You see it sometimes in the corner of the gym. A guy standing with a single dumbbell, shrugging his shoulder up to his ear over and over again. Just one side. No alternating. No second weight in the left hand. It looks... off. Honestly, it looks like he forgot half his equipment or just has a very specific itch he can't scratch. But if you’ve ever looked in the mirror and noticed one shoulder sitting significantly lower than the other, you’re looking at a guy working out one trap for a very specific, often frustrating reason. Muscular imbalance isn't just a vanity thing; it’s a biomechanical puzzle that can lead to chronic neck pain or even scoliosis-like symptoms if left unchecked.
The trapezius is a massive, kite-shaped muscle. It runs from the base of your skull, out to the shoulders, and halfway down your back. When we talk about shrugging, we’re mostly hitting the upper fibers. Most people treat them like a pair of bookends—they should be identical. But life isn't symmetrical. We carry heavy bags on one shoulder. We mouse with our right hand for ten hours a day. We lean on the center console of the car. Eventually, one side gets "tight" or overactive, while the other side gets weak and elongated.
The Logic Behind Training Just One Side
Why would anyone intentionally create an imbalance? Usually, they aren't. They’re trying to fix one that already exists. If you have a guy working out one trap, he’s likely dealing with what PTs call "scapular dyskinesis" or simply a glaring size discrepancy.
Think about the way most people train traps. Barbell shrugs are the gold standard. You load up 225 pounds and bounce. The problem? Your dominant side almost always takes the lion's share of the load. It’s subtle. You won't feel it in the moment, but over five years of training, your right trap becomes a mountain while your left looks like a molehill. By switching to unilateral (one-sided) work, you force the nervous system to fire motor units in the lagging muscle without the "help" of the stronger side. It's isolation in its purest form.
It’s not just about looks, though. Dr. Kelly Starrett, author of Becoming a Supple Leopard, often talks about "stable positions." If one trap is significantly weaker, your shoulder blade (scapula) won't sit correctly on your rib cage. This can lead to impingement. It can cause that annoying clicking in your shoulder when you bench press. So, that guy shrugging one side might actually be saving his rotator cuff from a future surgery.
Is It Always a Weakness Issue?
Actually, no. Sometimes the guy working out one trap is doing it because the other side is too tight. This sounds counterintuitive. Why work the weak side if the other side is the one that hurts?
In many cases, the "low" shoulder is actually the one that's stuck in a depressed state. The upper trap’s job is to elevate the scapula. If it’s inhibited—maybe due to a nerve issue or long-term postural habits—it literally can't hold the shoulder up. This creates a stretch-weakness. The muscle is stretched out like an old rubber band and loses its "snap." Shrugging just that side is an attempt to wake up the neurological connection. It's basically a "re-boot" for the muscle.
I've seen this in powerlifters who have a slight "tilt" in their squat. If one trap is thicker, the bar sits unevenly. That creates a kinetic chain nightmare. One hip handles more load, one knee starts to ache, and suddenly a "trap problem" becomes a "knee surgery." It’s all connected.
The "Quasimodo" Effect: When One-Sided Training Fails
You can't just shrug your way out of every problem. If you see a guy working out one trap and his neck is cranked to the side, he’s probably making it worse. The levator scapulae—a deeper muscle—often tries to take over when the trap is weak. If you shrug with poor form, you just tighten the neck and end up with a tension headache that lasts for three days.
Real correction requires more than just shrugs. It requires:
- Checking the first rib: Sometimes a "high" trap is actually a rib that has subluxed upward. No amount of lifting will fix that; you need a chiropractor or a manual therapist.
- Looking at the serratus anterior: This is the "boxer's muscle" under your armpit. If it’s not working, the trap tries to do its job, gets overworked, and grows larger than the other side.
- The "Mirror Test": Stand naked in front of a mirror. Relax. Don't "pose." If your fingertips on your right hand hang lower than the left, you have a genuine length discrepancy or a massive muscular imbalance.
High-Volume vs. High-Load for Asymmetry
If you’re going to be the guy working out one trap, you have to do it right. Going too heavy is the biggest mistake. When the weight is too much, your body recruits the lats, the obliques, and even the legs to "cheat" the weight up. That defeats the purpose.
🔗 Read more: Why the Left Side of Your Face is Puffy and When to Worry
The goal is mind-muscle connection. Use a kettlebell or a dumbbell. Hold the weight on the weak side. Shrug slowly. Hold the contraction at the top for three full seconds. Feel the muscle fibers twitching. Do 15 to 20 reps. You aren't trying to build a massive powerlifting yoke in this specific session; you are trying to tell your brain, "Hey, this muscle exists. Use it."
Interestingly, some bodybuilders like Jay Cutler have talked about unilateral work to polish their symmetry before a show. Even at the highest level of the sport, nobody is perfectly symmetrical. The human heart is on the left. Our liver is on the right. We are internally asymmetrical, so it’s only natural that our exterior reflects that. But on a bodybuilding stage, a half-inch difference in trap height can be the difference between first and fourth place.
Anatomy of the Perfect Unilateral Shrug
Don't just stand there and wiggle your shoulder. To get the most out of being the guy working out one trap, you need to manipulate the angle.
- The Lean: Grab a squat rack for support with your free hand. Lean slightly (about 10 degrees) away from the side you’re working. This aligns the fibers of the upper trap more vertically with gravity.
- The Scapular Set: Don't let the weight pull your shoulder forward. Keep your chest up.
- The Path: Shrug "up and back" toward your ear, not just straight up.
- The Controlled Negative: Lower the weight over a 4-second count. This eccentric phase is where most of the structural change happens.
What Research Says About Unilateral Training
There is a fascinating concept called "Cross-Education." Studies have shown that if you train one side of the body, the neural pathways for the other side also improve. A study published in the Journal of Applied Physiology found that strength gains can be transferred to the untrained limb via the nervous system.
However, in the case of the guy working out one trap, he’s usually trying to stop the stronger side from progressing so the weaker side can catch up. This is the "catch-up" protocol. You might do three sets on your weak side and only one (or zero) on your strong side for a few weeks. It feels "wrong" to train unevenly, but the body is remarkably adaptable.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
If you're going to try this, don't be the guy who ends up in the physical therapist's office.
- Stop Using Straps: At least at first. Use your grip. It engages the entire "pulling" chain.
- Watch Your Head: Don't tuck your chin or tilt your head toward the weight. Keep your gaze straight ahead. Tilting the head compresses the cervical spine under load. Bad news.
- Ignore the Ego: People will look at you. They'll wonder why you're only using one dumbbell. Let them. If your goal is a balanced physique and a pain-free neck, their confusion is a small price to pay.
Practical Steps to Fix Your Own Asymmetry
If you've noticed you're becoming that guy working out one trap, don't panic. It's usually a 3-to-6 month fix, not a lifetime sentence. Start by filming yourself from behind while doing normal barbell shrugs. If the bar is slanted, you have your answer.
Next, incorporate "Suitcase Carries." Grab a heavy dumbbell in just one hand and walk for 40 yards. Keep your torso perfectly upright. Your trap has to work overtime to keep that shoulder from dipping. It’s a functional way to build "anti-lateral flexion" strength while hitting the traps.
Finally, check your workstation. If you spend 8 hours a day with your right arm extended for a mouse, your right trap is in a constant state of semi-contraction. Move your mouse. Change your chair height. Sometimes the best "trap workout" is just stopping the habit that caused the lopsidedness in the first place.
Next Steps for Implementation:
- Assess: Take a "relaxed" photo of your back in a mirror to confirm the asymmetry.
- Test: Perform a single-arm dumbbell shrug max rep test with a moderate weight (e.g., 40 lbs). If you can do 20 reps on the right and only 12 on the left, you have a clear deficit.
- Program: Add 3 sets of 15 unilateral shrugs to the beginning of your "pull" or "back" days, focusing exclusively on the weaker side for 4 weeks before re-assessing.
- Mobilize: Spend 2 minutes daily with a lacrosse ball pressed into the tighter (usually the larger) trap to release hypertonic tissues that might be inhibiting the smaller side.
- Verify: After a month, re-film your barbell shrugs to see if the bar path has leveled out.