Some books feel like a secret handshake. You find someone else who has read Laurie Colwin’s 1978 masterpiece, Happy All the Time, and suddenly you’re in a private club. It’s a club for people who like their romantic comedies sharp, their Manhattan apartments drafty but chic, and their characters remarkably sane. Honestly, in an era of high-stakes "dark romance" and trauma-heavy literary fiction, Colwin’s work feels like an act of rebellion.
She writes about happiness. Real, itchy, complicated happiness.
The Guido and Vincent Dynamic
The book follows two cousins, Guido Morris and Vincent Cardworthy. They are third cousins, actually, a distinction Colwin makes with the kind of specific family-tree fussiness that feels very "old New York." They’ve been friends since the pram. They grow up together, drink beer together, and eventually find themselves in their late twenties, navigating a city that is both idealized and incredibly grounded.
Guido is the serious one. He’s a romantic who analyzes every emotion until it’s threadbare. He meets Holly Sturgis at a museum and decides, on the spot, that he’s in love. Holly is... well, Holly is "perfect." She is precise, she is serene, and she has a terrifying habit of being completely self-contained. At one point, she leaves for France just because life with Guido is getting too predictable. She calls it an "artificial break."
Then there’s Vincent. He’s a cheerful scientist who works on urban planning (specifically garbage, which is a great Colwin touch). He falls for Misty Berkowitz.
Misty is the soul of the book.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
She’s acerbic. She’s misanthropic. She describes herself as "the scourge of God." If Holly is a cool breeze, Misty is a porcupine with a soft underbelly. She doesn't trust Vincent’s cheerfulness. She doesn't trust the concept of easy love. The tension between Vincent’s relentless optimism and Misty’s "Jew-among-Gentiles" skepticism provides the book’s best comedic friction.
Why We Are Still Talking About It in 2026
You might wonder why a novel about upper-middle-class New Yorkers from the seventies is currently having a massive "second life" on social media and in book clubs. It’s not just nostalgia. It’s the prose.
Colwin was a master of what has been called "domestic sensualism." This isn't about smut; it's about the deep, tactile pleasure of a well-made sweater, a perfect cup of coffee, or a clean kitchen. She makes the mundane feel like a sanctuary.
What People Get Wrong
A common critique of Happy All the Time is that "nothing happens."
That’s sort of the point.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
There are no murders. No one gets amnesia. There isn't a secret billionaire or a hidden prophecy. Instead, you get the drama of everyday life:
- The quiet terror of realized happiness.
- The way a partner’s small habit can feel like a "constant shooting pain."
- The struggle to remain an individual while being part of a pair.
Colwin captures the "minutiae of domestic life" in a way that feels incredibly modern. When Holly runs away to a convent (briefly) because she’s pregnant and overwhelmed, it’s a radically human moment. She isn't being a "villain"; she's just a person who needs to own her own space.
The "Misty Berkowitz" Effect
If you’re looking for a character to root for, it’s Misty. The New York Times once compared her to a female Larry David with a vulnerable heart. She’s the one who says the things we actually think but don't say at dinner parties.
Her courtship with Vincent is a masterclass in pacing. She fends him off for ages. Not because she’s "playing hard to get," but because she’s genuinely worried that being with someone so happy will dilute her personality. She eventually learns that "yearning was a remarkably time-consuming pastime and that it was not especially useful."
It's a lesson we're all still trying to learn.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
Reading Laurie Colwin Today
If you’re diving into Colwin for the first time, keep in mind she was writing in a specific time and place. There are "70s-isms"—the constant smoking, the normalized drinking at every meal, the occasional "far out!" It’s a specific slice of white, affluent Manhattan.
But the emotional core is universal.
Actionable Insights for New Readers
If you want to get the most out of Happy All the Time, try these steps:
- Read it for the voice, not the plot. Don't wait for a "twist." Just enjoy the way she describes a room or a character’s internal monologue.
- Pairs well with food. Colwin was also a legendary food writer (check out Home Cooking). Her fiction is best enjoyed with a snack she would approve of—maybe a very good loaf of bread and some salted butter.
- Look for the side characters. Colwin’s minor players—the eccentric uncles, the spacey academics who are "completely interior"—are often the highlights.
- Compare the couples. Most readers find they are either a "Guido and Holly" (striving for perfection) or a "Vincent and Misty" (stumbling toward it). Figuring out which one you are is part of the fun.
Colwin died tragically young at 48 in 1992, but her work has this shimmering, timeless quality. She reminds us that happiness isn't a fluke; it's something you have to be brave enough to accept.
Next Steps for Your Reading List:
If you finish this and need more, move immediately to Family Happiness. It deals with similar themes but through the lens of a long-term marriage and an affair. It’s slightly darker but just as witty. After that, pick up her essay collection Home Cooking to see where the "domestic sensualism" really began.