Music is weirdly subjective. Ask a room of ten people who the best guitarist is and you’ll likely end up with twelve different answers and at least one heated argument about whether speed matters more than "soul." It’s a mess. But when we talk about great guitar players of all time, we aren't just talking about who can play the most notes per second. We're talking about the people who changed how the instrument actually functions.
They shifted the tectonic plates of culture.
Take Jimi Hendrix. People love to deify him, and for good reason. Before Hendrix, the electric guitar was largely an amplified acoustic instrument. After him? It was a laboratory of feedback, distortion, and sheer physical expression. He didn’t just play songs; he manipulated electricity. If you’ve ever watched the footage of him at Monterey Pop, you’ll see it isn’t just about the notes. It’s the way he treats the Stratocaster like a living, breathing extension of his own nervous system.
Honestly, most lists get this wrong by focusing purely on technical proficiency.
The Blues Roots and the Myth of Perfection
You can't have a conversation about the great guitar players of all time without looking at the Mississippi Delta. Robert Johnson is the ghost in the machine of every rock riff you've ever heard. The legend says he sold his soul at a crossroads. The reality is probably more impressive: he practiced his tail off until he could play rhythm, bass, and lead lines simultaneously on a beat-up acoustic.
Keith Richards once famously said that when he first heard Johnson, he thought there were two people playing. It was just one guy. That’s the "Delta magic."
Beyond the Three-Chord Loop
Then you have the kings. B.B. King, Albert King, and Freddie King. B.B. changed the game because he realized what you don't play is just as important as what you do. His vibrato—that "butterfly" flick of the wrist—is the gold standard. He could make one single note say more than a thousand shredders. He treated his guitar, Lucille, like a vocalist.
It’s about phrasing.
If you listen to "The Thrill Is Gone," you aren't hearing a technical exercise. You're hearing a conversation. This is a nuance that often gets lost in modern YouTube "shred" culture, where the goal is often maximum density. But B.B. taught everyone from Eric Clapton to John Mayer that space is a note, too.
✨ Don't miss: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
When the Volume Got Turned Up
In the late 60s and 70s, things got loud. Really loud. This is where the "Guitar God" archetype was born.
Jimmy Page is the architect here. As the mastermind behind Led Zeppelin, Page wasn't just a player; he was a producer who used the guitar as a textural tool. Think about the riff in "Whole Lotta Love." It’s simple. It’s primal. But the way he layered tracks and used distance miking created a "light and shade" effect that basically invented the sonic blueprint for hard rock.
Then there’s David Gilmour.
Pink Floyd wouldn't be Pink Floyd without that soaring, melodic sensibility. Gilmour’s solo on "Comfortably Numb" is frequently cited as the greatest of all time. Why? Because it’s a composition within a composition. It has a beginning, a middle, and a climax. He’s not showing off; he’s taking you somewhere. His gear setup is legendary for its complexity—fuzz faces, delay units, rotary speakers—but his touch is what makes it work.
The Van Halen Earthquake
1978 changed everything. Eddie Van Halen released "Eruption," and every guitar player on the planet suddenly felt like they were holding a prehistoric tool. Eddie didn’t invent two-handed tapping, but he perfected it and made it musical. He brought a sense of "brown sound" warmth and reckless joy to the instrument that had become a bit too serious and prog-heavy.
He was a tinkerer. He built his "Frankenstrat" because he couldn't find a guitar that did what he wanted. That DIY spirit is a huge part of why he's consistently ranked among the great guitar players of all time. He hacked the instrument.
Why the "Best" Is Often a Misleading Title
We need to address the elephant in the room: the technical wizards.
People like Allan Holdsworth or Guthrie Govan. These guys operate on a level of music theory and physical dexterity that is frankly terrifying. Holdsworth, in particular, influenced everyone from Eddie Van Halen to Frank Zappa. He played "sheets of sound" that felt more like a saxophone than a guitar.
🔗 Read more: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
But does technical perfection make you "great"?
Not necessarily. It depends on what you value. Some people want the raw, visceral punch of Link Wray or the jagged, intentional "wrongness" of Thelonious Monk-inspired players. Others want the mathematical precision of Steve Vai.
The Role of Innovation
- Django Reinhardt: Played incredible gypsy jazz with only two working fingers on his fretting hand after a caravan fire.
- Sister Rosetta Tharpe: The godmother of rock and roll who was shredding on a Gibson SG before most of the "legends" had even picked up a pick.
- Joni Mitchell: Used dozens of alternate tunings because she wanted to hear chords that didn't exist in standard tuning.
These players are often left out of the "top five" lists because they don't fit the leather-pants-and-Marshall-stacks mold. But their impact is arguably greater. Mitchell’s use of the guitar as a harmonic palette changed how songwriters approach the instrument.
The Great Guitar Players of All Time: A Global Shift
It’s easy to get stuck in the Anglo-American bubble. But the guitar is a global instrument.
Look at Paco de Lucía. He revolutionized Flamenco. He brought in elements of jazz and bossa nova, pushing the boundaries of what an acoustic guitar could do. His speed was lightning, but his rhythmic pocket was deep.
Then you have Prince.
People often forget how terrifyingly good Prince was at the guitar because he was also a world-class singer, dancer, and songwriter. But go watch the 2004 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame performance of "While My Guitar Gently Weeps." He steps out and absolutely demolishes a solo, then throws his guitar into the air, and it seemingly never comes down. That’s showmanship backed by elite-level skill. He could play in the style of Hendrix, Santana, or Nile Rodgers effortlessly.
The Misconception of Speed
There’s a pervasive idea that the faster you play, the better you are. This is a trap.
💡 You might also like: Is Lincoln Lawyer Coming Back? Mickey Haller's Next Move Explained
Think about Neil Young. He’s not a "shredder" by any stretch of the imagination. His solos are often one or two notes, played with a distorted, crumbling intensity. But they are perfect. They fit the song. They have "stink" on them.
On the flip side, you have Yngwie Malmsteen, who brought neo-classical shred to the masses. While his style is polarizing, you can't deny the technical achievement. He treated the guitar like a Paganini violin.
The divide usually falls between "feel" and "technique." The truly great guitar players of all time are the ones who manage to bridge that gap. Jeff Beck was perhaps the master of this. He never used a pick toward the end of his career; he used his thumb and fingers to manipulate the volume knob and the whammy bar simultaneously. He sounded like a human voice, an alien spacecraft, and a hot rod all at once.
How to Actually Learn from the Legends
If you’re a player looking to absorb some of this greatness, don’t just learn the tabs. Tabs are just the "what." You need to understand the "how" and the "why."
Practical Steps for Improvement
- Listen to the source: If you love Stevie Ray Vaughan, don't just listen to Stevie. Listen to Albert King and Buddy Guy. That’s where he got it from.
- Record yourself: It’s painful, but it’s the only way to hear your timing and tone objectively. All the greats had an incredible sense of time.
- Limit your tools: Try playing for a week with no pedals. See what sounds you can coax out of the wood and wire alone.
- Learn other instruments' parts: Try to play a Miles Davis trumpet solo or a Carole King piano line on your guitar. It will break you out of standard "box" patterns.
The guitar is a notoriously difficult instrument to master because it’s so tactile. Every tiny movement of your fingertip changes the pitch, the timbre, and the attack. That’s why we’re still obsessed with these players decades later. They found a way to make a piece of wood and six strings sound like a soul.
Where to Go Next
Start by diversifying your listening. If you’ve spent your life listening to blues-rock, go listen to Julian Bage or Tosin Abasi. See how different genres solve the problem of making music.
The "greatest" player is ultimately the one who inspires you to pick up the instrument and play. Whether that's the raw power of Kurt Cobain or the intricate tapping of Polyphia’s Tim Henson, the impact is the same. It’s about communication.
Stop worrying about the ranking and start listening to the phrasing. That’s where the real magic is hidden.