Why is Palestine and Israel Fighting: What Most People Get Wrong

Why is Palestine and Israel Fighting: What Most People Get Wrong

If you’ve spent any time on social media lately, you’ve probably seen the maps. Red lines, green lines, shifting borders that look like a puzzle nobody can solve. It’s messy. Honestly, it’s heartbreaking. As of January 2026, we are looking at a landscape in the Middle East that feels both frozen in time and radically changed by the violence of the last few years.

People always ask: "Why is Palestine and Israel fighting?" like there’s a single "Aha!" moment that started it all. There isn't. It’s a collision of two peoples claiming the same small slice of earth between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea. Both have deep, ancient ties to the land. Both have suffered unimaginable trauma.

The immediate trigger and the long shadow of October 7

We can't talk about 2026 without looking back at the 2023-2025 war. It changed everything. Before October 7, 2023, the world was almost ready to look away. Then Hamas launched a massive attack, killing nearly 1,200 people in Israel. The retaliation was absolute.

By the time the current, shaky ceasefire was brokered in late 2025, Gaza was largely a graveyard of concrete. Over 71,000 Palestinians have been killed. That is a number that’s hard to wrap your head around. It’s not just "fighting" anymore; it’s a total collapse of the old status quo.

In early 2026, the fighting continues in smaller, jagged bursts. Just this week, UNRWA—the UN agency for Palestinian refugees—had its offices in East Jerusalem raided. Water and power were cut. Even with a "peace plan" on the table, nobody is actually putting down their guns for good.

👉 See also: Ethics in the News: What Most People Get Wrong

Why is Palestine and Israel fighting over borders and identity?

At its core, this is a fight about "Where do I belong?" and "Who gets to rule?"

Israelis see the land as their ancestral home, a refuge for a people who faced the Holocaust and centuries of persecution. They want security. They want to know that a rocket won't hit their kitchen while they’re making coffee. After the horrors of 2023, that desire for a "buffer zone" has led to the Israeli military occupying roughly 53% of Gaza as of this month.

Palestinians see the same land as their home, where they’ve lived for generations. They see the 1948 "Nakba" (the catastrophe) as an ongoing event. For them, the fighting is about resisting a blockade in Gaza that has lasted nearly 20 years and an occupation in the West Bank that feels like it’s swallowing their future bit by bit.

The "Big Three" sticking points:

  • Jerusalem: Both sides claim it as their capital. It’s home to the Al-Aqsa Mosque and the Western Wall. It’s the spiritual heart of the conflict, and basically, nobody is willing to share.
  • Settlements: In 2025, Israeli settlement expansion in the West Bank hit record highs. When you build a house on land someone else wants for their future country, you’re going to have a fight.
  • The Right of Return: Millions of Palestinian refugees want to go back to homes their grandparents left in 1948. Israel says no, because it would end the country’s Jewish majority.

The 2026 "Four-State" Reality

Experts like those at the Middle East Institute are now talking about a "four-state" reality rather than a two-state solution. It sounds complicated because it is. You have:

✨ Don't miss: When is the Next Hurricane Coming 2024: What Most People Get Wrong

  1. Areas of the West Bank under tight Israeli control.
  2. Small "islands" of Palestinian Authority control.
  3. The "Yellow Zone" in Gaza where the IDF still operates.
  4. Scattered pockets where Hamas remnants still hold sway.

This fragmentation is exactly why is Palestine and Israel fighting right now. There is no clear border. There is no "over there" and "over here." It’s all mixed together, which makes every checkpoint a potential flashpoint.

Why the fighting hasn't stopped yet

Politics is a huge factor. Benjamin Netanyahu is still dealing with domestic crises in Israel, and some of his cabinet members are openly pushing to annex the West Bank entirely. On the other side, Palestinian leadership is split. Hamas and Fatah (the party that runs the West Bank) have tried to form "technocratic committees" to manage Gaza’s reconstruction this month, but they agree on very little.

When leadership is weak or extreme, the "street" takes over.

We see this in the West Bank daily. It’s not just armies fighting. It’s "lone wolf" attacks and settler violence. It's an endless cycle of "they hit us, so we hit them."

🔗 Read more: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection

What actually happens next?

The U.S. is currently pushing "Phase 2" of a peace plan involving a 15-member committee of Palestinian experts to run Gaza. Will it work? Honestly, it’s a long shot. The "demilitarization" of Gaza is a core requirement, but Hamas has already put heavy conditions on that.

If you want to understand the situation better, don't just look at the headlines. Look at the maps of the "Yellow Line" in Gaza. Look at the reports from OCHA (the UN's humanitarian wing) about food security.

Actionable Insights for staying informed:

  • Follow primary sources: Read reports directly from the UN Security Council or the International Court of Justice (ICJ) rather than just social media clips.
  • Check the "Day After" plans: The real fight right now isn't just about bullets; it's about who will pick up the trash, run the schools, and provide the water in Gaza.
  • Watch the West Bank: While Gaza gets the cameras, the West Bank is where the long-term map of the region is being rewritten through settlement expansion.

The fighting continues because neither side feels they can afford to lose. For Israel, losing means a threat to their existence. For Palestinians, losing means the total disappearance of their national identity. Until that fundamental fear is addressed, the cycle remains.