You’re driving through the Chihuahuan Desert, the sun is hammering the pavement, and suddenly you see the adobe walls of Old Mesilla. It feels like stepping back into 1850. Honestly, most "historic" restaurants feel like a tourist trap with overpriced burgers, but La Posta de Mesilla Mesilla NM is different. It’s a labyrinth. You walk through those heavy wooden doors and immediately get hit by the smell of roasting chiles and the sound of tropical birds. Yes, birds. There is a literal aviary in the lobby with macaws and piranhas in a tank nearby. It’s chaotic, loud, and smells like heaven.
People come here for the history, but they stay because the food hasn't really changed since Katy Griggs Camuñez opened the place in 1939 with just four tables and a dirt floor.
It’s located in a building that dates back to the 1840s. This isn't just a restaurant; it was a station for the Butterfield Overland Mail Stagecoach Line. Imagine Billy the Kid or Pancho Villa walking these same halls. Actually, they probably did. Mesilla was the capital of the Arizona-New Mexico Territory at one point, and this specific building was the heart of it all.
The Real Deal on the Menu
If you’re looking for "Tex-Mex," go somewhere else. This is authentic New Mexican cuisine. There is a massive difference. Here, it’s all about the chile. Specifically, the Hatch chile grown just a few miles up the road.
The Tostada Compuesta is what put them on the map. It’s basically a corn tortilla cup filled with beans, meat, and topped with their signature red or green chile. If you can’t decide on the sauce, just ask for "Christmas style." That gets you both. The red chile is earthy, deep, and has a slow burn. The green is bright, sharp, and hits you right in the back of the throat. It’s addictive.
💡 You might also like: Flights to Chicago O'Hare: What Most People Get Wrong
Then there are the sopaipillas. Most places serve them as a dessert with honey. At La Posta, they come with the meal. They’re pillowy, hot, and perfect for mopping up whatever sauce is left on your plate. You’ll see locals ripping them open and stuffing them with beans. That’s the pro move.
What Most People Get Wrong About the History
People often think La Posta has always been this massive complex. It wasn't. It grew organically, room by room, as Katy bought up adjacent parts of the old adobe building. This is why the floor plan makes zero sense. You’ll be walking to your table and end up in a room that feels like someone’s grandmother’s living room, then pass through a sun-drenched patio, then end up in a dark, moody bar area.
The "Corn Exchange" section of the building is perhaps the most significant. Back in the day, this was where traders swapped goods. You can still feel the thickness of the walls—some are over two feet thick. That’s how they kept things cool before air conditioning existed.
Why the Margaritas Actually Matter
A lot of high-volume restaurants coast on cheap tequila and sugary mixers. Not here. The tequila list at La Posta is intimidating. They have over 100 varieties. If you go to the Adobe Tequila Bar inside the restaurant, you’re getting a lesson in agave.
📖 Related: Something is wrong with my world map: Why the Earth looks so weird on paper
They use fresh lime juice. It sounds simple, but it changes everything. Try the "Organic Margarita" or something with a mezcal float if you want that smoky finish. It’s the kind of drink that makes you want to cancel the rest of your road trip and just stay in Mesilla for three days.
The Atmosphere is Polarizing
I’ve heard people complain that it’s too loud or that the wait times are insane. Both are true. On a Saturday night, you might be waiting an hour. But that’s part of the experience. You hang out in the lobby, look at the parrots, check out the black-and-white photos of the Camuñez family, and soak in the humidity from the indoor fountains.
It’s a sensory overload. The floors are uneven. The lighting is dim in some spots and bright in others. It feels alive. It’s the opposite of a sterile, corporate chain restaurant where every chair is bolted down in a specific spot.
Navigating the Old Mesilla Plaza
Once you’ve stuffed yourself with enchiladas, you have to walk it off. La Posta is just a few steps away from the Basica of San Albino. This church is the soul of the town. Even if you aren't religious, the architecture is stunning.
👉 See also: Pic of Spain Flag: Why You Probably Have the Wrong One and What the Symbols Actually Mean
The plaza itself is a National Historic Landmark. There are little shops selling silver jewelry, local art, and, of course, bags of dried chiles. It’s quiet. Unlike the plaza in Santa Fe, which can feel a bit like a high-end outdoor mall, Mesilla still feels like a dusty border town that happens to have incredible food.
The Legend of Katy Griggs
You can't talk about La Posta without talking about Katy. She was a powerhouse. In a time when women rarely ran major businesses, she turned a tiny snack bar into a multi-million dollar landmark. She was known for her hospitality, but also for her strict standards. She used her mother's recipes, and those recipes are supposedly still locked in a vault.
There's a story that she used to walk through the dining rooms making sure everyone was happy. That spirit of "mi casa es su casa" is still the goal, even though the restaurant now feeds hundreds of people a day.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
- Go for Lunch: If you want to avoid the two-hour dinner rush, hit it up at 11:30 AM. You’ll get a table immediately and the service is much faster.
- Check the Gift Shop: It’s actually good. They sell the actual chile pods and powders they use in the kitchen. Buy the "Extra Hot" green chile powder to take home.
- The Chile Meat Sauce: If you’re a fan of traditional New Mexican flavors, order the Red Chile Meat. It’s slow-simmered pork that melts.
- Parking Hack: Don't try to park right on the plaza. It’s a nightmare. There is a large dirt lot just a block behind the restaurant. It's easier and you won't get your door dinged.
- Order the Chile con Queso: It’s the standard starter, but they do it right. It’s thick, creamy, and loaded with chopped green chiles.
If you’re passing through Las Cruces or driving I-10 across the country, skipping Mesilla is a mistake. It’s one of those rare places that actually lives up to the hype. You’ll leave smelling like woodsmoke and cumin, with a slight burn on your tongue and a better understanding of what the Southwest used to be.
Experience the history by walking through the different "rooms"—each has its own name and distinct vibe based on the building's 180-year evolution. Whether you sit in the Garden Plaza or the more formal dining rooms, take a second to look at the vigas (ceiling beams). They’ve seen more history than most museums.