Honestly, most home renovation shows are just... loud. You know the ones. There is a lot of screaming about "open concepts," sledgehammers hitting drywall for the sake of a dramatic transition, and a frantic race against a fake clock. But In With the Old Season 4 hits different. It isn’t about flipping a house for a quick buck or turning a historic Victorian into a bland, gray box. It’s actually about the dust. The history. The weird, stubborn people who decide that a crumbling 1800s schoolhouse or a neglected soda fountain is worth saving, even when their bank accounts and their families are telling them to run away.
If you’ve been following the series on Magnolia Network or Discovery+, you already know the vibe. But In With the Old Season 4 felt like a turning point for the production. It leaned harder into the "why" rather than just the "how."
The Raw Reality of In With the Old Season 4
Most people get it wrong when they talk about this season. They think it’s just another collection of "before and after" shots. It’s not. It’s a love letter to craftsmanship that most of us forgot existed.
Take the episode featuring the restoration of the 1900s bank in Texas. That wasn't just a paint job. The designers had to figure out how to keep the original vault—a massive, literal ton of steel—as a focal point without making the place feel like a cold basement. It’s that kind of specific, regional problem-solving that makes In With the Old Season 4 so addictive. You aren't watching a generic contractor in Los Angeles; you're watching a couple in a tiny town in the Midwest sweat over whether they can save original lath and plaster.
It's gritty. It's slow. Sometimes, they don't even finish everything they wanted to. That’s the beauty of it.
Why the "Old" Matters More Than the "In"
We live in a disposable world. If a toaster breaks, we buy a new one. If a house gets old, we tear it down and put up three "modern farmhouses" that look exactly like a Starbucks.
📖 Related: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
In With the Old Season 4 challenges that entire mindset. The creators, including the visionary team behind Magnolia, curated stories this season that emphasize "adaptive reuse." This isn't just a buzzword. It’s the practice of taking a building that has outlived its original purpose—like a general store or a tannery—and giving it a second life as a home or a community hub.
One of the standouts this season was the restoration of the "Main Street" buildings. Small-town America is disappearing, but these episodes show that with enough stubbornness and a few vintage woodworking tools, you can actually bring the heart of a town back to life. It’s about soul. You can’t buy soul at a big-box hardware store.
The Designers Who Stole the Show
Every episode features a different team. It’s an anthology style that keeps the pacing from getting stale. In Season 4, we saw a massive range of expertise.
- The Purists: People who won't even use a modern screw if they can find a hand-forged nail from 1880.
- The Eclectics: Designers who mix mid-century modern furniture with crumbling stone walls.
- The DIY Warriors: Families who are literally doing the tiling themselves at 2:00 AM while the kids are asleep.
That variety is key. In previous seasons, the show sometimes felt a bit repetitive. But by the time In With the Old Season 4 rolled around, the producers clearly felt more comfortable letting the individual personalities of the renovators shine through. You feel their stress. You see the moments where they realize the foundation is cracked and they're $20,000 over budget. It’s relatable, even if most of us wouldn't dream of buying a haunted-looking mansion in the middle of nowhere.
Breaking Down the Technical Mastery
Let's get into the weeds for a second. If you’re a fan of the show, you probably appreciate the cinematography. It’s shot differently than HGTV hits. There’s a lot of "slow TV" influence here. The camera lingers on the texture of old wood. It watches the way light hits a hand-blown glass windowpane.
👉 See also: Cuba Gooding Jr OJ: Why the Performance Everyone Hated Was Actually Genius
In Season 4, the editing became even more refined. They stopped rushing the "reveal." They realized that the audience actually wants to see the joinery. We want to see how the crown molding was matched to a sample that’s been rotting for fifty years.
Why Restoration is Harder than Renovation
Renovation is making something new. Restoration is a puzzle where half the pieces are missing and the other half are covered in lead paint.
The experts in In With the Old Season 4 often talk about the "burden of history." When you take on a project like the ones seen this season, you aren't the owner; you’re a steward. You’re looking after the building for the next hundred years. This season highlighted the immense pressure that comes with that. If you mess up the exterior of a landmarked building, you aren't just losing money—you're erasing a piece of the town's identity.
Common Misconceptions About the Show
People often ask if the show is fake. "Did they really do all that work?"
While every TV show has a production schedule, In With the Old is famously more authentic than its competitors. The timelines are often stretched over months, sometimes years. Season 4 captures projects that were clearly long-term labors of love. The sweat is real. The budget collapses are real.
✨ Don't miss: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
Another misconception? That you need a million dollars to do this. While some projects are high-end, Season 4 also showcased people working with very little. They used salvaged materials. They traded labor. They found beauty in things other people literally threw in the trash.
How to Apply the Lessons of Season 4 to Your Own Home
You don't have to buy a 12,000-square-foot abandoned hotel to get something out of this show. The "In With the Old" philosophy is actually pretty practical for the average homeowner.
First, stop ripping everything out. Before you demo that "ugly" wood paneling or replace those "dated" windows, look at the quality. Is it solid oak? Is that glass wavy and beautiful? Season 4 teaches us to look for the character beneath the grime.
Second, embrace the "patina." We’re so obsessed with things looking brand new. But a floor with a few scratches tells a story. A door that's been touched by ten generations of hands has a warmth that a brand-new hollow-core door from a warehouse will never have.
Actionable Steps for the Aspiring Restorer
- Research your home’s "bones." Go to your local library or records office. Find out who lived in your house in 1920. Knowing the history makes you less likely to destroy it.
- Learn one old-school skill. Whether it’s stripping paint without damaging the wood or learning how to glaze a window, doing it yourself connects you to the house.
- Shop architectural salvage. Instead of buying new furniture, look for "pickers" or salvage yards. You can find hardware, lighting, and doors that have ten times the character for half the price.
- Prioritize repair over replacement. It’s almost always better (and often cheaper in the long run) to fix a high-quality old thing than to buy a low-quality new thing.
In With the Old Season 4 isn't just entertainment. It’s a wake-up call. It reminds us that our surroundings matter and that the buildings we inherit are worth the effort it takes to save them. Whether you're a hardcore preservationist or just someone who likes looking at pretty houses, this season stands as a masterclass in what happens when we stop looking for the next big thing and start appreciating what’s already right in front of us.
The real magic isn't in the reveal at the end of the episode. It's in the quiet moments in the middle—the sanding, the planning, and the sheer, stubborn refusal to let a good building die. That's why we keep watching. That's why it matters.
Next Steps for Your Preservation Journey:
- Audit Your Hardware: Check your home for original brass or iron hardware covered in layers of "landlord special" paint. Boiling them in water with a bit of baking soda can reveal incredible 19th-century craftsmanship hiding in plain sight.
- Source Local Materials: Use sites like OldHouseWeb or local architectural salvage directories to find period-accurate materials rather than settling for modern replicas.
- Document the Process: If you start a restoration, take photos of the "ugly" phases. In With the Old proves that the struggle is the most compelling part of the story.