Why How You Can Mend a Broken Heart is Rarely About Closure

Why How You Can Mend a Broken Heart is Rarely About Closure

It hurts. Like, physically hurts. You feel it in your chest, a literal heaviness that makes breathing feel like a chore. People call it "heartbreak" because it feels like something inside actually snapped. If you’re scouring the internet trying to figure out how you can mend a broken heart, you’ve probably already heard the platitudes. "Time heals all wounds," they say. Or, my personal favorite: "There are plenty of fish in the sea." Honestly? Those phrases are useless when you’re staring at your phone at 3:00 AM wondering how a human being can just disappear from your life.

Neuroscience tells us this isn't just "all in your head." When we go through a devastating breakup, the brain reacts in a way that’s strikingly similar to physical pain or even drug withdrawal. Researchers at Rutgers University, led by biological anthropologist Helen Fisher, used fMRI scans to look at the brains of the heartbroken. What they found was fascinating and slightly terrifying: the areas of the brain that light up when you're in physical pain—the secondary somatosensory cortex and the dorsal posterior insula—are the same ones that fire off when you're looking at a photo of an ex who dumped you. You aren't being dramatic. Your brain thinks you've been physically wounded.

💡 You might also like: How Alcohol Destroyed My Life: The Brutal Reality of Addiction

The Chemistry of Why You’re Messed Up

Basically, your brain is a dopamine junkie. When you were in love, you were getting regular "hits" of feel-good chemicals like oxytocin and dopamine. Then, suddenly, the supply was cut off. Cold turkey. This sends your system into a tailspin. You’re essentially going through a neurological detox. This is why you feel that desperate, frantic urge to text them or check their Instagram. It’s a craving. It’s a literal addiction response.

Understanding this is the first step in how you can mend a broken heart without losing your mind in the process. You have to treat yourself like someone recovering from a physical illness or an addiction. You wouldn't tell someone with a broken leg to "just get over it" and go for a run, right? So, stop expecting yourself to be "fine" two weeks after your world collapsed.

Why "Closure" Is Mostly a Myth

We’ve been sold this idea that if we just have one more conversation, everything will make sense. We think that if they explain why they left, the pain will vanish.

It won't.

Searching for closure is usually just a subconscious excuse to see them one last time. You want to see if they look as miserable as you do. You want to see if there's a flicker of regret in their eyes. But here is the hard truth: no explanation will ever be "good enough" to justify the pain you’re feeling. If they say they fell out of love, it hurts. If they say they found someone else, it hurts more. If they say they need to "find themselves," it’s frustratingly vague.

Actually, real closure is something you give yourself. It’s the moment you decide that the "why" doesn't matter as much as the "what." What happened is that the relationship ended. That is the only fact you need to move forward. Guy Winch, a psychologist and author of How to Fix a Broken Heart, argues that we often create "addictive loops" by ruminating on the relationship. We replay the highlight reel. We ignore the fights and the times they made us feel small. To heal, you have to look at the full picture, even the ugly parts.

Practical Steps to Stop the Bleeding

  1. The No-Contact Rule (It’s Not Just a Meme)
    Seriously. Stop. Don't "check-in." Don't look at their stories from a burner account. Every time you see their face or hear their voice, you’re hitting the "reset" button on your brain’s recovery. You need a period of absolute silence to let those dopamine receptors stabilize. It’s not about being petty; it’s about survival.

  2. Rewrite the Narrative
    We tend to idealize the person who left. We turn them into a saint. Take a piece of paper and write down every single way they weren't right for you. Did they chew too loudly? Did they dismiss your feelings? Were they bad with your parents? Keep that list on your phone. Every time you feel that wave of "I miss them" coming on, read the list. Remind yourself of the reality, not the fantasy.

  3. Movement Over Meditation (At First)
    Sometimes sitting still with your thoughts is the worst thing you can do in the early stages. Get out of the house. Walk. Garden. Clean your kitchen. Physical activity helps process the cortisol—the stress hormone—that is currently flooding your system.

  4. Reclaim Your Spaces
    If there's a coffee shop "you guys" always went to, it’s now haunted. You have two choices: avoid it forever or go there with your best friend and make a new memory. Reclaim your territory. Change your bedsheets. Rearrange your living room. Small physical changes signal to your brain that a new chapter has actually started.

The Trap of the "Rebound"

We've all seen it. Someone gets dumped on Tuesday and is on a date by Saturday. While it might provide a temporary distraction, it usually backfires. You’re essentially putting a Band-Aid on a gunshot wound. You aren't mending your heart; you're just numbing it with someone else's attention.

That said, there is a nuance here. Some studies suggest that "rebound" relationships aren't always the disaster they're made out to be, provided you’re honest with the other person. But if you’re using someone as a human shield against your own feelings, you’re just delaying the inevitable. You eventually have to sit with the sadness. There's no way around it, only through it.

When to Seek Professional Help

There is a real condition called Takotsubo Cardiomyopathy, often referred to as "Broken Heart Syndrome." It’s a temporary heart condition that’s often brought on by stressful situations, such as the death of a loved one or a traumatic breakup. It can actually mimic a heart attack. If you are experiencing chest pain, shortness of breath, or an irregular heartbeat, please don't just "tough it out." Go to a doctor.

On the emotional side, if you find that after several months you still can't function—if you aren't eating, can't sleep, or are having thoughts of self-harm—it’s time to talk to a therapist. There is no shame in needing a professional to help you navigate the wreckage. Grief isn't linear, but it should be moving. If you feel "stuck" in the same place for months on end, a therapist can help you identify the cognitive blocks keeping you there.

Why How You Can Mend a Broken Heart Matters for Your Future

The way you handle this breakup sets the tone for your next relationship. If you bury the pain, you'll carry the baggage into the next one. If you over-analyze and become cynical, you’ll build walls that prevent future connection.

Mending your heart isn't about becoming "whole" again, because you aren't actually broken. You’re wounded. And wounds leave scars. But scars are tougher than regular skin. You’re learning about your boundaries, your needs, and your resilience. You’re discovering that you can survive the thing you thought would kill you. That is a powerful piece of self-knowledge to carry forward.

Actionable Next Steps

  • Audit your social media. Mute or unfollow. You don't need to see them living their life while you're trying to rebuild yours.
  • Establish a "Breakup Buddy." One person you can text whenever you have the urge to text your ex. They are your designated "hold my phone" person.
  • Schedule your "Grief Time." It sounds weird, but give yourself 20 minutes a day to just sob and feel miserable. When the timer goes off, wash your face and do something else. It prevents the sadness from bleeding into every single hour of the day.
  • Focus on "Micro-Wins." Today, maybe you just showered and ate a real meal. That’s a win. Tomorrow, maybe you go to the grocery store without crying in the cereal aisle. Celebrate the small steps.
  • Invest in "Newness." Buy a new scent, start a hobby you never did with your ex, or travel somewhere you’ve never been. Create a version of yourself that never knew them.