Malinda Lo didn’t just write a book. She basically built a time machine. When Last Night at the Telegraph Club hit shelves, it felt like a shift in the Young Adult landscape. People were used to historical fiction being a bit... dry. Stiff. This was different. It’s 1954. San Francisco. The Red Scare is making everyone paranoid, and Lily Hu is just trying to figure out why she feels so drawn to a girl named Kathleen Merritt and a neon sign in North Beach.
History isn't just dates. It's smells. It's the sound of a specific record player. Lo spends pages grounding us in the fog of the Bay Area and the specific, claustrophobic tension of being Chinese American during the McCarthy era. You feel the stakes. They aren't "YA stakes" where a breakup feels like the end of the world. Here, a "wrong" association could literally get your father deported. It’s heavy stuff, honestly.
The Reality of San Francisco’s Queer History
Most people think of the Castro when they think of LGBTQ+ history in San Francisco. But in the 1950s? It was all about North Beach. The Telegraph Club in the novel isn't a real place you can visit today, but it’s a composite of legendary spots like Mona’s 440 Club. Mona’s was the first lesbian bar in the city, where women wore tuxedos and lived lives that the rest of the world tried to pretend didn't exist.
Lo did the homework. She spent years digging through the San Francisco Public Library’s James C. Hormel LGBTQIA Center. This matters because the "vibe" of the book is rooted in actual police raids and the very real "three-piece law." Back then, you could be arrested if you weren't wearing at least three items of "gender-appropriate" clothing. Imagine the courage it took to just walk down the street.
Lily Hu’s journey isn't a vacuum. She’s navigating the intersection of being a daughter of immigrants and a woman realizing she’s queer in a decade that demanded conformity. The Red Scare adds this terrifying layer. Because Lily’s father is a physician, the threat of losing his citizenship due to perceived "subversive" activities is a constant shadow. It makes the romance with Kath feel both beautiful and incredibly dangerous.
Why the Science Element Matters
Lily wants to work at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory. She’s a math nerd. In 1954, that was a radical dream for a woman, let alone a Chinese American woman. The book weaves in the history of the "human computers"—the women who did the complex orbital mechanics by hand before digital computers were a thing.
👉 See also: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
It’s a cool parallel. Lily is looking at the stars, trying to calculate the infinite, while her personal life is being squeezed into the smallest possible box. The inclusion of the "X-15" and the race for space flight isn't just window dressing. It represents the future. A future Lily wants to be part of, even if the present is trying to hold her back.
Addressing the Misconceptions About 1950s San Francisco
A lot of folks assume the 50s were just "Leave It to Beaver" style boredom. Last Night at the Telegraph Club destroys that myth. The city was a powder keg. You had the Beat poets starting to hang out in City Lights Bookstore (which opened in '53, right before the book's setting). You had the vibrant, complex social hierarchies of Chinatown.
And you had the "Tommy-girls."
That was the slang for butch women back then. Lo doesn't sanitize this. She shows the internal politics of the queer community—how some women passed as straight during the day and changed their lives at night. It wasn't a monolith. There was tension between different classes and races even within the safety of the bars.
The Accuracy of the Red Scare
People forget how much the 1950s targeted the Chinese community specifically. The "Confession Program" was a real thing. The government encouraged Chinese immigrants to admit they had entered the country illegally (often as "paper sons") in exchange for a chance at legal status, but it was often used to entrap people and find "communist sympathizers."
✨ Don't miss: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa
When Lily’s family faces the confiscation of her father’s passport, that’s not dramatic license. That was the lived reality for thousands. It highlights a specific type of American trauma where loyalty is always questioned. Lo handles this with a surgical touch, showing how the macroscopic politics of DC trickled down into a teenage girl’s bedroom in Chinatown.
The Impact on Modern Literature
Winning the National Book Award for Young People’s Literature was a huge deal. It was the first time a book with a queer AAPI protagonist took that top prize. It signaled that these "niche" stories are actually universal.
The prose is deceptive. It’s simple but carries a massive emotional weight. One minute you're reading about the best way to cook char siu, and the next, you're hit with the realization that Lily might lose her entire family if she stays true to herself. It’s that contrast that keeps people talking about it years after its release.
- The Research: Lo included a massive bibliography in the back.
- The Language: She uses Cantonese phrases naturally, without over-explaining for the "white gaze."
- The Ending: It’s hopeful but realistic. It doesn't promise a "happily ever after" because, in 1955, that wasn't really an option for people like Lily and Kath. It promises a "maybe."
Practical Ways to Dive Deeper Into the History
If you finished the book and felt a void, you aren't alone. Most people want to know what happened next or if the world was really like that.
First, look up the "Wide Open Town" history of San Francisco. There are walking tours that cover the North Beach area specifically through a queer lens. Second, check out the GLBT Historical Society’s digital archives. They have photos of the actual bars that inspired the Telegraph Club.
🔗 Read more: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
Read Forbidden City, USA by Arthur Dong. It’s about the Chinese American nightclub scene in San Francisco during the 30s, 40s, and 50s. It gives a lot of visual context to the world Lily grew up in.
Lastly, look into the history of the "Paper Sons." Understanding how Chinese immigrants had to navigate the Exclusion Act explains why Lily’s father is so terrified of the FBI. It wasn't just paranoia; it was a survival strategy.
The best way to honor a book like this is to actually learn the history it's based on. The stories of the people who frequented the real Telegraph Clubs are mostly lost, but books like this keep the memory of their bravery alive. It’s a reminder that we’ve always been here, even when the laws tried to say otherwise.
Actionable Next Steps for Readers and Researchers
To truly appreciate the context of the novel, start by exploring the James C. Hormel LGBTQIA Center’s online collections to see the primary documents Lo used. If you're a writer or history buff, use the "Map of Chinatown" resources available through the San Francisco Planning Department to see how the neighborhood's boundaries and landmarks have shifted since 1954. Finally, support the preservation of Asian American history by visiting the Chinese Historical Society of America; they frequently host exhibits that mirror the exact cultural tensions Lily Hu navigated.