Most people remember Crazy, Stupid, Love for Ryan Gosling’s abs or that incredible backyard brawl where every plot twist collided at once. It’s a classic. But if you strip away the slick suits and the "dirty dancing" lift, the character who actually anchors the movie in a messy, uncomfortable reality is Jessica Riley.
She's the babysitter.
Played by Analeigh Tipton (who now goes by Lio Tipton), Jessica from Crazy Stupid Love isn't just a plot device to give Steve Carell’s character, Cal, someone to talk to. She is the embodiment of that specific, agonizing brand of teenage yearning that most Hollywood rom-coms totally gloss over in favor of prom queens and makeovers. Jessica is 17, she’s in over her head, and she is desperately in love with a man twice her age. It’s cringey. It’s awkward. Honestly, it’s exactly how being seventeen feels.
The Babysitter Trope vs. The Reality
Usually, the "hot babysitter" is a cliché designed for the male gaze. You know the one. She walks in, drops her bag, and the dad does a double-take. Directors Glenn Ficarra and John Requa flipped that entirely. Jessica isn’t a temptress; she’s a kid who has confused kindness for compatibility.
When Cal is at his lowest point, spiraling after Emily (Julianne Moore) asks for a divorce, Jessica is there. She listens. She sees him as a tragic, romantic figure instead of a middle-aged guy in New Balance sneakers who just lost his wife. To her, his sadness is profound. To the rest of the world, it’s a midlife crisis. This disconnect is where Tipton’s performance really shines. They play Jessica with this wide-eyed sincerity that makes you want to look away from the screen because the secondhand embarrassment is so high.
✨ Don't miss: Why La Mera Mera Radio is Actually Dominating Local Airwaves Right Now
Think about the scene where she tries to give him the "nude" photos she took. It’s heartbreakingly naive. She thinks she’s being a femme fatale, but she’s just a girl in her bedroom trying to figure out how to be an adult. It highlights the central theme of the movie: everyone, regardless of age, is an absolute moron when it comes to love.
That Bizarre Love Triangle (Square?)
The genius of the script by Dan Fogelman is how it weaves Jessica’s unrequited love for Cal into Robbie’s unrequited love for her. Robbie, played by Jonah Bobo, is Cal’s 13-year-old son. He is obsessed with Jessica. He gives these grand speeches about soulmates and destiny—speeches that, in any other movie, would be framed as "cute" or "inspiring."
But because Robbie is directed at Jessica, and Jessica is directed at Cal, the movie forces us to see how annoying "grand gestures" actually are when you don't like the person giving them.
- Robbie thinks he’s Romeo.
- Jessica thinks he’s a pest.
- Jessica thinks she’s Cal’s savior.
- Cal thinks she’s just the girl who watches his kids.
It’s a cycle of misplaced affection. It shows that love isn't always a two-way street; sometimes it's just a series of people staring at the back of each other's heads.
🔗 Read more: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
Why Lio Tipton’s Performance Anchors the Film
Before Crazy, Stupid, Love, Lio Tipton was mostly known for America's Next Top Model. There was a lot of skepticism about a reality star taking on a nuanced role alongside heavy hitters like Moore and Carell. They proved everyone wrong. There is a specific facial expression Tipton makes throughout the film—a sort of trembling-lip, "I’m about to cry but I’m trying to be cool" look—that perfectly captures late-adolescence.
Jessica isn't "cool." She’s weird. She’s into photography. She has a complicated relationship with her parents, particularly her dad (played by the terrifyingly intense Kevin Bacon), who eventually finds the photos she took. That confrontation in the driveway isn't played for laughs. It’s scary. It reminds the audience that while Cal and Jacob (Gosling) are playing a game of "pick up artist," there are real-world consequences for the kids caught in the crossfire of their parents' crumbling lives.
The Evolution of the "Older Man" Crush
We have to talk about how the movie handles the age gap. In 2011, this subplot felt a bit more "indie quirky." Looking at it through a 2026 lens, it feels a lot more like a cautionary tale about boundaries.
The movie manages to stay on the right side of the line because Cal never once reciprocates. He’s a "good guy" not because he’s perfect, but because he recognizes Jessica’s vulnerability even when he’s a mess himself. When he finally sees the photos, he doesn't mock her. He doesn't take advantage. He treats it with a sort of weary, paternal pity that eventually leads to her growth.
💡 You might also like: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
What People Miss About the Ending
By the end of the film, Jessica has moved on. Sort of. She’s still in the orbit of the Weaver family, but the "crush" has deflated. The most important moment for her character isn't a romantic resolution. It’s when she hands Robbie the photos he’s been begging for, but with a twist. She has reclaimed her own agency.
She isn't a prize to be won by Robbie, and she isn't a tragic figure rejected by Cal. She's just a young woman who survived her first massive, embarrassing heartbreak. And honestly? That's a more successful character arc than almost anyone else in the film.
Actionable Takeaways for Rewatching
If you're going back to watch Crazy, Stupid, Love this weekend, keep a few things in mind to see the film in a new light:
- Watch the backgrounds. In the scenes where Jessica is babysitting, look at how Tipton uses body language. She’s constantly trying to look older than she is—straightening her posture or trying to use "adult" vocabulary—until she’s alone or with Robbie, where she slumps back into being a teenager.
- Compare Jessica and Hannah. Hannah (Emma Stone) is the "adult" version of Jessica. She’s also a bit of a dork who thinks she has things figured out with her lawyer boyfriend, only to realize she wants something more chaotic. Both characters are looking for a version of love that doesn't actually exist until they find it in the most unexpected (and awkward) places.
- The Kevin Bacon Factor. Pay attention to how the "cheating" subplot with David Lindhagen (Bacon) mirrors Jessica’s own secrets. The movie suggests that the adults are just as bad at keeping secrets and managing impulses as the 17-year-olds.
Jessica Riley is the heart of the movie because she represents the transition point. She’s the bridge between the childhood innocence of Robbie and the jaded, broken world of Cal and Emily. Without her, the movie is just a series of funny sketches. With her, it’s a story about how much it hurts to grow up.
Next time you see it, don't just wait for the "Be the better man" speech. Watch the babysitter. She’s the one actually telling the truth.