Think about 1989. You’ve got big hair, neon spandex, and synth-pop dominates the airwaves. Then, out of nowhere, this 21-year-old kid from New Orleans drops a record that sounds like it was recorded in 1945. It’s stripped down. It’s piano, bass, and drums. It's Harry Connick Jr in When Harry Met Sally, and honestly, it changed the way we think about movies and music forever.
Rob Reiner didn't just want background noise for his romantic comedy. He wanted a vibe. He wanted Manhattan. He wanted that feeling of walking through Central Park with autumn leaves crunching under your feet while you worry if you're ever going to find "the one." He found that in Harry. Before this movie, Harry Connick Jr. was a jazz prodigy known mostly in New Orleans circles and by hardcore piano enthusiasts. After? He was a superstar. The soundtrack went multi-platinum. It won him his first Grammy.
But it’s weird, right? A movie about modern dating in the 80s leaning so heavily on the Great American Songbook. It shouldn't have worked. Yet, it’s the reason the movie feels timeless today. If they had filled it with 80s pop, it would feel like a relic. Instead, it feels like a classic.
The Big Gamble on a New Orleans "Kid"
When Rob Reiner was putting the film together, he originally looked at Bobby Short. He wanted that sophisticated, cabaret-style energy. But then he heard Harry. At the time, Harry Connick Jr. was barely legal to drink, yet he played with the soul of a man who’d been through three divorces and a world war. He wasn't just a singer; he was an incredible pianist.
The soundtrack isn't just a collection of songs. It’s a character. When you hear "It Had to Be You," you aren't just hearing a cover. You're hearing the emotional climax of the film. Most people don't realize that Harry actually recorded two versions of many of these songs. There’s the version you hear in the film—often instrumental or featuring a full big band—and the version on the When Harry Met Sally soundtrack album, which focuses more on his trio and vocals.
Marc Shaiman, who served as the music's arranger, deserves a ton of credit here. He saw the potential in Harry’s voice. It wasn't perfect. It was a little raw, a little Sinatra-esque but with a Southern drawl. That imperfection is exactly what made it feel human. It felt like Harry (Billy Crystal) and Sally (Meg Ryan). Real. Messy. Authentic.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Why the Music Actually Matters for the Story
Music in movies usually does one of two things: it tells you how to feel, or it covers up a boring transition. Harry Connick Jr in When Harry Met Sally does something different. It provides a sense of history. The movie spans twelve years. By using standards like "Our Love is Here to Stay" or "But Not for Me," the film suggests that Harry and Sally's love isn't just a flash in the pan. It's something that belongs to the ages.
You've probably noticed that the music stops during the most famous scenes. The deli scene? Silent. The argument on the street? No music. Reiner and Connick Jr. knew when to lean in and when to back off. The music is saved for the "in-between" moments. The travel montages. The shots of the New York skyline. It creates a rhythm. It’s basically jazz in cinematic form.
Breaking Down the Soundtrack Album
If you go back and listen to the album today, it’s surprisingly short. It’s only about 38 minutes long. But man, it packs a punch.
- "It Had to Be You" (Trio Version) – This is the definitive one. It’s confident.
- "Our Love is Here to Stay" – A bit more melancholy, fitting for the years they spent apart.
- "Stompin' at the Savoy" – This shows off Harry’s chops as a pianist. He’s not just a "crooner." He’s a beast on the keys.
- "Don't Get Around Much Anymore" – Probably the most famous vocal track on the record. It’s playful. It’s cocky.
People often forget that at the time, jazz was considered "old people music." Harry Connick Jr. made it cool for Gen X. He paved the way for the swing revival of the 90s and artists like Michael Bublé later on. He was the bridge.
The "Sinatra" Comparisons
Was he the next Frank? Everyone said so. Harry hated it. He wanted to be Harry. While Sinatra was the king of phrasing, Connick brought a New Orleans "stride" piano influence that Frank never had. On the When Harry Met Sally tracks, listen to the way he plays behind his own singing. It’s syncopated. It’s got a bit of "dirt" on it.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
The record didn't just sell well; it stayed on the charts for forever. It was the kind of album everyone's parents had, but then the kids started stealing it. It’s rare for a soundtrack to achieve that kind of cross-generational reach without having a single "radio hit" in the traditional sense.
Behind the Scenes Nuance
There’s a specific nuance to the way the album was recorded. They didn't use a bunch of digital polish. You can hear the room. You can hear the sticks hitting the cymbals. It’s an organic sound that mirrors the "realness" of the dialogue written by Nora Ephron.
Ephron’s writing is sharp and fast. Harry’s playing is sharp and fast. It was a match made in heaven. Interestingly, Harry was actually quite nervous about the vocal parts initially. He viewed himself as a piano player first. It was the success of this film that pushed him to embrace the "leading man" vocal persona that defined the next three decades of his career.
The Cultural Legacy
Is it the best romantic comedy soundtrack? Probably. If not the best, it’s certainly the most influential. It taught Hollywood that you don't need the latest Billboard Top 40 hits to sell a movie to young people. You just need a vibe that fits the story.
When you think about Harry Connick Jr in When Harry Met Sally, you aren't just thinking about a singer. You’re thinking about an era of New York that maybe only exists in the movies, but feels 100% real because of the music. It’s the sound of longing. It’s the sound of "I’ve been looking for you my whole life and I finally found you at a New Year’s Eve party."
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
Honestly, it’s just good music. You don't need to love the movie to love the record. But if you love both, it’s a religious experience.
Actionable Takeaways for Music and Movie Fans
If you want to truly appreciate the work Harry Connick Jr. did for this film, don't just stream it on Spotify while you're doing dishes. Do this instead:
- Watch the movie with a focus on the "Bridge" scenes. Notice how the music starts exactly when the dialogue fails the characters. It fills the emotional gaps.
- Compare the Soundtrack to "20". Listen to Harry’s album 20, recorded just before the movie. You can hear him developing the style that would eventually define the When Harry Met Sally sound.
- Listen for the Piano, Not Just the Voice. Harry’s arrangements are complex. If you’re a musician, pay attention to his left-hand work on "Stompin' at the Savoy." It’s master-class level stuff.
- Check Out the Marc Shaiman Connection. Look up other films Shaiman scored. You’ll start to see a pattern in how he uses jazz and traditional pop to ground contemporary stories.
- Create a "Standards" Playlist. Use the movie’s tracklist as a starting point. Compare Harry’s versions to the originals by Ella Fitzgerald or Louis Armstrong. It’s a great way to learn about the history of American music through a modern lens.
The impact of this collaboration can't be overstated. It launched a career, revived a genre, and gave us a soundtrack that sounds just as fresh today as it did in 1989. Whether you're in it for the romance or the brass, it's a masterpiece.
To explore further, look into the 30th-anniversary interviews where Harry and Rob Reiner discuss the "happy accidents" during the recording sessions. Many of the best musical flourishes were improvised on the spot in the studio, proving that the best movie magic isn't always scripted—sometimes it's played on a piano at 2:00 AM.
Investigate the discography of the other musicians on the album as well, particularly Benjamin Jonah Wolfe on bass and Jeff "Tain" Watts on drums. These guys weren't just "session players"; they were giants of the jazz world who brought a level of technical sophistication rarely seen in Hollywood soundtracks. Understanding their contribution makes the listening experience even richer.