You know that feeling when you walk into a thrift store and it just smells like... well, old stuff? Housing Works Thrift Shops Brooklyn Heights isn't that. It’s different. Tucked away on Montague Street, this place feels more like a curated boutique where the neighborhood’s wealthiest residents drop off their last-season Prada because they simply ran out of closet space.
It’s a vibe.
Most people hitting Brooklyn Heights are there for the Promenade or the quiet, tree-lined streets with brownstones that cost more than most small islands. But if you’re looking for the actual soul of the neighborhood—and maybe a vintage Chanel blazer or a first-edition Hemingway—you head to 150 Montague St.
Let's be real: thrifting in NYC has changed. It's gotten expensive. It’s gotten crowded. Yet, this specific Housing Works location manages to keep its head above the water, balancing the high-end "Gold Coast" energy of the Heights with the grittier, mission-driven roots of the Housing Works organization. Honestly, it’s one of the few places where you can buy a $5 paperback and a $500 mid-century modern chair in the same transaction while knowing your money is actually doing something good.
What Most People Get Wrong About Housing Works Thrift Shops Brooklyn Heights
People think "thrift shop" and they think of bins. They think of digging through piles of fast fashion.
That’s not what’s happening here.
The Brooklyn Heights location is uniquely positioned. Because the donor base consists of some of the wealthiest families in New York City, the inventory is high-tier. We’re talking about people who donate things because they’re moving to the Hamptons, not because the item is worn out. I’ve seen brand-new Theory suits with the tags still on. It’s wild.
The biggest misconception is that it’s "too expensive" for a thrift store. Sure, you aren't going to find $1 t-shirts like you might at a massive warehouse in the outer boroughs. But you’re also not getting junk. You’re getting value. If you find a West Elm side table for $80 that retails for $350, that’s a win.
The shop is also surprisingly small. If you're expecting a sprawling department store, you'll be disappointed. It’s intimate. It’s cozy. It feels like someone’s very stylish living room. The staff—mostly volunteers—know the regulars by name. There's a level of civility here that you won't find at the frantic Buffalo Exchange locations in Manhattan.
The Mission Behind the Merchandise
We have to talk about why this place exists. It’s not just a business. Housing Works was founded in 1990 by four members of ACT UP. Their goal was—and still is—to end the dual crises of homelessness and AIDS.
👉 See also: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive
Every single dollar spent at Housing Works Thrift Shops Brooklyn Heights goes toward life-saving services. We’re talking about housing, healthcare, and advocacy for New Yorkers living with HIV/AIDS and those who are homeless. When you buy that slightly-used Le Creuset pot, you’re literally helping fund a clinic.
That's the part that hits home. In a city where everything feels like a soulless transaction, this feels like a community effort. The organization is a powerhouse in the advocacy space. They don't just provide services; they fight for policy changes in Albany and D.C.
Strategy for Success: When to Visit and What to Look For
If you show up on a Saturday afternoon, good luck. It’s packed. The narrow aisles of the Montague Street shop become a bit of a bottleneck.
The real pros? They go on Tuesday mornings.
Why? Because the weekend donations have been processed. The shelves are freshly stocked. The energy is calm. You can actually browse the jewelry case without someone breathing down your neck.
- The Furniture Game: The furniture here moves fast. I mean, fast. If you see a velvet sofa you like, buy it. Don’t "go get coffee and think about it." It will be gone.
- The Book Nook: Don't sleep on the book section. While the Housing Works Bookstore in Soho gets all the glory, the Brooklyn Heights branch has a remarkably curated selection of art books and literary classics.
- Designer Labels: Check the "Best of Brooklyn" racks. The staff knows their brands. They separate the high-end stuff, so you don't have to hunt as hard, though the prices reflect that curation.
The "Best of" racks are where the magic happens. I once found a pair of Ferragamo loafers that looked like they’d been worn exactly once. They were priced at $75. In a retail store? Probably $600. That’s the kind of math that makes this place addictive.
Understanding the Pricing Logic
Is everything a steal? No.
Sometimes they miss the mark. You might see a Zara top priced at $20, which is basically what it costs new. It happens. The pricing is done by humans, and sometimes those humans are overly optimistic about a brand name.
However, they have a color-coded tag system. If an item has been sitting on the floor for a while, the price drops. Keep an eye on those signs near the register.
✨ Don't miss: Pink White Nail Studio Secrets and Why Your Manicure Isn't Lasting
The Atmosphere of Montague Street
Montague Street itself is undergoing a bit of a transformation. For a few years, it felt like there were too many empty storefronts. But Housing Works Thrift Shops Brooklyn Heights has remained a constant anchor.
Stepping out of the shop with a brown paper bag full of treasures and walking toward the Promenade—with that view of the Manhattan skyline—is a quintessential Brooklyn experience. It feels grounded.
The shop fits the neighborhood's aesthetic. It’s sophisticated but not snobby. It’s the kind of place where a college student and a retired judge might be fighting over the same vintage lamp.
Why the Volunteer Culture Matters
A lot of the people working there are volunteers. They aren't there for a paycheck; they’re there because they believe in the mission. Or because they love the community.
This changes the shopping experience. You’ll often hear the staff chatting about the history of a piece or recommending another local spot for a good bagel (head to Lassen & Hennigs nearby, by the way). It’s a human connection in an increasingly digital world.
There's a specific kind of pride in the way they display the windows. They aren't just throwing stuff in there; they’re telling a story. One week it might be a "Mid-Century Modern Office" theme, and the next, it’s "Winter in the Catskills." It makes you want to stop and look even if you aren't planning on buying anything.
Comparison: Brooklyn Heights vs. Other Locations
Housing Works has locations all over the city—Chelsea, the Upper West Side, Hell’s Kitchen, Park Slope.
How does the Heights location compare?
- Selection: It’s more "classic" than the Park Slope branch. Park Slope tends to have more kids' gear and quirky, bohemian stuff. Brooklyn Heights is more "classic New York elegance."
- Size: It’s smaller than the Chelsea flagship. This is a pro and a con. Less to walk through, but a higher density of quality items.
- Vibe: It’s quieter. It feels less like a tourist destination and more like a local haunt.
If you’re a serious thrifter, you’ve probably done the "Housing Works Crawl" where you hit multiple shops in one day. If you’re doing that, save the Brooklyn Heights one for the end of your trip. It’s the perfect place to wind down and find that one special piece you didn't know you needed.
🔗 Read more: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you
The Reality of Thrifting in 2026
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room: resellers.
We’ve all seen them. People with their phones out, scanning barcodes and checking eBay prices in real-time. It can be annoying. It can make the shop feel like a battlefield rather than a community space.
But Housing Works handles this well. Because they price their designer items closer to market value, it discourages some of the "flipping" culture. It ensures that the money stays with the charity rather than just going into a reseller's pocket.
It’s a delicate balance. On one hand, you want people to find bargains. On the other hand, the goal is to raise as much money as possible for HIV/AIDS services. Most shoppers here seem to understand that. There’s a general sense of, "Okay, I’m paying a little more, but it’s for a good cause."
What to Bring for Donations
If you’re looking to clear out your own closet, the Brooklyn Heights location is usually happy to take your stuff, but check their hours first. They are picky—and they should be.
They want high-quality, sellable items. Think "gently used" or "like new." If it’s stained, torn, or broken, don't bring it here. Take it to a textile recycling bin instead.
- Clothing: Clean, seasonal items are best. Don't bring heavy wool coats in July.
- Housewares: Glassware, decorative objects, and small kitchen appliances that actually work.
- Art: They love framed art. It’s one of their best sellers.
Donating here is a tax-deductible move, which is a nice perk. But honestly, the real perk is knowing your favorite old jacket isn't going to end up in a landfill. It's going to find a new life on a new person, and the proceeds will help someone get the medicine they need.
Final Thoughts on the Brooklyn Heights Experience
Visiting Housing Works Thrift Shops Brooklyn Heights isn't just about the "haul." It's about the ritual.
It’s about the walk down Montague Street. It’s about the chime of the door as you walk in. It’s about the thrill of the hunt—that split second where you see a flash of a specific fabric or the spine of a book you’ve been looking for for years.
In a world of fast fashion and overnight shipping, there is something deeply satisfying about a physical shop that requires patience and curiosity. It’s a reminder that the best things are usually found when you aren't looking for anything in particular.
Actionable Next Steps
If you're planning to visit or support the shop, here is exactly how to make the most of it:
- Check the Tag Sale: Before you start browsing, ask the person at the register what the "color of the week" is. This can save you 25% to 50% on specific items.
- Follow on Social: Many Housing Works locations post their "new arrivals" on Instagram. It’s a great way to scout furniture before you make the trip.
- Donate Mindfully: If you’re donating, call ahead at (718) 243-0054 to ensure they are currently accepting items, as storage space is limited and they sometimes hit capacity.
- Make it a Day Trip: Combine your visit with a walk to the Brooklyn Heights Promenade. It’s two blocks away and offers the best view of the Manhattan skyline for free.
- Become a Member: If you’re a frequent shopper, consider a Housing Works membership. You get early access to "Best of" sales events and a discount on most purchases, which pays for itself if you're a regular.