s about the "Devil of the Caribbean" trophy and the genuine sense of accomplishment. When you see that final ship sink into the turquoise water, you know you've actually mastered the game.
💡 You might also like: Dandys World Ship Chart: What Most People Get Wrong
How to Prepare Your Jackdaw
Don't even think about engaging these ships until you are 100% upgraded. You need the Elite Hull, the Elite Mortars, and especially the Elite Heavy Shot.
- Prioritize the Elite Hull. You cannot dodge every hit. You need the HP to soak up mistakes.
- Stock your ammo. Every single legendary fight is an ammo sink. If you go in with 50% mortars, you’ve already lost.
- Master the Bracing. It sounds simple, but timing your "brace" (holding the button just before impact) reduces damage significantly. Against El Impoluto, a well-timed brace is the difference between desynchronization and survival.
- Use the Wind. Always check the wind direction before engaging. If you are sailing against the wind, you lose your maneuverability, and in these fights, speed is life.
Final Tactics for Success
If you're struggling, remember that the AI has patterns. The Brothers in Arms will always try to sandwich you. La Dama Negra will always prioritize keeping her distance so she can use her mortars.
One "pro tip" that many people miss: use your swivel guns on the weak points. When you land a heavy shot and the red target appears, hit it immediately. It deals massive "bonus" damage that bypasses some of the legendary armor ratings.
Also, don't be afraid to run. If a fight is going south, sail out of the mission zone. You’ll lose your progress in that specific battle, but you won't lose your cargo or have to reload a long save.
Tackling the legendary ships black flag challenges is the definitive end-game experience. It turns a fun pirate romp into a genuine test of grit. Take your time, upgrade your ship, and remember: the sea doesn't forgive mistakes, and neither do these ships.
To finish your conquest of the Caribbean, focus on the Prince first to build confidence, then move to La Dama Negra. Save the Brothers and El Impoluto for last; they are the true gatekeepers of the pirate legend status. Once they are all at the bottom of the ocean, you've officially earned your place among the most feared captains in history.