They didn't win. Honestly, that’s the first thing people usually forget when they talk about Jet and Cord from the Amazing Race. You’d think a team that appeared in three different seasons—Season 16, Season 18 (Unfinished Business), and Season 24 (All-Stars)—would have at least one victory under those Stetson hats. Nope. Despite being perhaps the most naturally gifted racers the CBS franchise has ever seen, the "Cowboys" always seemed to hit a snag right before the finish line.
But winning isn't everything in reality TV. Impact is.
Jet and Cord McCoy didn't just play a game; they became a blueprint. Before them, the show often leaned into "mismatch" casting—divorced couples, high-strung best friends, or people who had never left their zip code. Then came these two brothers from Tupelo, Oklahoma. They were polite. They said "Oh, my gravy." They treated every roadblock like a chore on the ranch. Watching them was less about the stress of travel and more about watching two guys operate with a level of calm that drove their competitors absolutely insane.
The Cowboy Way: More Than Just a Gimmick
When Jet and Cord first stepped onto the starting line at Universal Studios in Season 16, the other teams kind of wrote them off as a novelty act. Big mistake. You see, the McCoys weren't "urban cowboys" or guys who bought a hat at the airport. They were world-class rodeo professionals. Cord was a four-time PBR (Professional Bull Riders) World Finals qualifier. Jet was a champion in his own right.
That background matters because of the discipline it requires.
Rodeo is about reacting to chaos with physical precision. When you’re used to staying on a 2,000-pound animal that wants to kill you, a delayed flight in Chile just doesn't feel that life-threatening. They moved through airports like they were walking through a quiet barn. While other teams were screaming at taxi drivers or sobbing over lost passports, Jet and Cord were usually just... whistling.
It wasn't all sunshine and "Yes, Ma'am," though. Their "all-American" persona faced real scrutiny. In Season 16, they clashed heavily with Jordan Lloyd and Jeff Schroeder (of Big Brother fame) and the winners, Dan and Jordan Pious. There were accusations of a lack of social game. They were often "on an island," refusing to join the massive alliances that define modern seasons of the show. They preferred to run their own race. That independence is exactly why fans loved them, but it’s also arguably why they never took home the $1 million. In the Amazing Race, sometimes you need the pack to survive. The Cowboys? They were always the lone wolves.
💡 You might also like: Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Light Trail: Is the New York Botanical Garden Event Worth Your Money?
The "Oh My Gravy" Factor
You can't talk about Jet and Cord from the Amazing Race without mentioning the catchphrases. It sounds silly, but their refusal to swear or lose their cool became a brand. They turned "Oh, my gravy" into a national slogan for reality TV fans.
But let’s get real for a second. Being that "clean-cut" in the middle of a high-stress race across the globe is exhausting. There were moments where you could see the cracks. In Season 18, during a brutal leg in China, the frustration was etched on Jet’s face. They were perfectionists. When they made a mistake—like the infamous "Double U-Turn" incidents or struggles with specific navigation—it wasn't just a lost lead. It felt like a personal failure to them.
Why They Kept Coming Back (And We Kept Watching)
Three seasons is a lot. Only a handful of teams have ever been invited back that many times. CBS knew that the Cowboys were ratings gold because they appealed to a demographic that reality TV often ignores: the heartland. They weren't trying to be influencers. They weren't there to get a clothing line. They just wanted to see the world and compete.
- Season 16 (2nd Place): This was their peak performance. They won five legs. That is an absurdly high number. They lost the final sprint to Dan and Jordan Pious because of a seating arrangement on a plane—a classic Amazing Race heartbreak.
- Season 18 (6th Place): The "Unfinished Business" season. They were U-Turned by the Globetrotters (Flight Time and Big Easy). It was a clash of titans, and for the first time, the Cowboys looked vulnerable.
- Season 24 (5th Place): The second All-Stars. By this point, they were veterans. They knew the tricks. But the game had changed, becoming more about social maneuvering and less about raw speed. They got caught in the crossfire of the "Brenchel" (Brendon and Rachel) drama and a massive alliance that targeted them for being too big of a threat.
It’s actually kinda crazy when you look at the stats. They’ve traveled over 100,000 miles on screen. They’ve visited dozens of countries. And through it all, they never really changed who they were. That consistency is rare. Most people go on these shows and have a "growth arc" where they learn to be more tolerant or less anxious. Jet and Cord started as cowboys and ended as cowboys.
The Controversy Nobody Mentions Anymore
It wasn't all positive press. During their first season, there was a persistent rumor—largely fueled by online forums and a few comments from other contestants—that the brothers used a homophobic slur toward another contestant, Jordan Pious.
The show never aired it. The brothers have always denied it.
📖 Related: Diego Klattenhoff Movies and TV Shows: Why He’s the Best Actor You Keep Forgetting You Know
It’s one of those "he-said, she-said" moments in reality TV history that remains a stain for some viewers while being totally dismissed by others. In the years since, the McCoys have mostly stayed out of the line of fire, focusing on their families and their ranching businesses. But it serves as a reminder that even the most "wholesome" teams have their complexities and their critics.
Life After the Finish Line
So, what happened when the cameras stopped rolling for the last time in 2014?
They went back to the ranch. Seriously.
Jet McCoy actually jumped into politics. He ran for the Oklahoma State Senate in 2016. He didn't win that race either, which feels oddly poetic given his history on the show, but he remained a prominent figure in his community. Cord, meanwhile, stayed deep in the rodeo world. He’s now a successful stock contractor, raising the very bulls that riders try to stay on for eight seconds. He transitioned from the guy on the bull to the guy owning the bulls.
They also didn't disappear from the Amazing Race family. They still show up at charity events and "Reality Rally" gatherings. They’re the elder statesmen now. When new teams get cast, they often look at Jet and Cord's tapes to learn how to handle the physical tasks.
What You Can Learn From the Cowboys
If you're a fan of the show or just someone who likes analyzing how people handle pressure, there are legitimate takeaways from how Jet and Cord operated.
👉 See also: Did Mac Miller Like Donald Trump? What Really Happened Between the Rapper and the President
First, efficiency beats speed. They rarely ran at full tilt. They walked fast. They stayed organized. They kept their backpacks light.
Second, don't let the highs get too high. When they won a leg, they were happy, sure. But they didn't celebrate like they'd won the whole game. They knew a 12-hour pit stop was coming and then everything would reset. That stoicism is a superpower in a race that lasts 30 days.
The Reality of the "Cowboy" Legacy
We probably won't see them on a fourth season. The show has moved on to a younger generation, and the McCoys are in a different stage of life now. But their influence is everywhere. Every time you see a "fish out of water" team that turns out to be surprisingly competent, that’s the Cowboy archetype.
They proved that you don't have to be a loudmouth to be a "character." You don't have to manufacture drama to get airtime. If you’re good enough at the tasks and polite enough to the locals, the audience will find you.
Next Steps for Fans and Aspiring Racers:
- Watch Season 16 Again: If you want to see the pure version of their strategy, go back to the beginning. Pay attention to how they handle the "Detour" choices—they almost always pick the physical labor option over the mental puzzles.
- Check Out Cord’s Bull Riding Business: For a look at his real life, follow McCoy Farms. It shows the grit that made them successful on TV.
- Study the Navigation: If you’re ever planning to audition for the show, look at the legs where Jet and Cord struggled. It was almost always due to a lack of "street smarts" in dense urban environments like Tokyo or Mumbai. The lesson? If you're a country kid, spend some time in a city before you go.
- Follow the "No-Alliance" Rule: Notice how being independent made them fan favorites but strategically vulnerable. Decide for yourself: is it better to win the money or win the hearts of the audience?
The story of Jet and Cord is a reminder that the Amazing Race is as much about temperament as it is about travel. They didn't need the million dollars to become the most successful team in the show's history—they just needed two hats and a little bit of gravy.