You’re sitting there, the cuff finally lets go of your arm, and you look down at the monitor. The top number—the systolic—is up in the 140s or 150s. You’re already thinking about cutting out salt. But then you see the bottom number, the diastolic. It’s sitting at 70. Maybe even 60. You’ve always been told "120 over 80" is the gold standard, so this gap feels… weird. It’s a physiological seesaw that leaves a lot of people asking why is my systolic high and my diastolic low while their doctor just nods and calls it "Isolated Systolic Hypertension."
It’s actually a pretty common phenomenon, especially as we get older, but it's not something you should just shrug off. Honestly, that gap between the two numbers is often more telling than the numbers themselves.
In the medical world, we call the difference between those two numbers your pulse pressure. If your systolic is 150 and your diastolic is 70, your pulse pressure is 80. A "normal" pulse pressure is usually around 40. When that gap starts to stretch out like a piece of old elastic, it’s usually a signal that your arteries are losing their "bounce."
Understanding the "Stiff Pipe" Problem
Think about your arteries for a second. When you’re young, they’re like high-quality rubber garden hoses. When the heart pumps (systole), the hose expands to take the pressure. When the heart rests (diastole), the hose snaps back, pushing blood along and keeping the pressure from dropping too low.
But things change.
As we age, or due to things like high blood sugar and chronic inflammation, those "hoses" start to turn into metal pipes. They get stiff. This is called arteriosclerosis. When a stiff artery receives a burst of blood from the heart, it can’t expand. The result? The pressure spikes—that's your high systolic. Then, because the artery didn’t expand, there’s no "snap back" to maintain pressure while the heart refills. The pressure just falls away. That’s why your diastolic stays low or even drops further.
It’s a mechanical issue as much as a medical one.
💡 You might also like: Supplements Bad for Liver: Why Your Health Kick Might Be Backfiring
The Role of the Heart Valves
Sometimes the reason why is my systolic high and my diastolic low has nothing to do with the "pipes" and everything to do with the "valves." Specifically, the aortic valve.
Imagine a one-way swinging door. That’s your aortic valve. It opens to let blood out of the heart and slams shut to keep it from flowing back in. If that door doesn’t shut all the way—a condition called aortic regurgitation—blood leaks back into the heart right after it’s pumped out.
Because the blood is escaping backward, the pressure in your system during the "rest" phase (diastole) plummets. Meanwhile, the heart has to pump even harder the next time to make up for the blood it lost, which drives the systolic pressure through the roof. If you have this, you might feel a "bounding" pulse where you can actually feel your heartbeat in your neck or fingertips. It’s a very specific clinical sign that doctors like Dr. Valentin Fuster at Mount Sinai often look for when diagnosing valvular issues.
Other Hidden Culprits: From Thyroid to Anemia
It isn't always about the heart itself. Sometimes the heart is just responding to a "noisy" system.
- Hyperthyroidism: When your thyroid is overactive, it’s like someone turned the idle screw up on your engine. Your heart beats harder and faster. This force increases the systolic pressure, but because the thyroid hormones also cause peripheral blood vessels to dilate (to let off heat), the diastolic pressure often stays low.
- Severe Anemia: If you don't have enough red blood cells to carry oxygen, your heart has to circulate the blood you do have much faster. This hyperdynamic state creates a wide gap in pressures.
- Vitamin B12 Deficiency: Believe it or not, being low on B12 can sometimes lead to types of anemia that mess with your pressure readings.
Why the "Gap" Actually Matters
For a long time, doctors focused almost exclusively on the diastolic number. They thought the "resting" pressure was the real danger. We know better now.
Large-scale studies, including data from the Framingham Heart Study, have shown that in people over 50, systolic pressure and pulse pressure are much better predictors of stroke and heart attack than diastolic pressure. A wide pulse pressure means your heart is working harder to push blood through a resistant system. It's like trying to run a marathon in combat boots. You can do it, but your joints—or in this case, your heart muscle—are going to pay the price.
📖 Related: Sudafed PE and the Brand Name for Phenylephrine: Why the Name Matters More Than Ever
Specifically, a high systolic pressure puts a massive strain on the left ventricle of the heart. Over time, the muscle gets thick and stiff (Left Ventricular Hypertrophy). A stiff heart is a less efficient heart.
Can You "Fix" a Low Diastolic?
This is the tricky part. Most blood pressure medications are designed to lower pressure across the board. If your blood pressure is 160/60, and a doctor gives you a heavy dose of a standard diuretic or beta-blocker, your systolic might drop to a healthy 120. Great, right?
Not necessarily.
If the medication also drops your diastolic from 60 down to 45, you’re going to feel like absolute garbage. You might get dizzy when you stand up (orthostatic hypotension) or feel a weird brain fog. This is because the coronary arteries—the ones that feed the heart muscle itself—actually get most of their blood flow during the diastolic phase. If the diastolic pressure gets too low, you might actually be starving your heart of oxygen while trying to "fix" your blood pressure.
This is why managing isolated systolic hypertension requires a bit of a "Goldilocks" approach.
Actionable Steps to Narrow the Gap
If you're staring at a wide gap in your numbers, don't panic, but do start making adjustments. You can't always "un-stiffen" an artery overnight, but you can improve how they function.
👉 See also: Silicone Tape for Skin: Why It Actually Works for Scars (and When It Doesn't)
1. Aerobic Exercise is Non-Negotiable
Not heavy weightlifting—that can actually stiffen arteries further if done incorrectly. Think rhythmic, aerobic movement. Brisk walking, cycling, or swimming. This triggers the release of nitric oxide, which helps the inner lining of your arteries (the endothelium) relax and become more elastic.
2. Watch the Sodium, but Up the Potassium
Everyone talks about salt, but potassium is the "antidote" to sodium. It helps ease the tension in your blood vessel walls. Reach for avocados, spinach, and bananas.
3. Check Your Medications
Some over-the-counter meds can worsen the gap. Decongestants containing pseudoephedrine are notorious for spiking systolic pressure while leaving the diastolic alone. If you have a cold, check the label.
4. Get a Professional "Manual" Reading
Home monitors are great, but they are often calibrated for "standard" blood pressure patterns. If you have a very wide pulse pressure or an irregular heartbeat, the digital sensor might struggle to get an accurate diastolic reading. Go to your doctor and ask for a manual reading with a stethoscope. It’s still the gold standard for a reason.
5. Consider Your Stiffness Triggers
Smoking is the obvious one, but chronic high blood sugar (pre-diabetes) is a stealthy "gluer" of arteries. It causes "Advanced Glycation End-products" (appropriately called AGEs) that cross-link the collagen in your artery walls, making them brittle.
The Path Forward
The "why is my systolic high and my diastolic low" question is usually a sign that your vascular system is changing its architecture. It's moving from a flexible system to a rigid one.
The goal isn't just to "hit a number." The goal is to protect your organs. If you’re seeing these numbers consistently, it’s time to have a specific conversation with a healthcare provider about arterial stiffness. Ask them if you should be screened for aortic valve issues or if your current medication might be dropping your diastolic too low.
Monitor your readings at different times of the day—specifically first thing in the morning and right before bed—and keep a log. This data is worth its weight in gold when you're trying to fine-tune a treatment plan that keeps your "top" number safe without letting the "bottom" number fall off a cliff.