You've heard the rhetoric. It’s everywhere. Turn on the news or scroll through a heated social media thread, and you'll see the same narrative pushed over and over: the idea that newcomers bring chaos. But if you actually sit down with the hard data—the kind of stuff researchers spend decades obsessing over—the reality is the polar opposite. The truth is that immigrants are less likely to commit crimes than people born in the United States. It’s not just a marginal difference, either. We are talking about a consistent, decades-long pattern that holds up across different cities, states, and even generations.
Data is weirdly stubborn.
📖 Related: Who is the Mayor of Little Rock? Frank Scott Jr. and the Reality of Arkansas Politics
Take a look at a massive study published by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) in 2023. Researchers analyzed census data spanning 150 years. They found that since 1960, the gap has only widened. Today, immigrants are 60% less likely to be incarcerated than those born in the U.S. That is a staggering number. It doesn't matter if we're talking about the 1880s or the 2020s; the "immigrant paradox" remains a constant fixture of American criminology.
The Gap Between Perception and Reality
Why do we get this so wrong? Human brains are basically wired to notice the exception rather than the rule. When a tragic crime is committed by someone who isn't a citizen, it becomes a national headline. It’s visceral. It’s scary. But when millions of people move into a neighborhood, start small businesses, and keep their heads down, nobody writes a news story about "Local Man Continues to Obey the Law."
Sociologists call this the "immigrant paradox."
You’d think—or at least the common logic suggests—that people moving to a new country under high stress with limited resources would be more prone to crime. Poverty is often a driver of illegal activity, right? Except, in the case of immigrants, it isn't. Despite often facing language barriers and lower initial wages, this group consistently maintains lower crime rates. Honestly, it’s one of the most well-documented findings in all of social science, yet it’s the one that feels the most counterintuitive to the average person on the street.
What the Numbers Actually Say
Charis Kubrin, a criminology professor at the University of California, Irvine, has spent a huge chunk of her career looking at this. She’s performed meta-analyses—essentially studies of studies—and found that not only do immigrants commit fewer crimes, but cities with high concentrations of immigrants actually tend to be safer.
Think about that for a second.
If the common narrative were true, "border towns" or "immigrant hubs" should be the most dangerous places in the country. Instead, places like El Paso, Texas, frequently rank among the safest large cities in America. It’s not a fluke.
The "Selection Effect" and Why it Matters
There’s a very logical reason why immigrants are less likely to commit crimes, and it’s something called the "selection effect." Basically, the people who choose to pack up their entire lives, leave their families, and move thousands of miles for a chance at a better life are not your "average" people. They are hyper-motivated. They are risk-averse when it comes to legal trouble.
They have everything to lose.
Imagine you've spent years waiting for a visa or risked your life to get here. Are you really going to throw that away for a petty theft or a bar fight? Probably not. The stakes are massive. For a natural-born citizen, a misdemeanor might mean a fine or a night in jail. For an immigrant, it could mean permanent deportation and the destruction of their family's future. That’s a powerful deterrent that most of us born here never have to think about.
The Breakdown by Generation
Here is where it gets even more interesting: the "protective effect" of being an immigrant actually starts to fade by the second and third generation.
✨ Don't miss: Why Can't U.S. Territories Vote for President Explained (Simply)
The kids and grandkids of immigrants—people who were born and raised in the U.S.—actually have crime rates that look almost exactly like the rest of the American population. Basically, they "assimilate" into American culture, and unfortunately, that means they pick up our higher propensity for crime.
- First-generation: Very low crime rates.
- Second-generation: Rates rise to meet the national average.
- Third-generation: Indistinguishable from the general population.
It’s a bit ironic. The more "American" someone becomes, the more likely they are to end up in the justice system. This suggests that the low crime rates aren't about where someone is from, but rather the specific mindset and pressures of the immigrant experience itself.
Public Safety and Neighborhood Revitalization
Beyond just individual statistics, there’s the "Immigrant Revitalization Perspective." This theory suggests that immigration actually reduces crime in neighborhoods that were previously struggling. When immigrants move into a neglected urban area, they don't just occupy space. They open grocery stores. They renovate houses. They fill the streets with foot traffic and "eyes on the street," as Jane Jacobs famously put it.
This social cohesion is a natural repellent for crime.
A 2016 study published in the journal Criminology looked at 200 metropolitan areas over several decades. The researchers found that as immigration increased, the rates of homicide and robbery actually decreased. It’s the exact opposite of the "invasion" rhetoric we see on cable news. Immigrants often act as a stabilizing force in communities that were otherwise losing population and economic steam.
Debunking the "Illegal Alien" Crime Myth
The conversation usually gets even more heated when people talk specifically about undocumented immigrants. People assume that because someone entered the country without inspection, they are inherently more likely to commit other crimes.
But the data from Texas—the only state that specifically tracks the immigration status of people who are arrested—tells a different story.
A study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) used this Texas Department of Public Safety data. They found that undocumented immigrants had substantially lower arrest rates for violent crimes, property crimes, and drug crimes compared to both legal immigrants and native-born citizens.
✨ Don't miss: Nurse Hailey Okula: What Most People Get Wrong About the Case
Specifically, native-born citizens were arrested for violent crimes at a rate over twice as high as undocumented immigrants.
Real Talk: The Nuance We Often Miss
Is every immigrant a saint? No. That would be a ridiculous claim. People are people, and in any group of millions, there will be individuals who do terrible things. When those things happen, they are devastating. But as a matter of policy and public safety, we have to look at the broad reality, not the specific tragedy.
The risk of being a victim of a crime committed by an immigrant is statistically much lower than being a victim of a crime committed by someone born right here in the U.S.
We also have to account for the fact that immigrants are often victims of crime and are less likely to report it. Because of fear of deportation or a general distrust of authorities, many immigrants suffer in silence when they are robbed or assaulted. This means the "crime gap" might actually be even wider than the official data suggests, because immigrants are under-represented in crime reports both as perpetrators and as victims.
Making Sense of the Noise
If you find yourself in a debate about this, keep these specific points in mind:
- Incarceration Rates: Census data shows immigrants are jailed at a fraction of the rate of native-born Americans.
- The Texas Data: The most comprehensive state-level tracking shows undocumented immigrants have lower felony arrest rates than citizens.
- Economic Stabilization: Immigrant-heavy neighborhoods often see a drop in violent crime due to increased economic activity and social ties.
- Generational Shift: The "immigrant advantage" disappears as families spend more time in the U.S., proving it’s the immigrant drive, not ethnicity, that keeps crime low.
Understanding that immigrants are less likely to commit crimes isn't just about being "pro-immigrant." It’s about being pro-fact. When we base our safety policies on myths rather than data, we waste resources and ignore the actual roots of crime in our society.
Actionable Steps for Navigating the Facts
If you want to dive deeper or use this information effectively, here is how to handle the data:
- Check the source: When you see a "crime surge" headline, look for the raw numbers. Is the crime rate rising across the board, or is the article focusing on one specific person to trigger an emotional response?
- Look at "Crime per 100,000": Raw numbers of arrests mean nothing if the population is also growing. Always look for the rate of crime to get an accurate picture.
- Reference the PNAS and NBER studies: These are peer-reviewed, non-partisan sources that provide the most rigorous look at the "immigrant paradox."
- Focus on community health: Support initiatives that integrate newcomers into the community. Data shows that the more connected an immigrant feels to their neighborhood, the safer that neighborhood becomes for everyone.
The evidence is overwhelming. Newcomers aren't the threat to public safety they’re often made out to be. If anything, the data suggests that if we want to lower crime rates, we might want to take a page out of the immigrant handbook: prioritize family, work hard, and keep an eye on your neighbors.