Ever opened a block of sharp cheddar and wondered why it looks like a highlighter? It’s a weird thing when you actually think about it. Milk is white. Like, aggressively white. Yet, we walk into a grocery store and see wheels of Gouda, slices of American, and wedges of Gloucester that range from a pale straw to a neon sunset. You’ve probably heard it’s just food coloring. That’s partially true, but it’s honestly a much deeper rabbit hole involving seasonal diets, 17th-century fraud, and a tiny seed from the tropics.
The question of why is cheese yellow isn't just about aesthetics. It’s about history.
It all starts with what the cow is eating
Long before we had industrial factories, cheese color was a seasonal marker. Cows that spent their days lounging in lush, green pastures were eating grass rich in beta-carotene. If that sounds familiar, it’s because it’s the same stuff that makes carrots orange. Beta-carotene is fat-soluble. When a cow eats grass, the pigment gets stored in its fat globules.
But there’s a biological twist.
When that cow produces milk, the beta-carotene is carried along in the cream. However, in its liquid form, milk still looks white. This happens because the fat globules are surrounded by a thin membrane that reflects light, masking the pigment inside. You don't see the yellow until you start making cheese. When a cheesemaker agitates the milk and breaks those membranes, the fat clusters together. The "mask" is gone. The yellow pigment is released.
This is why traditional summer cheeses were naturally golden. They were a direct reflection of a healthy, pasture-raised diet.
Why goats and sheep are the exception
You might have noticed that goat cheese or Manchego (made from sheep's milk) is almost always stark white. Why? It's not because they eat different stuff. It’s biology. Goats and sheep are much more efficient at converting beta-carotene into Vitamin A, which is colorless. Their bodies "process out" the yellow before it ever hits the milk pail. So, if you see a bright yellow goat cheese, something very strange—and probably artificial—is going on.
The great 17th-century cheese scam
Here is where things get kinda scandalous. Historically, the yellow tint became a signal of quality. If your cheese was golden, it meant it was high-fat and made from rich summer milk. People wanted that. They associated the color with flavor and luxury.
Cheesemakers, being business-minded (and sometimes a bit sneaky), realized they could make more money by skimming the cream off the top of the milk to sell separately or make butter. They’d then make cheese with the remaining low-fat milk. The problem? That "skimmed" cheese looked white and pathetic. It looked cheap because it was cheap.
To hide the fact that they had stolen the cream, they started adding pigments to the low-fat milk. They were essentially faking the high-fat look. They used things like saffron, carrot juice, and eventually, annatto.
What is annatto, anyway?
If you look at a label of yellow cheddar today, you’ll almost certainly see "annatto" listed. It’s the seeds from the achiote tree (Bixa orellana), which grows in tropical regions like Central and South America. It’s been used for centuries as a dye for textiles and body paint.
In the world of dairy, it’s the king of colorants.
It’s potent. It’s stable. It doesn’t really affect the flavor in the small amounts used for coloring. It’s the reason why Wisconsin cheddar looks the way it does. Interestingly, the tradition of using annatto became so ingrained in certain regions—like Cheshire and Gloucester in England—that even when they weren't trying to scam people anymore, consumers just expected their cheese to be orange. It became a brand identity.
The regional divide
If you go to Vermont, you’ll find a lot of white cheddar. If you go to Wisconsin, it’s mostly yellow. There is no chemical difference in the "cheddaring" process between the two. It’s purely a matter of regional tradition and consumer expectation. Folks in the Northeast stuck to the natural look, while the Midwest embraced the annatto-tinted heritage of their ancestors.
Is the color actually changing the flavor?
Honestly? No. Not chemically.
Pure annatto has a slightly nutty, peppery vibe, but the concentration in your average block of Sharp Cheddar is so low that your taste buds can't really pick it up. However, your brain is a different story.
Multiple sensory studies, including work by researchers like MaryAnne Drake at North Carolina State University, suggest that our perception of flavor is heavily tied to color. In blind taste tests, people often describe yellow cheeses as tasting "sharper" or "creamier" than the exact same cheese left white. We eat with our eyes first. If it looks like a rich, aged cheddar, our brain convinces us it tastes like one.
The modern reality of why cheese is yellow
Today, most cattle aren't grazing on fresh pasture year-round. Many are fed grain or hay, especially in the winter. Grain-fed cows produce milk with very little beta-carotene. If we didn't add color, most of our cheese would be a dull, off-white color regardless of the season.
Using annatto provides consistency. Large-scale producers want the block of cheese you buy in January to look identical to the one you buy in July. Without a coloring agent, the "natural" color of cheese would shift constantly throughout the year, which would freak out most modern supermarket shoppers.
Does "natural" mean better?
Not necessarily. You can have a very high-quality, pasture-raised cheese that is naturally pale because the cows were grazing in the winter. Conversely, you can have a low-quality, processed "cheese food" slice that is bright orange thanks to a heavy dose of annatto or even apocarotenal.
The color is a signal, but in the modern world, it's a signal that can be easily manipulated.
Identifying quality beyond the tint
If you want to know if you're getting the "good stuff," don't look at how yellow it is. Look at the texture and the ingredient list.
- Check for "Annatto" or "Achiote": If it's orange, this should be there. If you see "Yellow 5" or "Yellow 6," you're looking at a highly processed product, not traditional cheese.
- The "Sweat" Test: High-quality, naturally fatty cheeses will "bead" a little oil when brought to room temperature. This is the fat (and that beta-carotene) saying hello.
- The Season Matters: If you’re buying from a local artisan creamery, ask when the cheese was made. A "summer" cheese made without additives will naturally be more golden than a "winter" cheese from the same farm.
Your Next Steps for a Better Cheese Board
Next time you're at the deli counter, try a side-by-side comparison. Buy a small piece of Vermont White Cheddar and a piece of Sharp Yellow Cheddar. Close your eyes and taste them. See if you can actually tell the difference once the visual cue is gone.
💡 You might also like: Kansas City MO Weather: Why the Forecast Always Keeps You Guessing
If you want to experience the "real" yellow of history, look for labels that say "Pasture-Raised" or "Grass-Fed" and check for a lack of added colorants. You’ll likely find a cheese that is a soft, buttery cream color—the true result of a cow eating exactly what it was meant to eat.
For the best flavor experience, always take your cheese out of the fridge at least 30 minutes before eating. Cold temperatures mute the fats, and since the fats hold the color and the flavor, you’re literally chilling the life out of your snack. Let it breathe, let the oils soften, and enjoy the chemistry of the pasture.