Why Greta Gerwig’s Lady Bird Is Still the Best Coming-of-Age Movie Ever Made

Why Greta Gerwig’s Lady Bird Is Still the Best Coming-of-Age Movie Ever Made

Everyone remembers that first real fight with their mom where things felt... final. Not just a door-slamming "I hate you" moment, but that terrifying instant where you realize you're two separate people with different hearts. Lady Bird captures that. It’s a 2017 masterpiece that somehow feels like it was filmed in your own childhood bedroom, even if you never lived in Sacramento or wore a pink cast on your arm.

Honestly, the movie works because it refuses to be precious. Greta Gerwig, making her solo directorial debut here, didn't just write a script; she bottled the specific, itchy feeling of being seventeen and desperate for your "real" life to start.

The film follows Christine "Lady Bird" McPherson. She’s played by Saoirse Ronan, who manages to be both deeply annoying and incredibly sympathetic in the same breath. She wants to go to college in New York. Or at least "somewhere with culture." Her mom, Marion (played by the formidable Laurie Metcalf), is a nurse working double shifts because the family is basically one bad month away from financial ruin.

That’s the core. It’s not just a "teen movie." It's a movie about money, class, and the exhausting labor of love.

The Sacramento Problem and Why It Matters

Most movies treat the protagonist's hometown as a backdrop. In Lady Bird, Sacramento is a character. It’s the "Midwest of California," as the film points out. For Lady Bird, it’s a cage. For her mother, it’s home.

There is this incredible scene toward the end. Lady Bird is finally in New York. She’s walking around, and she sees a reflection of herself. She calls home. She talks about driving through Sacramento and how she noticed the way the light hits the trees. It’s the first time she realizes that "attention" is just another word for "love."

Joan Didion once wrote about Sacramento with a mix of disdain and deep, aching nostalgia. Gerwig leans into that. She doesn't make the city look like a postcard. It looks like a place where people go to work, shop at Thrift Town, and wonder if they’ll ever leave.

If you've ever felt like your life was happening somewhere else, this movie is for you. It’s for the kids who spent their Saturdays at the mall because there was literally nothing else to do. It’s for the parents who watched those kids grow up and felt a weird mix of pride and resentment that their children wanted more than what was given to them.

Let's Talk About Marion McPherson

We need to talk about Laurie Metcalf. Seriously.

Most "movie moms" are either saints or villains. Marion is neither. She is tired. She’s stressed about the mortgage. She’s worried her daughter is going to fail because she doesn't have the "work ethic" to survive the real world.

💡 You might also like: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong

When they’re shopping for a prom dress and Lady Bird asks, "Do you even like me?" and Marion responds, "I want you to be the best version of yourself that you can be," it’s devastating.

Lady Bird’s response is the heartbeat of the film: "What if this is the best version?"

That line kills me every time. It’s the ultimate teenage plea. Accept me as I am, even if I’m messy and ungrateful and weird. ### The Finance of Coming of Age
Unlike Pretty in Pink or other 80s staples, Lady Bird is obsessed with the cost of things.

  1. The price of a magazine at the grocery store.
  2. The tuition for a private Catholic school that the family can barely afford.
  3. The shame of Lady Bird’s father, Larry (Tracy Letts), losing his job and hiding his depression.
  4. The way Lady Bird lies to her "cool" friends about where she lives.

She tells the rich girl, Jenna, that she lives in the "big blue house" she saw during a walk. It’s a classic move. We’ve all done some version of that—pretending our lives are shinier than they are to fit in with people who don't actually care about us.

The Boys: Kyle, Danny, and the Art of Being Wrong

Lady Bird’s romantic interests are perfectly cast archetypes of the early 2000s.

First, there’s Danny. Lucas Hedges is great here. He’s the "nice guy" who ends up being gay, which leads to one of the most empathetic scenes in modern cinema. Instead of making it about her betrayal, Lady Bird holds him while he cries in the parking lot of the supermarket. It’s a moment of pure, platonic grace.

Then there’s Kyle. Timothée Chalamet plays the ultimate "alt" boy. He reads The People’s History of the United States. He rolls his own cigarettes. He’s "anarchist" but lives in a house with a pool.

Kyle is the guy who tells you he doesn't "believe in money" while his dad pays for everything. Every girl in 2002 knew a Kyle. Every girl in 2026 knows a Kyle. He’s a universal constant. He’s the guy who takes your virginity and then tells you he isn't into "labels."

Lady Bird’s realization that Kyle is actually kind of a loser is a massive part of her growth. She stops trying to be the "cool girl" and realizes that her best friend, Julie (Beanie Feldstein), is the only person who actually knows her.

📖 Related: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted

Why Lady Bird Still Matters Today

It’s been years since the movie came out, and it hasn't aged a day. Why? Because Greta Gerwig didn't try to make a "period piece" about 2002. She made a movie about the specific friction of mother-daughter relationships.

It’s also technically brilliant.
The editing by Nick Houy is fast. It feels like memories. You get these short bursts of scenes—Lady Bird jumping out of a car, a school play rehearsal, a quick argument in the kitchen—that build a mosaic of a year.

There’s no "big" plot. Nobody dies. There’s no huge twist. It’s just life. And that’s why it works.

The Catholic School Element

The setting of Immaculate Heart of Mary is vital. It provides a structure for Lady Bird to rebel against. But interestingly, the movie isn't "anti-religion." The nuns and priests are actually depicted with quite a bit of warmth.

Sister Sarah Joan (Lois Smith) is the one who notices Lady Bird’s love for Sacramento through her writing. She’s the one who sees the talent before Lady Bird sees it herself. It’s a refreshing take. Usually, cinematic nuns are strict caricatures. Here, they’re just teachers trying to help a kid find her way.

What Most People Get Wrong About the Ending

Some people think the ending is sad. Lady Bird gets to New York, gets drunk, ends up in the hospital, and goes to church. They think it's a defeat.

It’s not.

The ending is about integration. She sheds the "Lady Bird" persona and goes back to being Christine. She realizes that she can’t just cut off her past. She finally understands her mother.

When she calls home and leaves that voicemail, she isn't admitting defeat. She’s admitting love. She’s acknowledging that her mother gave her everything she could, even if it was wrapped in criticism and anxiety.

👉 See also: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground

It’s a complicated ending for a complicated relationship.

Actionable Takeaways for Movie Lovers

If you haven't seen Lady Bird in a while, or if you're looking to dive deeper into why this film works, here are a few things to keep in mind for your next rewatch or film study:

  • Watch the background. Notice the clutter in the McPherson house compared to the sterile, empty spaces in the "big blue house." The production design tells the story of their income bracket without saying a word.
  • Listen to the score. Jon Brion’s music is whimsical but has an underlying tension. It sounds like the inside of a teenager’s head—hopeful but slightly frantic.
  • Pay attention to the mirror shots. Gerwig uses mirrors throughout the film to show Lady Bird’s shifting sense of identity. She’s constantly checking to see who she is becoming.
  • Compare it to Gerwig’s later work. If you watch Little Women or Barbie, you can see the seeds of her style here. She loves female ensembles and exploring the "inner life" of women who are often dismissed by society.

Lady Bird is a masterpiece of the "slice of life" genre. It doesn't need explosions or high-stakes drama because, when you’re seventeen, choosing the right prom dress or getting into a college your parents can't afford is high-stakes drama. It’s the highest.

To really appreciate the craft, look at the script’s structure. It skips the "boring" parts of scenes. We enter late and leave early. This keeps the pace brisk and mirrors the way time feels like it’s slipping through your fingers during your senior year of high school. One minute it’s homecoming, the next you’re packing a suitcase.

Check out the "making of" features or interviews with Saoirse Ronan about her accent work. She’s Irish, but you would never know it. She nails the flat, Northern California vowels perfectly. It’s a testament to her skill and Gerwig’s direction.

If you want to understand the modern cinematic landscape, you have to understand this movie. It paved the way for a new era of female-led, personal filmmaking that doesn't apologize for being "small." Because, as it turns out, the small stories are usually the biggest ones we have.


Next Steps to Deepen Your Appreciation:

  • Read the Screenplay: Greta Gerwig’s writing is incredibly descriptive. Reading the script allows you to see how she envisioned the "Sacramento light" before a single frame was shot.
  • Watch the "Brother" Films: Check out Frances Ha and Mistress America. Gerwig co-wrote these with Noah Baumbach, and they act as a spiritual evolution of the themes found in this movie—moving from the teen years into the messy twenties.
  • Explore the Soundtrack: Beyond the score, the 2002-era needle drops (like Dave Matthews Band) are used with zero irony. They capture the era’s "uncool" authenticity perfectly.

The film is a reminder that being "average" is okay, as long as you're paying attention to the world around you. Lady Bird wanted to be special, but in the end, she realized she was already something better: she was herself.