Let's be honest. Most lip balms are just glorified wax sticks that sit on top of your skin and do absolutely nothing once they wear off. You've been there. You apply a cheap stick every twenty minutes, yet your lips still feel like sandpaper by noon. It's frustrating.
Then there is the Kiehl's Butterstick Lip Balm.
If you haven't tried it, you’re likely wondering why a single tube of lip treatment costs more than a decent lunch. I used to think the same thing. I figured it was just the brand name. But after years of testing everything from high-end French pharmacy creams to drugstore staples, this specific formula remains a standout for a very simple reason: it actually sinks in. It doesn't just coat; it treats.
The Science of the Squeeze: What’s Actually Inside?
Most people think "butter" is just a marketing term. For Kiehl's, it’s a literal description of the ingredient deck. The heavy lifter here is Coconut Oil, often referred to as "the tree of life" in various cultures because of its insane fatty acid content. We aren't talking about the stuff you buy in a giant tub for frying eggs, though. This is highly refined, Fair Trade Coconut Oil that stays solid at room temperature but melts the second it hits 98.6 degrees—your body heat.
But the oil isn't the whole story.
The "butter" part of the Kiehl's Butterstick Lip Balm comes from Lemon Butter. This is an essential oil-rich butter sourced from California lemons. It’s naturally packed with antioxidants. Why does that matter for your mouth? Because your lips are incredibly thin. They don't have sweat glands. They don't have oil glands. They are constantly under attack from UV rays, wind, and the salt in your food. Adding an antioxidant barrier helps neutralize the environmental stress that causes premature aging—yes, "lip wrinkles" are a real thing people worry about now.
I’ve found that the texture is the real differentiator. It’s thick. Not "sticky-gloss" thick, but "nourishing-balm" thick. When you swipe it on, there’s a slight tug. That's good. It means it’s dense with emollients.
Why the SPF 30 Version is a Non-Negotiable
If you’re buying the untinted version, get the one with SPF 30. Seriously.
According to the Skin Cancer Foundation, the lower lip is significantly more likely to develop squamous cell carcinoma than the upper lip because of how it protrudes and catches the sun. Most people remember to put sunscreen on their nose and forehead, but they forget the one area that’s constantly exposed.
💡 You might also like: Human DNA Found in Hot Dogs: What Really Happened and Why You Shouldn’t Panic
The brilliance of the SPF 30 Kiehl's Butterstick Lip Balm is that it doesn't taste like chemicals. You know that weird, acrid "sunscreen taste" you get from cheap SPF balms? It’s absent here. It just tastes like a faint hint of lemon and vanilla. It’s subtle. It’s sophisticated.
Dealing with the Tinted Options
Kiehl's didn't just stop at hydration. They released several shades, like Rose, Simply Rose, and Berry.
Here is the thing about the tints: they are surprisingly pigmented. This isn't a "hint of a tint" that disappears into your natural lip color. The Berry shade, in particular, packs a punch. It’s perfect for those days when you have a Zoom call and look like a ghost but don’t want to commit to a full lipstick. It gives you that "I just ate a popsicle" flush that looks healthy and vibrant.
The Rose shade is more of a universal "your lips but better" pink. It’s what I recommend to people who are scared of color.
One caveat: because the formula is so buttery, the tinted versions can sometimes get a bit soft in the summer. If you leave this in a hot car in Phoenix, you’re going to have a melted mess on your hands. Keep it in your pocket or your bag. The soft texture is what makes it feel so good, but it’s also its Achilles' heel in extreme heat.
Kiehl's Butterstick Lip Balm vs. The Competition
Let’s look at the landscape. You have your Burt’s Bees, your Aquaphor, and your Laneige Lip Glowy Balms.
Burt’s Bees is great for a quick fix, but it’s heavy on the beeswax. Beeswax is an occlusive—it seals moisture in. But if your lips are already bone-dry, you’re just sealing in the dryness. You need a humectant or an emollient to actually add moisture first. That’s where the coconut oil in the Butterstick wins.
Aquaphor is the gold standard for healing. Honestly, if your lips are bleeding or cracked, just use Aquaphor. It’s boring, but it works. However, it’s greasy. You look like you just ate fried chicken. It’s not exactly a "look" for the office.
📖 Related: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
The Kiehl's Butterstick Lip Balm occupies that middle ground. It’s more decorative and pleasant to use than a medicated ointment, but it’s significantly more effective than a standard wax stick. It has a matte-to-satin finish. It looks like you have healthy lips, not like you're wearing a product. Men usually prefer the untinted version for this exact reason—it’s invisible but effective.
Real Talk on the Price Point
It’s expensive. There’s no getting around it. Spending $20+ on a lip balm feels like a luxury.
But consider this: how many $3 sticks have you lost or thrown away because they didn't work? If you use one high-quality product that actually prevents chapping, you use less of it over time. I’ve found that one tube of Kiehl's lasts me about four to five months of daily use.
The packaging also feels premium. It’s a soft-touch, screw-on cap. This is a massive detail that most people overlook. How many times has a lip balm cap popped off in your purse, only to get covered in lint and crumbs? The screw-top ensures the product stays clean and the cap stays put. It’s a small engineering win that justifies the price tag for me.
Sustainability and Sourcing
Kiehl’s has been making a bigger push toward "Future Made Better" initiatives. The coconut oil in this balm is sustainably sourced. This matters more than it used to. When you're buying a product you're essentially eating (since we ingest a huge percentage of what we put on our lips), knowing where the oils come from provides a bit of peace of mind.
They also focus on using minimal plastic where possible, though the tube is still the primary vessel. It’s a balance.
How to Get the Most Out of Your Application
Don't just swipe and go.
If your lips are really peeling, you need to exfoliate first. You can use a damp washcloth or a sugar scrub. Once the dead skin is gone, apply a thick layer of the Kiehl's Butterstick Lip Balm before you go to bed. Think of it as an overnight mask. When you wake up, your lips will be soft and ready for the day.
👉 See also: God Willing and the Creek Don't Rise: The True Story Behind the Phrase Most People Get Wrong
For daytime, I suggest applying it at the very start of your routine. Let it sink in while you do your hair or the rest of your makeup. By the time you’re ready to leave, the oils have penetrated the skin, leaving a smooth base.
If you like wearing matte liquid lipsticks—which are notoriously drying—this balm is a lifesaver. Apply it, let it sit for five minutes, blot off the excess, and then put on your matte lipstick. It creates a barrier so the lipstick doesn't suck the soul out of your skin.
The Verdict on Longevity
Does it stay on?
It lasts through a cup of coffee. It won't last through a burger. Because it’s oil-based, it breaks down with other oils. That’s just chemistry. But the hydration it leaves behind persists even after the physical layer of balm is gone. That’s the "treatment" aspect I mentioned earlier.
A lot of people complain that balms make their lips "addicted." This usually happens when products contain camphor or menthol, which can cause a cycle of irritation. The Butterstick doesn't have those. It relies on lipids. Your skin likes lipids.
Actionable Next Steps for Better Lips
If you're ready to move beyond basic drugstore sticks, here is how to integrate this into a routine that actually works:
- Audit your current stash. Throw away any balms that contain phenol, menthol, or salicylic acid if you have chronically dry lips. These are "medicated" ingredients that can actually cause more peeling if used long-term.
- Pick your "vibe." If you want a daily workhorse, get the Untinted SPF 30. If you want a low-maintenance makeup look, go for the Rose tint.
- Apply at night. The most important time for lip care is while you sleep. We breathe through our mouths at night, which dries out the lips instantly. A heavy coat of the Butterstick acts as a shield.
- Check the expiration. Because this contains natural oils and butters, it can go rancid after about 12 to 18 months. If it starts to smell like old crayons, it’s time to toss it and get a fresh one.
Kiehl's has been around since 1851 for a reason. They tend to stick to formulas that work rather than chasing every single trend. The Butterstick is a perfect example of that philosophy. It’s simple, it’s effective, and it actually feels like a treat every time you use it. Your lips will thank you, especially when the winter wind starts biting.