You remember the feeling. Standing in a grocery aisle, staring at a vast, beige expanse of empty metal shelving where the 12-packs used to be. It felt like the world had tilted. Honestly, the sight of a lone, crushed roll of generic single-ply became a genuine victory for some. But why? People weren't suddenly using the bathroom 500% more often. It’s one of those weird moments in modern history where a basic necessity just... vanished. To understand why is there a toilet paper shortage, you have to look past the "panic buying" headlines and dive into the weird, rigid world of paper manufacturing and the psychology of a crisis.
It wasn't just about people being "crazy."
The reality is much more mechanical. Our global supply chain is built on a "just-in-time" model. This means companies don't keep massive warehouses full of extra rolls. They make what they think they’ll sell next week. When the world changed overnight, that model broke. Hard.
The Great Split: Why We Couldn't Just Use "Office Paper"
Here is the thing most people missed. There are actually two completely different toilet paper industries. You have the consumer side—the soft, quilted stuff you buy for your house. Then you have the commercial side—those giant, scratchy rolls you find in airports, office buildings, and stadiums.
When the lockdowns hit, the demand for "home" paper skyrocketed. At the same time, the demand for "commercial" paper plummeted to almost zero. You’d think the companies could just pivot, right? Just put the office paper in grocery store packaging.
Wrong.
📖 Related: Postage Stamps Cost Today: What Most People Get Wrong
The machinery used to make those jumbo commercial rolls is massive and highly specialized. It can’t just be "tweaked" to produce a four-pack of Charmin. These factories are billion-dollar investments. Georgia-Pacific, one of the biggest players in the game, noted that their commercial and retail supply chains are almost entirely separate. Everything is different: the wood pulp mix, the thickness, the packaging, and even the shipping pallets. You can't just put a giant 50-pound roll on a grocery store shelf. It doesn't fit the scanners, the shelves, or the trucks.
So, while offices were sitting on mountains of paper nobody was using, grocery stores were bone dry.
The Psychology of the "Bullwhip Effect"
We have to talk about the "Bullwhip Effect." It’s a supply chain phenomenon that starts with a tiny flutter in consumer behavior and ends with a massive swing at the manufacturing level. Imagine a literal whip. A small flick of the wrist creates a massive, violent snap at the end of the cord.
In early 2020, people saw one news report about a shortage in another country. They bought two packs instead of one. Just in case. That’s the flick of the wrist.
Retailers saw their shelves emptying faster than usual, so they doubled their orders to the distributors. The distributors, seeing the massive orders, called the factories and demanded triple the output. By the time the signal reached the paper mills, it looked like the world was suddenly demanding ten times more toilet paper than ever before. But the mills were already running at 92% capacity. There was no "extra" gear to shift into.
Panic buying is a self-fulfilling prophecy. If you think there will be a shortage, you buy more. Because you bought more, there is a shortage. Everyone else sees the empty shelf and thinks, "I guess I better buy ten packs next time I see them." It's a feedback loop that defies logic.
Logistics and the "Bulky" Problem
Toilet paper is a nightmare to move. Seriously.
Think about it. It’s mostly air. It’s light, but it takes up a massive amount of physical space. For a trucking company, toilet paper is one of the least profitable things to haul. You can fill an entire semi-trailer with it, and it barely weighs anything, but you've used up all your cubic volume.
👉 See also: Chick-fil-A Ads: What Most People Get Wrong About the Cows
When the toilet paper shortage hit its peak, the bottleneck wasn't just at the mills. It was the trucks. With the world shifting to online shopping for everything, shipping capacity was squeezed. If a distributor had to choose between shipping a pallet of high-margin electronics or a pallet of low-margin toilet paper, the TP often lost out.
Why We Can't Just Build More Factories
People often ask: "If there's so much demand, why don't they just build more factories?"
Economics.
Building a new paper mill costs hundreds of millions, sometimes billions, of dollars. It takes years to get the permits and build the infrastructure. Paper companies knew this was a "spike." They knew that eventually, people would have enough rolls stuffed under their beds to last a year, and demand would crash. If they spent $500 million building a new plant today, it would be useless by the time it opened.
Instead, companies like Kimberly-Clark and Procter & Gamble did what they could: they simplified. They stopped making the "extra-soft-mega-ultra" versions and focused on one or two standard types to keep the machines running without stopping for changeovers.
The Myth of the Raw Material Shortage
Despite the rumors, we never really ran out of trees.
The United States and Canada have plenty of pulpwood. The issue was never a lack of wood. It was the "conversion" process—turning that pulp into a finished, embossed, wrapped roll and getting it to a store in a suburb of Ohio.
There were some minor issues with chemicals used in the whitening process, as those were also being diverted to make PPE and cleaning supplies. But for the most part, the "stuff" was there. The "system" just couldn't move it.
Hidden Factors: The "Stay at Home" Math
Let's do some quick, somewhat gross math.
The average person uses the bathroom at home much more frequently when they aren't at work or school. Industry experts estimated a 40% increase in home toilet paper demand purely because of the shift in where people were physically located. When you combine a 40% legitimate increase in usage with a 200% increase in panic buying, no supply chain on earth can handle that.
The industry is built for "normal." It is not built for "the entire world staying home at the same time."
The Evolution of the Shortage
As the months rolled on, the shortage morphed. It wasn't just about the paper anymore. It became about the plastic film used to wrap the rolls. It became about the cardboard tubes in the middle. Even the wooden pallets used to move the stacks became scarce.
It was a "cascading failure." One small break in the chain caused a ripple that affected everything else.
Looking Ahead: Will It Happen Again?
The short answer? Kinda.
Supply chains are more resilient now, but they are still optimized for efficiency, not "just in case" scenarios. However, the 2020-2022 era taught retailers a lot. Many now keep higher "safety stocks" of essential goods.
But here is the reality: if a massive global event triggers a collective panic, people will always go for the toilet paper. It's a "control" item. When the world feels out of control, having a full pantry and a closet full of TP makes people feel safe. It's psychological armor.
Actionable Steps to Navigate Future Shortages
If you start seeing those empty shelves again, don't feed the beast. Here is how to handle it without losing your mind or your money:
- Diversify your sources: Stop going to the big box stores where everyone else is. Local hardware stores, office supply stores, and even some pharmacies often have stock when the giants are empty.
- Invest in a Bidet: This is the single biggest "shortage-proof" move you can make. It sounds intimidating to some, but it reduces paper usage by 75% or more. Tushy and Luxe Bidet are popular brands that take 10 minutes to install.
- The 2-Week Rule: Keep a rolling two-week supply of essentials. Not a two-year supply. If you always have two weeks' worth, you don't need to join the 6:00 AM line at Costco when the news breaks.
- Look for Commercial Sellers: Many "janitorial supply" companies started selling to the public during the last shortage. The paper might be a bit rougher, but they usually have plenty of it.
- Check the "Bottom Shelf": People tend to grab what’s at eye level. Check the very top and very bottom of the aisles; often, the less popular brands or larger, awkward packs are still there.
The toilet paper shortage wasn't a mystery of disappearing trees or a secret government plot. It was a perfect storm of rigid manufacturing, a massive shift in human geography, and a touch of collective hysteria. Understanding that the system is built for "just-in-time" helps you realize why you need to be "just-in-case."
Key Takeaways for the Future:
The paper industry has slowly adapted by making supply lines more flexible, but the fundamental constraint remains: machines can only spin so fast. By focusing on reducing your personal reliance on paper through alternatives like bidets and maintaining a modest, non-panic-induced buffer, you can avoid the stress of the next supply chain hiccup. Most importantly, remember that "out of stock" at one store usually means "stuck in a truck," not "gone forever." Stay calm, buy what you need, and leave some for the next person.