It’s the most trivial debate in the history of indoor plumbing. Or is it? You walk into the bathroom, reach for the roll, and find it's backwards. Maybe you’re an "over" person and someone flipped it to "under." Maybe you don’t care at all. But for a surprisingly large chunk of the population, learning how to put toilet paper on the roll the "right" way is a matter of hygiene, aesthetics, and even intellectual superiority.
Seriously. People have lost their minds over this.
The Patent That Settled the Score
Let's get the historical heavy hitter out of the way first. If you want to end an argument at a dinner party, you bring up Seth Wheeler. In 1891, Wheeler—the founder of the Albany Perforated Wrapping Paper Company—patented the roll we use today. If you look at the original patent drawings (Patent No. 459,516), the paper is clearly depicted hanging over the top.
Wheeler didn't just invent the roll; he invented the perforations. Before him, you were basically hacking away at a continuous sheet of paper like a barbarian. His whole pitch was about reducing waste. By hanging the paper in the "over" position, the perforations are easier to see and grab. It's a design feature, not a suggestion.
But humans are contrarians. We love to mess with a good thing.
The Over vs. Under Debate: Why It Matters
Most people think this is just about habit. It isn't. There are actually functional reasons for both sides, even if one side is objectively better for your health.
The Case for Over
This is the gold standard. When you hang the paper over the roll, it hangs away from the wall. This is a big deal. Why? Because bathroom walls are gross. Even if you clean yours regularly, they accumulate dust and, well, "bathroom particles." When the paper hangs over, your hands only touch the paper you're about to use. You aren't dragging your knuckles against the drywall or the back of the dispenser.
💡 You might also like: Finding the most affordable way to live when everything feels too expensive
It’s also just easier to grab. You can see the edge. You don't have to go on a scavenger hunt behind the roll like you're searching for a lost treasure in a dark cave. If you're using high-ply, quilted paper with a pattern, "over" ensures the pretty side faces out. Manufacturers literally print the designs so they look best in the over position.
The Case for Under
Now, if you have a cat or a toddler, "under" is the survivalist's choice. We’ve all seen the videos. A bored tabby cat discovers the toilet paper roll and bats at it until the entire bathroom is buried in a white, fluffy mountain. If the paper is hung "over," every paw swipe unspools more paper. It’s a literal treadmill of waste.
However, if you flip it to "under," the cat’s downward swatting just spins the roll in place. Nothing unspools. It’s a defensive maneuver. Some people also argue it looks "tidier" because the loose end is tucked away. They're wrong, but they're entitled to their opinion.
The Psychology of the Roll
Believe it or not, psychologists have actually looked into this. Dr. Gilda Carle created a "Toilet Paper Personality Test" where she surveyed 2,000 people about their rolling habits. Her findings? People who prefer "over" tend to be more dominant and take-charge types. Those who prefer "under" are often more submissive or laid-back.
It sounds silly. It probably is. But it highlights how a tiny, repetitive action can reflect our need for control. When someone flips your roll at home, it feels like a personal slight. It’s a micro-invasion of your space.
How to Put Toilet Paper on the Roll the Right Way
Let's talk mechanics. It’s not rocket science, but there is a technique to doing it efficiently so you aren't fumbling with a spring-loaded rod that shoots across the room like a projectile.
📖 Related: Executive desk with drawers: Why your home office setup is probably failing you
- Remove the empty cardboard core. Don’t leave it sitting on the counter. Don't put it in the trash if you can recycle it. Just get it out of the way.
- Compress the spring-loaded spindle. Most holders use a telescoping rod. Push one end in, tilt it, and pull it out. If you have one of those fancy "pivot" arms that just lifts up, I envy you.
- Orient the new roll. This is the moment of truth. Hold the roll so the loose end is draped over the top, hanging toward you.
- Slide the spindle through. Make sure it’s centered.
- Lock it back into the bracket. Insert one end of the spindle into the hole, compress, and snap the other side in. Give it a test spin. It should move freely.
If you’re in a public restroom or a guest’s house, please, for the love of all that is holy, don't change their roll direction. Even if they have it "under" and it's killing you inside. It’s their house. Their rules.
Hygiene, Germs, and the "Wall Contact" Problem
There is a serious side to this. A study from the University of Colorado found that public bathrooms are essentially hotbeds for bacteria like E. coli and MRSA. When you use the "under" method, you are significantly more likely to touch the wall or the dispenser housing.
In a shared environment, this is how germs spread. Someone with unwashed hands fumbles for the end of the paper, brushes their fingers against the wall, and leaves behind a microscopic gift for the next person. By keeping the paper "over," you minimize contact with everything except the paper you are actually using. It's a simple way to stay a little bit cleaner.
Variations and Modern Dispensers
The world of how to put toilet paper on the roll is changing. We’re seeing more "pivot" style holders where the arm just swings up. These are great because they remove the "the spindle flew into the toilet" risk.
Then there are the jumbo rolls. You see these in offices and airports. They’re usually locked in giant plastic shells. In those cases, the direction is almost always "under" because the dispensers are designed to create tension so people don't use too much. It’s a cost-saving measure, not a preference.
And let’s not forget the "European" style holders which are basically just a horizontal hook. These make it incredibly easy to swap rolls, which ironically means people are more likely to actually do it rather than just leaving the new roll sitting on top of the empty one.
👉 See also: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
Why We Fight About It
At the end of the day, the toilet paper debate is a "safe" argument. In a world full of high-stakes political and social tension, arguing about whether the paper should go over or under is a relief. It’s a way to vent frustration without actually hurting anyone.
We cling to our "over" or "under" preference because it’s one of the few things in our daily environment we can perfectly control. It's about order. It's about the "right" way to do things.
Actionable Steps for a Better Bathroom Experience
If you're ready to take your bathroom game to the next level, stop just throwing the roll on the holder and hope for the best.
- Check your hardware. If your spindle is squeaky or gets stuck, a tiny drop of mineral oil or even a rub with a wax candle on the ends can make it spin like a dream.
- The "Fold" Trick. If you want to feel like you're staying at a five-star hotel, fold the end of the "over" roll into a neat triangle. It makes it easier for the next person to grab and looks surprisingly classy for something that takes three seconds.
- Storage Matters. Keep your extra rolls in a dry spot. Bathrooms are humid. If you store your paper right next to the shower without a cover, it absorbs moisture and loses that "fluff" factor.
- The "One-Handed" Test. If you can’t rip off a square with one hand, your roll is either too loose or your holder is poorly positioned. You might need a holder with a bit more natural tension.
Basically, just put it on "over." It’s what the inventor wanted. It’s cleaner. It looks better. And unless you have a cat that is a literal agent of chaos, there is no reason to do otherwise.
Stop overthinking it. Just flip the roll and move on with your life. You've got better things to worry about than which way the paper faces, but if you're going to do it, you might as well do it right. Check your rolls tonight. If they're "under," you know what to do. Flip them. Your knuckles—and your guests—will thank you.