It is basically a cliffside dream. You’ve probably seen the photos—those yellow and white striped towels draped over lounge chairs, the sparkling Tyrrhenian Sea, and that iconic elevator that tunnels through solid rock to reach the beach club. Hotel Il Pellicano Porto Ercole isn't just a hotel; it’s a vibe that has somehow managed to stay cool since the mid-1960s. That’s hard to do. Most "legendary" spots eventually feel like a museum or, worse, a tourist trap. But this place feels like you've been invited to the private home of a very wealthy, very tasteful friend who happens to have a Michelin-starred chef in the kitchen.
The story of how it started is actually kinda romantic. It wasn't built by a massive hospitality corporation. Instead, it was the love child of Michael and Patricia Graham. He was a British aviator; she was an American socialite. They found this rugged, hidden cove on the Monte Argentario peninsula and decided it was the perfect spot to build a club for their glamorous friends. They named it after Pelican Point in California, where they first met. Honestly, the fact that it started as a private retreat is exactly why the layout feels so intimate and rambling today. It wasn't designed for "flow" or "maximizing occupancy." It was designed for parties.
The Aesthetic of Il Pellicano Porto Ercole
Walking into the lobby, you realize quickly that this isn't that sterile, minimalist luxury you find in Dubai or New York. It’s warm. It’s terracotta tiles, sprawling bougainvillea, and stacks of art books. Marie-Louise Sciò, the daughter of Roberto Sciò who bought the hotel from the Grahams in the 70s, is the creative force here. She’s an architect by training, and you can tell. She has this knack for mixing mid-century Italian glamour with stuff that feels totally current.
The rooms are spread across several cottages and the main building. They don't all look the same. Some have massive terraces overlooking the sea, while others feel like tucked-away garden sanctuaries. The color palette stays true to the Tuscan coast—lots of ochre, creamy whites, and deep greens. It’s the kind of place where you actually want to spend time in your room, though the saltwater pool usually wins that battle.
That Famous Beach Club
Let’s talk about the beach club. If you’ve scrolled through Instagram in the last five years, you’ve seen it. But seeing it in person is different. The descent in the glass-fronted elevator gives you this slow-motion reveal of the rocky shoreline. There is no sand here. It’s all about the platforms built directly into the cliffs.
You jump straight into deep, turquoise water. It’s bracing. It’s salty. It’s perfect. The service at the water’s edge is famously attentive but not hovering. You want a Negroni at 11:00 AM? Nobody is going to judge you. In fact, it’s encouraged. The "Pellicano" cocktail is a staple—a refreshing mix that somehow tastes better when you're smelling the Mediterranean salt air.
💡 You might also like: The Largest Spider in the World: What Most People Get Wrong
What People Get Wrong About Monte Argentario
A lot of travelers fly into Rome, head straight to Florence or the Amalfi Coast, and completely skip this area. That is a massive mistake. Porto Ercole is located on Monte Argentario, which used to be an island but is now connected to the mainland by three strips of land. It feels distinct from the rest of Tuscany. It’s more rugged. Less manicured.
When staying at Hotel Il Pellicano Porto Ercole, people often think they should just stay on the property. And sure, it’s hard to leave. But the surrounding area is where you find the soul of Maremma. You have the town of Porto Ercole itself—a charming fishing village where the Dutch royal family used to vacation. Then there’s Porto Santo Stefano on the other side of the mountain, which is a bit more bustling.
- The Orbetello Lagoon: It’s a protected nature reserve. You can see flamingos here. Actual flamingos in Italy.
- The Fortresses: The Spanish ruled this area for a while, and they left behind these massive, imposing forts like Forte Stella. You can hike up to them for views that make your brain short-circuit.
- The Food: This isn't just steak and pasta. It’s seafood-heavy. Crudo, bottarga, and grilled octopus are the stars here.
Dining at the Edge of the World
Eating here is an event. You have two main options: the fine-dining Pelligrano and the more casual Pelligrill.
The fine-dining experience is spearheaded by chefs who understand that when you have ingredients this good, you don't need to hide them under ten layers of foam. The seafood is usually caught that morning. The olive oil probably comes from the trees you walked past on your way to dinner.
Pelligrill is where you go for the "real" Italian summer experience. Think grilled fish, local vegetables, and a bottle of chilled Vermentino. The atmosphere is breezy. It’s the kind of dinner that lasts three hours because you keep ordering "one more" appetizer or a different dessert to share. The sound of the waves hitting the rocks below acts as a natural soundtrack. No cheesy lounge music needed.
📖 Related: Sumela Monastery: Why Most People Get the History Wrong
The Sciò Legacy and Modern Luxury
Roberto Sciò bought the place because he fell in love with it as a guest. That’s a recurring theme. People come here once and then they come back every single year for thirty years. It’s a cult. But not a weird one. Just a group of people who appreciate that the hotel hasn't tried to become a "brand" with fifty locations worldwide. There is only one Pellicano.
Marie-Louise has expanded the world through "ISSIMO," her digital lifestyle platform, but the physical hotel remains the anchor. She’s managed to keep the soul of the 60s alive—the era of Charlie Chaplin and Jackie O—without making it feel like a costume party. It’s a very thin line to walk, and she does it better than almost anyone in the industry.
Logistics: Getting There and Staying There
Don't expect a quick hop from the airport. Getting to Porto Ercole takes effort, which is why it stays exclusive.
- From Rome: It’s about a two-hour drive from Fiumicino (FCO). The road takes you through some beautiful coastal scenery.
- From Florence: Expect about two and a half to three hours depending on traffic.
- By Train: You can take a train to Orbetello-Monte Argentario, but you’ll definitely need a taxi or a rental car from there to reach the hotel.
When to go? May and September are the sweet spots. July and August are scorching and packed, though the sea breeze helps. Late September is particularly magical because the crowds thin out, but the water is still warm from the summer sun.
Realities to Consider
Is it expensive? Yes. Ridiculously so. If you’re looking for a budget Tuscan getaway, this isn't it. You are paying for the history, the privacy, and the fact that the staff knows your name before you’ve even checked in.
👉 See also: Sheraton Grand Nashville Downtown: The Honest Truth About Staying Here
Another thing: the terrain. The hotel is built on a cliff. There are stairs. Lots of them. While the elevator handles the trip to the beach, navigating the rest of the property requires a certain level of mobility. If you have knee issues, ask for a room close to the main building.
Also, it’s quiet. If you’re looking for a Mykonos-style party scene with thumping bass until 4:00 AM, you will be disappointed. This is "quiet luxury" before that phrase became a TikTok trend. It’s about the clink of ice in a glass and the sound of the wind through the pines.
Moving Beyond the Stripes
To really "do" Hotel Il Pellicano Porto Ercole right, you have to lean into the Italian concept of dolce far niente—the sweetness of doing nothing.
Don't overschedule your days. Don't try to see every hilltop town in Tuscany in one week. Spend a whole afternoon just watching the boats go by. Take a boat out yourself. The hotel can arrange a gozzo (a traditional Italian wooden boat) for you to explore the hidden coves of Monte Argentario that aren't accessible by land. This is where you find the truly secret swimming spots.
Your Actionable Plan for a Pellicano Trip
- Book Way Ahead: For peak summer months, you often need to book six to nine months in advance. This isn't a "last-minute deal" kind of place.
- Pack for "Elegant Casual": You don't need a tuxedo, but you'll want linen shirts, high-quality swimwear, and something chic for dinner. Leave the flip-flops for the beach; leather sandals are the move everywhere else.
- Rent a Car: While the hotel can arrange transfers, having your own car allows you to explore the Maremma countryside, visit the Tarot Garden (Giardino dei Tarocchi) by Niki de Saint Phalle—which is an absolute must-see—and eat at local trattorias in Orbetello.
- Try the Pelliclub: Their spa is small but uses products from Santa Maria Novella. Getting a treatment after a day in the sun is a game-changer.
- The "Yellow Stripe" Souvenir: If you can't afford a week-long stay, look into their ISSIMO collaborations. You can often find the iconic towels or beach bags online, bringing a piece of the coast home without the four-figure nightly rate.
The magic of this place is that it feels like it has always been there and will always be there. In a world that's changing way too fast, there’s something deeply comforting about a yellow striped umbrella and a view of the sea that hasn't changed since 1965.