Kehlani has always been an open book. But in 2020, that book got a lot heavier. When Kehlani It Was Good Until It Wasn’t dropped right in the thick of a global lockdown, it didn't just feel like another album release. It felt like a collective exhale. We were all trapped inside, staring at our phones, dissecting our failed relationships, and Kehlani gave us the exact soundtrack for that specific brand of misery.
It’s messy. It’s vulnerable. Honestly, it’s a bit toxic in places, but that’s why it works.
The project didn't rely on the high-energy pop-R&B fusion of their previous work. Instead, it leaned into the shadows. It’s an album about the "after." After the honeymoon phase, after the trust breaks, and after you realize that the person you love might actually be the worst thing for you. Most artists try to polish their heartbreak to make it look cinematic. Kehlani kept the rough edges.
The Sound of Falling Apart
There’s a specific mood to this record. It’s hazy. You can almost feel the humidity in the production. Working with guys like Boi-1da and Jahaan Sweet, Kehlani moved away from the bright, radio-ready sheen of SweetSexySavage.
Take a track like "Toxic." It’s arguably one of the most honest songs about addictive relationships ever written. The bass is heavy, dragging its feet, mimicking that feeling of being stuck in a loop with someone you know is bad for you. Ty Dolla $ign provides these haunting background vocals that make the whole thing feel like a fever dream. It’s not a "fun" song. It’s a "staring at the ceiling at 3 AM" song.
Then you have "Can I." It’s smoother, sure, but there’s an underlying tension. The album moves like a conversation that starts calm and ends in a shouting match.
The pacing is deliberate. It’s short—only about 39 minutes. In an era where artists pack 25 tracks onto an album just to game the streaming charts, Kehlani kept it tight. Every song serves the narrative. There’s no filler. You’re either in the feelings or you’re out.
Why the Title Kehlani It Was Good Until It Wasn’t Hits So Hard
Titles matter. Sometimes they’re just catchy phrases, but this one is a thesis statement. It captures that precise moment when the red flags become impossible to ignore.
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Relationships don't usually end with a massive explosion. They erode. It’s a slow leak. One day you wake up and realize the "good" parts are outnumbered by the "wasn't" parts. Kehlani captures this transition perfectly on "Water." It’s fluid and beautiful, but it leads directly into the paranoia of tracks like "Bad News."
The album cover itself tells the story. Kehlani is standing in a backyard, looking over a fence with a garden hose in hand. It looks like a normal, domestic scene. But she’s looking at something we can’t see—something coming over the horizon. It’s the visual representation of waiting for the other shoe to drop.
The Quarentine Aesthetic and the DIY Videos
We have to talk about how this album was marketed. It was a masterclass in making the best of a bad situation. Because of the pandemic, big-budget music videos were out of the question. Kehlani just used their backyard.
These "Quarantine Style" videos were incredibly effective. They removed the barrier between the superstar and the fan. Seeing Kehlani dance in their garage or sit on their floor made the music feel more intimate. It stripped away the celebrity gloss. It made the lyrics about loneliness and longing feel authentic because, well, we were all lonely and longing for something back then.
"F&MU" is a great example. It’s a song about the cycle of fighting and making up. The video is simple, raw, and feels like a home movie. It shouldn't work as well as it does, but because the songwriting is so strong, you don't need the pyrotechnics.
Real Stories Behind the Tracks
This wasn't just fiction. Kehlani has been through the ringer in the public eye. From very public breakups to the complexities of motherhood, they’ve lived it.
The song "Lexii's Outro" is a heartbreaking tribute to the late Lexii Alijai. It grounds the album in a reality that’s bigger than just romantic drama. It’s about grief. It reminds the listener that while we’re obsessing over who texted who back, there are much more permanent losses happening.
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
And then there’s "Little Story." It’s one of the most stripped-back moments on the project. It shows a level of vocal maturity that some critics didn't think Kehlani had yet. They aren't oversinging. They’re just telling the truth.
The collaborations are also remarkably curated. You’ve got:
- Jhené Aiko on "Change Your Life," bringing that airy, California vibe.
- Masego on "Hate The Club," which captures that awkward feeling of going out just to see an ex.
- Lucky Daye on "Grieving," which is a soul-crushing look at the end of a long-term bond.
- James Blake on the "Everywhere & Nowhere" outro.
None of these features feel like they were bought for a check. They feel like friends coming over to help Kehlani process their trauma.
The Cultural Impact and Critical Reception
When Kehlani It Was Good Until It Wasn’t debuted at number two on the Billboard 200, it proved something important. R&B doesn't need to be upbeat to be successful. In fact, the genre is often at its best when it’s wallowing in the "blue" notes.
Critics praised the album for its cohesion. Rolling Stone and Pitchfork both noted that this felt like Kehlani’s "grown-up" record. They stopped trying to please everyone and started writing for themselves.
The album also signaled a shift in R&B trends. We started seeing more of this "lo-fi" aesthetic across the board. The influence of this record can be heard in a lot of the alternative R&B that has come out since 2020. It gave artists permission to be quiet.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Album
There’s a common misconception that this is just a "breakup album." That’s too simple.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
It’s actually an album about self-reflection. Kehlani isn't always the hero in these songs. Sometimes they’re the one causing the mess. On "Open (Passionate)," they admit to being difficult. On "Serial Lover," they acknowledge their own patterns of jumping from one person to the next.
It’s an album about accountability. It’s about looking in the mirror and realizing that if every relationship you have is "good until it isn't," maybe you’re the common denominator. That’s a heavy realization for a pop star to put on record.
Why You Should Still Be Listening
In 2026, the music landscape is faster than ever. Trends die in a week. But this album has stayed relevant because feelings don't go out of style. Toxic exes still exist. Loneliness still exists. The "good until it wasn't" cycle is a universal human experience.
If you’re revisiting the album today, notice the subtle details. The way the birds chirp at the end of some tracks. The muffled conversations in the background. It’s an immersive experience.
Actionable Insights for the R&B Fan
If you want to truly appreciate the depth of this era, don't just put the album on shuffle. R&B is an intentional genre. Here is how to actually digest the weight of this project:
- Listen in sequence. The transition from "Toxic" to "Can I" is vital. The album is structured like a timeline of a collapsing relationship.
- Watch the "Honey" and "Nights Like This" videos first. If you watch Kehlani’s older videos and then jump into the It Was Good Until It Wasn’t era, the growth in their visual storytelling is jarring in the best way.
- Pay attention to the basslines. This album is a masterclass in "low-end" production. If you have decent headphones, use them. The sub-bass on "Grieving" is a physical experience.
- Read the lyrics to "Lexii's Outro." Understanding the context of Kehlani’s friendship with Lexii Alijai adds a layer of weight to the entire second half of the album.
Ultimately, Kehlani proved that you don't need a massive studio or a million-dollar budget to make something that lasts. You just need a story that people can see themselves in. They took their personal chaos and turned it into a sanctuary for everyone else who was going through it.