It was late 2013. Most people still thought of Justin Bieber as the kid with the purple hoodie or the "Boyfriend" singer trying to find his footing in adult pop. Then came Music Mondays. For ten weeks, Bieber dropped a new track every single Monday at midnight, leading up to a compilation that wasn't even a traditional studio album. It was a project called Journals. If you look at the tracklist now, the Justin Bieber Journals songs represent a jarring, fascinating pivot from bubblegum pop to a stripped-back, R&B-heavy sound that basically alienated his younger fan base while earning him his first real respect from "serious" music critics.
Honestly, it was a mess behind the scenes. He was going through a very public breakup with Selena Gomez, getting into trouble with the law, and clearly struggling with the transition from teen idol to grown man. But that chaos produced his best work. Journals wasn't about radio play. It was a diary.
The Sound of a Meltdown (and a Breakthrough)
Most pop stars play it safe. They hire twenty writers to make sure a hook is catchy enough for a car commercial. Bieber didn't do that here. He locked himself in with producers like Poo Bear and focused on "vibe" over "structure."
Take "Heartbreaker." It was the first song released during the Music Mondays campaign. It’s nearly five minutes long. It doesn't have a massive, explosive chorus. Instead, it’s built on this hypnotic, repetitive guitar loop and Bieber’s airy vocals. It felt intimate. It felt like you were eavesdropping on a phone call he shouldn't have been making. That’s the core appeal of the Justin Bieber Journals songs—they feel private.
Critics at the time were actually surprised. Rolling Stone and Pitchfork, who had spent years dunking on the kid, suddenly had to admit that he had taste. He was pulling from 90s R&B influences like Craig David and Jodeci. He wasn't chasing the EDM-pop trend that was killing the charts in 2013. He was doing something quiet.
Collaborations that Actually Made Sense
Usually, features on a pop album feel like they were brokered by lawyers in a boardroom. On Journals, the features felt earned.
- "Confident" featuring Chance the Rapper: This was the outlier. It was upbeat, funky, and had that infectious bassline. At the time, Chance was the indie darling of the hip-hop world. Putting him on a track with the world's most scrutinized pop star was a bold move that paid off. It’s arguably the most "commercial" song on the project, but it still maintains that slick, late-night R&B texture.
- "PYD" featuring R. Kelly: While this track has aged poorly due to the featured artist’s subsequent legal convictions and horrific history, at the moment of its release, it was seen as a "passing of the torch" in terms of R&B vocal arrangement.
- "All Bad" and "Lolly": These tracks played with contemporary trap influences without feeling like a caricature.
Why These Tracks Failed Commercially (and Succeeded Culturally)
If you look at the Billboard charts for Journals, it wasn't a "hit." It wasn't even eligible for the album charts initially because of how it was sold as a digital-only collection of singles. Labels hated it. Radio stations didn't know what to do with "Recovery" or "Bad Day" because they weren't "bops." They were depressing. They were slow.
But that’s exactly why the "Beliebers" who grew up with him cite this as their favorite era. It was the first time Bieber seemed like a person rather than a product.
💡 You might also like: Olivia Pope on Scandal: Why the White Hat Still Matters
There's a specific vulnerability in "Hold Tight." The song is basically about physical longing, but the way it's produced—thick with atmosphere and reverb—makes it feel more like a memory than a present-day event. He was experimenting with his falsetto in a way that wasn't just "showy." He was using it to convey exhaustion.
The Poo Bear Factor
You can't talk about Justin Bieber Journals songs without mentioning Jason "Poo Bear" Boyd. He is the architect of this era. Before Journals, Bieber was working with Max Martin-style hitmakers. Poo Bear brought a different philosophy: keep it soulful, keep it raw, and don't over-edit the vocals.
They recorded most of these songs in hotel rooms and random studios while Bieber was on the Believe tour. You can hear that "on the road" fatigue in the music. It’s the sound of a 19-year-old with too much money and a broken heart, trying to figure out if he even wants to be a pop star anymore.
The Tracks You Probably Slept On
Everyone knows "Confident," but the deep cuts are where the real gems live. "One Life" is a perfect example. It has this shimmering, synth-heavy production that sounds like a sunset. It’s hopeful but cautious.
Then there’s "Backyard Luv." It’s quirky, almost experimental for a guy who was just singing "Baby" a few years prior.
And "Memphis." This track is weird. It’s got this stuttering beat and Big Sean dropping a verse that actually fits the mood. It sounds like something that would come out of the Atlanta scene today, but Bieber was doing it in 2013. He was ahead of the curve on the "PBR&B" movement that artists like The Weeknd and Frank Ocean were pioneering.
📖 Related: Who all died in Harry Potter: The deaths that actually broke us
A Quick Look at the Tracklist Evolution
- Heartbreaker – The breakup anthem.
- All That Matters – A song about priority (widely believed to be about Selena).
- Hold Tight – The R&B slow jam.
- Recovery – Sampling Craig David’s "Fill Me In."
- Bad Day – A literal interpretation of a "shitty day" over a guitar.
- All Bad – Defensive, moody, and sharp.
- PYD – The vocal powerhouse.
- Roller Coaster – One of the few moments of high energy.
- Change Me – A piano ballad that feels like a plea for forgiveness.
- Confident – The hit.
The rest of the tracks like "Swap It Out" and "What’s Hatnin’" filled out the digital release, creating a cohesive, moody experience that lasted nearly an hour. It wasn't just a collection of singles; it was a mood board of a mental breakdown.
The Legacy of the Journals Era
Years later, Journals has become a cult classic. When Bieber performs now, the fans in the front row aren't screaming for "Beauty and a Beat." They are screaming for "Flatline."
It’s the project that allowed Purpose to happen. Without the experimentation of the Justin Bieber Journals songs, he never would have had the confidence to work with Diplo and Skrillex. He needed to prove to himself that he could make music that didn't rely on a bubblegum hook. He needed to prove he had "soul."
The project also changed how artists release music. The "Music Mondays" concept—dropping a track a week—is now a standard strategy in the streaming era. In 2013, it was revolutionary. It bypassed the traditional gatekeepers of radio and went straight to the fans' phones.
How to Listen to Journals Today
If you're going back to revisit these tracks, don't just put it on shuffle. You have to listen to it late at night. It’s "driving in the rain" music. It’s "staring at your phone waiting for a text" music.
The production is surprisingly timeless. Unlike the heavy EDM-pop of 2013, which sounds incredibly dated now (looking at you, Artpop and Prism), the minimalist R&B of Journals sounds like it could have been released yesterday. The drums are crisp, the bass is warm, and the vocal layers are lush.
Actionable Insight for Music Fans:
If you want to truly appreciate the technical side of this era, listen to "Swap It Out" with high-quality headphones. Pay attention to the way the vocal harmonies are panned. It’s a masterclass in R&B vocal production. For those trying to understand Bieber’s evolution, compare "Heartbreaker" to his later work on Changes. You’ll see that Journals was actually the blueprint for his entire adult career.
The most important takeaway? Journals proved that Justin Bieber was an artist, not just a celebrity. It was the moment the "Bieber Fever" died and a real musician was born.
To get the full experience of this era, watch the Believe documentary and the "All That Matters" music video filmed at the Great Wall of China. It provides the visual context for the isolation he was feeling during the recording process. You can find the full compilation on all major streaming platforms, often listed as an "EP" or "Compilation" rather than a standard studio album. Don't let the label fool you; it's the most essential project in his discography.
Check out the production credits for "Recovery" and "Bad Day" to see how they utilized acoustic elements to ground the electronic R&B sounds. This balance is what keeps the songs feeling "human" despite the polished studio environment.