Finding a place to crash in Manhattan is usually a nightmare of overpaying for a room the size of a shoebox. Honestly, it’s exhausting. If you’ve been looking at the Hotel Indigo New York brand, you’ve probably noticed something confusing: there isn’t just one.
New York City doesn't do "one size fits all." Currently, if you’re looking for that specific Indigo vibe—which is basically InterContinental Hotels Group's (IHG) attempt at being the "cool parent" of hotel chains—you’re likely looking at two main spots: the Hotel Indigo Lower East Side New York and the Hotel Indigo NYC Downtown - Wall Street. They are both under the same brand umbrella, but they feel like completely different planets.
The Lower East Side: Gritty Luxury and That Famous Pool
If you want to feel like you’re actually in New York and not just visiting a museum of it, the Lower East Side (LES) location on Ludlow Street is the heavy hitter. It’s loud. It’s colorful. The lobby isn't even on the ground floor; you have to take an elevator up to the 14th floor just to check in.
That first moment when the elevator doors open? It’s a total flex. The 360-degree views of the Manhattan skyline are arguably some of the best in the city, mainly because the building towers over the surrounding tenements.
The rooms here reflect the neighborhood's history. Think hardwood floors, unpolished concrete ceilings, and murals by local artists like Lee Quiñones. It’s "industrial chic," but actually done well, not just some cheap exposed piping. You’re steps away from Katz’s Delicatessen. You can smell the pastrami from the sidewalk.
But here’s the thing people miss: the noise.
Ludlow Street is a nightlife epicenter. If you’re a light sleeper, this place might drive you crazy. You’ve got Mr. Purple, the rooftop bar, right upstairs. It is a massive draw for locals and tourists alike. In the summer, the rooftop pool is the place to be, but don’t expect a quiet lap swim. It’s a scene. A vibe. A place to see and be seen while holding a $20 cocktail.
What’s the Deal with the Wall Street Location?
Now, flip the script. The Hotel Indigo NYC Downtown - Wall Street is a totally different beast. Located on Maiden Lane, this spot is tucked into the narrow, winding streets of the Financial District (FiDi).
📖 Related: Food in Kerala India: What Most People Get Wrong About God's Own Kitchen
While the LES location is for the midnight crowd, the Wall Street Indigo is for the "I have a 9:00 AM meeting but want a cool shower" crowd. The design leans into the neighborhood's history—think gold accents and "old money" aesthetics reimagined for the 2020s.
FiDi used to be a ghost town after 6:00 PM. That’s changed. With the Seaport District nearby and the Oculus, it’s more lived-in now. However, the energy is still buttoned-up. You stay here because you want to be near the 9/11 Memorial, the Stock Exchange, or the ferries to Brooklyn.
Why the "Boutique" Label is Sorta Complicated
People call Indigo a boutique hotel. Is it? Technically, it’s a global chain. IHG owns it, alongside Holiday Inn and InterContinental.
The trick Indigo pulls off—and why it ranks so high for travelers—is that each property is required to reflect the local neighborhood. That’s why the LES location has street art and the Wall Street one has nautical and financial nods. They aren't cookie-cutter.
You’ll find "neighborhood guides" in the rooms, curated by the staff. It feels personal, even if the backend is a massive corporate machine. It’s a smart middle ground for people who are scared of Airbnb but bored of the Marriott Marquis.
Navigating the Room Situation: What to Actually Expect
Let's talk about the space. This is New York.
Unless you are booking the "King Terrace Suite" at the Lower East Side location, don't expect to host a dance party in your room. The standard rooms are efficient. Some might say small.
👉 See also: Taking the Ferry to Williamsburg Brooklyn: What Most People Get Wrong
- The Bathrooms: Usually have spa-inspired walk-in showers. No tubs in most standard rooms, so keep that in mind if you’re a bath person.
- The Tech: Generally updated. Most have easy casting for your phone to the TV.
- The Windows: This is where the value is. Even the smaller rooms often have floor-to-ceiling windows. In a city where some hotels have windows facing a brick wall two feet away, this is a huge win.
The Hidden Gems and Frustrations
One thing that doesn't get mentioned enough is the elevator situation at the LES property. Since the lobby and the bar are both high up, those elevators work hard. During peak bar hours on a Saturday night, you might be waiting a while. It’s the price you pay for the view.
On the flip side, the fitness centers are surprisingly decent. Most hotel gyms are a sad treadmill in a basement. The Indigo gyms usually have natural light and modern equipment like Peloton bikes.
Comparing the Costs: Is it Worth the Premium?
New York hotel prices fluctuate wildly. One night it's $250, the next it's $700 because some tech conference is in town.
Generally, the Hotel Indigo New York options sit in that "upper mid-scale" bracket. You are paying for the location and the aesthetic. If you just need a bed, there are cheaper Pod Hotels nearby. If you want a full-service experience with a bellhop and three on-site restaurants, you go to the Four Seasons.
Indigo lives in the "I want a cool photo for my Instagram, a comfortable bed, and a bar downstairs" space.
Making the Choice
If you're still torn between the locations, ask yourself what you want to see when you walk out the front door.
- Lower East Side: You step out into street art, skate shops, and some of the best small-plate restaurants in the world. It’s gritty. It’s loud. It’s the "real" Manhattan.
- Wall Street: You step out into canyons of stone and glass. It’s cleaner, quieter at night, and closer to the water.
There was also a Chelsea location, but the hotel landscape in NYC is constantly shifting with rebranding and management changes. Always check the specific street address before you book to make sure you're getting the neighborhood you actually want.
✨ Don't miss: Lava Beds National Monument: What Most People Get Wrong About California's Volcanic Underworld
Actionable Steps for Your New York Stay
If you’re ready to pull the trigger on a stay at an Indigo property in NYC, here is how to do it without losing your mind or your savings.
Book directly through the IHG One Rewards site. Even if you aren't a "points person," the member rates are almost always $10–$20 cheaper per night than Expedia or Booking.com. Plus, if the hotel overbooks, they are way less likely to "walk" a direct-booking guest to another hotel than someone who booked through a third-party site.
Request a high floor at the Lower East Side location. If you are on a lower floor, the street noise from Ludlow will haunt you. The 20th floor is a whole different world than the 5th floor.
Check the "Amenity Fee" (The Destination Fee). New York hotels love to hide these. It’s usually around $25–$35 a night. At Indigo, this often includes a credit for the bar or pantry. Use it. Don't let them take that money for nothing. Most guests forget they have a $15 daily beverage credit and leave it on the table.
Skip the hotel breakfast. You’re in New York. At the LES Indigo, walk three minutes to Russ & Daughters for a bagel. At Wall Street, find a local cart or a small bodega. Hotel eggs are hotel eggs everywhere; New York bagels are a religious experience.
Check the Mr. Purple schedule. If you’re staying at the LES location, check if there’s a private event at the rooftop bar. There’s nothing worse than planning a sunset drink only to find out a corporate law firm has rented out the whole deck.
The Hotel Indigo New York experience is ultimately what you make of it. It’s a stylish, reliable home base in a city that can otherwise feel overwhelming. Choose your neighborhood wisely, bring some earplugs just in case, and make sure you actually spend some time looking out those floor-to-ceiling windows. That’s what you’re really paying for.