Healing from high-control environments or religious trauma feels like trying to untangle a knotted necklace in the dark. You pull one thread, and three more tighten. For a lot of folks, the heaviest knot isn't even the trauma itself—it’s the crushing weight of personal shame. You feel like you should have known better, or you wonder why you stayed so long. This is exactly where the It's Not Your Fault book by Dr. Laura Anderson steps in to flip the script.
It’s a rare thing to find a book that manages to be both scientifically grounded and deeply empathetic without sounding like a dry medical textbook. Anderson, a therapist who specializes in religious trauma and complex PTSD, doesn't just offer platitudes. She digs into the nervous system. She looks at how bodies react when they are under constant surveillance or psychological pressure. Basically, she’s telling you that your "weird" reactions were actually your brain doing its job to keep you alive.
The Body Doesn't Care About Logic
Most people think healing is a mental game. If you just think the right thoughts or read the right mantras, you’ll be fine, right? Wrong. Anderson argues—and the science backs this up—that trauma lives in the body. When you grow up or live in a high-control group, your nervous system is essentially programmed to stay in a state of high alert.
Your body was adapted to survive an environment that demanded compliance.
If you find yourself freezing up when someone asks for your opinion, or if your heart starts racing when you walk past a church, that’s not a character flaw. It’s your dorsal vagal response or your sympathetic nervous system firing off a warning shot. In the It's Not Your Fault book, the central premise is that these "symptoms" are actually brilliant survival adaptations. You aren't broken; you're evolved.
Breaking Down the "High-Control" Myth
We often hear the word "cult" and think of isolated compounds in the desert with people wearing matching robes. Anderson broadens this definition. High-control environments can be found in families, toxic workplaces, and mainstream religious institutions. They share a common thread: they strip away your autonomy. They use shame as a steering wheel.
One of the most powerful insights in the book is how these systems create a "fawning" response. You’ve probably heard of fight or flight. But fawning is the act of people-pleasing to stay safe. If you spent years anticipating the needs of a volatile leader or parent just to avoid a blow-up, your brain got really good at it. Now, as an adult, you might struggle to set boundaries. Again, it’s not because you’re weak. It’s because fawning kept the peace when you didn't have any other options.
✨ Don't miss: Ankle Stretches for Runners: What Most People Get Wrong About Mobility
Honestly, it’s a relief to hear a professional say that. The shame of being a "people pleaser" melts away when you realize it was a tactical maneuver for survival.
Why Religious Trauma is Different
Religious trauma hits differently because it involves the "ultimate" authority. It’s not just a bad boss; it’s the creator of the universe (as defined by that group) being used as a weapon against you. Anderson describes this as "Institutional Betrayal." When the places that are supposed to offer safety and spiritual growth actually cause harm, the psychological fallout is massive.
The It's Not Your Fault book spends significant time on the concept of "Religious Trauma Syndrome," a term coined by Dr. Marlene Winell. Anderson builds on this by explaining how the fear of hell or divine punishment creates a specific type of chronic stress. This isn't something you just "get over" by moving to a new city. It requires a somatic—body-based—approach to unlearning the fear.
Complex PTSD and the Long Road Back
Many readers of the It's Not Your Fault book come to it already familiar with PTSD, but Anderson focuses heavily on C-PTSD (Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder). Unlike a single event—like a car accident—C-PTSD comes from prolonged exposure to trauma. It's the "death by a thousand cuts" version of mental health struggles.
Because the trauma happened over years, the healing takes time too.
Anderson is very clear about the fact that there is no "back to normal." You are building a new version of yourself. She uses a framework that moves away from "forgiveness" as the ultimate goal. In many toxic religious circles, you're pressured to forgive your abusers immediately. Anderson argues that forced forgiveness is just another form of control. Instead, she prioritizes agency. You get to decide who is in your life. You get to decide if and when you forgive.
🔗 Read more: Can DayQuil Be Taken At Night: What Happens If You Skip NyQuil
The Role of the Nervous System in Self-Gaslighting
Have you ever had a "good" day where nothing went wrong, but you still felt like the floor was about to drop out?
That’s your nervous system waiting for the other shoe to drop. In the It's Not Your Fault book, this is explained as a calibrated state of hyper-vigilance. Your body is so used to chaos that "calm" feels dangerous. This often leads to self-gaslighting, where you tell yourself you're overreacting or being dramatic.
Anderson’s work helps bridge the gap between what you know (that you are safe now) and what you feel (that you are in danger). She suggests that instead of fighting the feeling, you acknowledge it. You tell your body, "I see you're trying to protect me, but we're okay right now." It sounds simple, but for someone who has spent decades disconnected from their physical sensations, it's a revolutionary act.
Redefining Autonomy and Reclaiming the Body
A huge chunk of the book is dedicated to the "how-to" of reclamation. High-control groups usually have strict rules about what you can eat, wear, think, and do with your body. Reclaiming that autonomy starts small.
- Buying a shirt in a color you were told was "sinful" or "wrong."
- Eating a food that was previously restricted.
- Setting a tiny boundary, like not answering a phone call immediately.
These aren't just lifestyle choices. They are neurological exercises. Every time you make a choice based on your own desire rather than someone else's rule, you are re-wiring your brain. The It's Not Your Fault book emphasizes that you don't need to have a grand plan. You just need to start listening to your "gut" again—that internal compass that high-control groups work so hard to break.
Misconceptions About Healing from Religious Trauma
One common mistake people make when they leave a high-control group is jumping straight into a different, but equally rigid, system. It’s a bit like a pendulum swing. Anderson warns against this "identity jumping." Just because you left the group doesn't mean the "internalized critic" left your head.
💡 You might also like: Nuts Are Keto Friendly (Usually), But These 3 Mistakes Will Kick You Out Of Ketosis
Another misconception is that you have to become an atheist or stay religious to be "healed." Anderson is surprisingly neutral here. She doesn't push a specific belief system. Her focus is entirely on the mechanism of the belief. Is it coming from a place of fear and coercion, or a place of choice and curiosity? That’s the only metric that matters in her framework.
Practical Steps Toward Recovery
If you’re sitting there wondering where to even start, Anderson provides a roadmap that is more about "being" than "doing."
First, get curious about your triggers. Instead of getting mad at yourself for having a panic attack, ask, "What did my body just perceive as a threat?" Second, find a community that doesn't have a "leader." Peer support groups where everyone is on level ground are incredibly healing for those coming out of hierarchies.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, stop trying to rush the process. You can't "life-hack" your way out of trauma. Your nervous system moves at the speed of safety, not the speed of your calendar.
The It's Not Your Fault book is essentially a permission slip. It's permission to be messy, to be angry, and to take up space. It’s a reminder that the things you’re ashamed of—the "weakness," the "confusion," the "compliance"—were actually the things that helped you survive long enough to get out.
Actionable Next Steps for Healing
- Audit Your Sensory Environment: Identify one thing in your daily life that makes you feel "tight" or anxious (a certain song, a smell, a specific person's social media). Remove it for one week and notice if your baseline anxiety shifts.
- Practice Body Scanning: Spend five minutes a day just noticing where you feel tension. Don't try to change it. Just name it. "My shoulders feel like rocks." This builds the mind-body connection that trauma severs.
- Seek Trauma-Informed Support: If you choose therapy, ensure the provider specifically understands "Religious Trauma" or "High-Control Groups." General therapy can sometimes accidentally re-traumatize by using "forgiveness-first" models.
- Read Diversely: Supplement your reading with authors like Bessel van der Kolk (The Body Keeps the Score) or Janina Fisher to understand the biological side of what Dr. Anderson discusses.
- Document Your Wins: Keep a list of times you made a choice for yourself. No matter how small. "I chose to sleep in until 9:00 AM." These are your "autonomy markers."