Imagine waking up in a house where the walls are screaming. That’s not a metaphor. For Francisco de Goya, the most famous painter in Spain, it was just Tuesday. Between 1819 and 1823, an aging, deaf, and increasingly disillusioned Goya retreated to a villa outside Madrid called the Quinta del Sordo (the Villa of the Deaf Man). He didn't paint these for a king. He didn't paint them for money. He painted them directly onto the plaster of his dining room and salon walls.
The Black Paintings Goya created during this period are arguably the most disturbing sequence of images in Western art history. They weren't meant to be seen by you. Or me. Or anyone. They were private nightmares.
Most people think of Goya as the guy who painted royal portraits or that famous "Nude Maja." But the Black Paintings are something else entirely. They are a visceral, terrifying descent into the darkest corners of the human psyche. When you look at Saturn Devouring His Son, you aren't just looking at a mythological scene; you’re looking at a man who has lost all faith in humanity, watching the world tear itself apart. It’s raw. It’s messy. Honestly, it’s a bit much for most people to handle in a single sitting.
The Mystery of the Quinta del Sordo
The house itself is gone now. It was demolished in 1909, but the murals were luckily transferred to canvas by a restorer named Salvador Martínez Cubells. If he hadn't done that, we’d have nothing but written accounts of these horrors. Goya bought the property in 1819. He was 73. He had survived two near-fatal illnesses, lived through the Napoleonic Wars, and watched the Spanish Inquisition tighten its grip. He was done with the "polite" world.
There are 14 paintings in total. They aren't "black" just because of the mood—Goya used a restricted palette of blacks, ochres, and greys. It’s heavy. It’s oppressive.
Take The Dog, for instance. It’s basically just a tiny dog’s head peeking over a brown mass, looking up at a vast, empty void. Some art historians, like Robert Hughes, have argued this is the most modern painting of the 19th century. It feels like existential dread before existentialism was even a word. There’s no context. No story. Just a creature drowning in nothingness.
💡 You might also like: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
What the Black Paintings Goya Produced Actually Mean
Scholars have been arguing about the "meaning" of these works for two centuries. The truth? Goya never wrote a single word about them. He didn't even give them titles. The names we use today—Witches' Sabbath, A Pilgrimage to San Isidro, Fight with Cudgels—were all invented by his friends or later curators at the Museo del Prado.
Here is the thing about Saturn Devouring His Son. In the original Greek myth, Saturn eats his children to prevent them from overthrowing him. Usually, artists like Rubens painted this as a majestic, albeit gory, scene. Goya’s version is a monster. The eyes are bulging. The hands are clawing into the bloody torso of a body that looks way too adult to be a "child." Many experts believe this was Goya’s way of commenting on the Spanish state "eating" its own people through war and revolution. Or maybe it was just a man facing his own mortality and the "devouring" nature of time.
Fight with Cudgels is another brutal one. Two men are buried up to their knees in mud, swinging heavy clubs at each other’s heads. They can’t run. They can’t escape. They are stuck in a cycle of violence until one—or both—dies. If you want a visual representation of civil war or political polarization, Goya nailed it in 1820.
The Technical Struggle
Painting on plaster is a nightmare. Goya used oils, not the traditional "buon fresco" technique. This meant the paintings started deteriorating almost immediately. By the time they were moved to the Prado in the late 1800s, they were a mess.
Martínez Cubells, the restorer, had to fill in a lot of gaps. Some critics actually argue that the paintings we see today are "half-Goya, half-Cubells." It’s a controversial take, but it adds to the layering of the mystery. Were the originals even darker? It’s hard to imagine they could be.
📖 Related: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
A Breakdown of the Key Murals
- Witches' Sabbath (The Great He-Goat): A massive, hulking goat-man sits before a crowd of terrified, deformed women. It’s a critique of superstition and the "dark" side of religious fervor.
- Two Old Men Eating Soup: Two skeletal figures, one laughing, one seemingly toothless. It’s grotesque. It mocks the frailty of old age.
- Judith and Holofernes: Unlike the vibrant versions by Artemisia Gentileschi, Goya’s Judith is shrouded in shadow. The act of violence is quiet, somber, and deeply unsettling.
- The Leocadia: This is one of the few "calm" ones. It shows a woman leaning against a mound, possibly Goya’s housekeeper and companion. Even here, the atmosphere is heavy with mourning.
Why Do We Care?
In a world of polished Instagram filters and AI-generated "perfect" art, Goya’s Black Paintings feel incredibly honest. He wasn't trying to please a patron. He wasn't trying to make something "pretty" for a living room. He was venting.
The Black Paintings Goya created represent the birth of Expressionism. Without Goya’s dark period, you don't get Francis Bacon. You don't get Edvard Munch. You don't get the idea that art can be a scream instead of a song. He broke the rules of what art was "allowed" to be. He showed us that the monsters aren't under the bed; they're inside us.
Some people find the Prado's "Goya Room" too much. It’s low-lit. The paintings are huge. You feel like you’re being watched by the distorted faces in The Holy Office. But that’s the point. Goya wanted to confront the shadows.
The Controversy: Did Goya Even Paint Them?
I have to mention this because it’s a big deal in the art world. In the late 90s and early 2000s, some researchers, like Juan José Junquera, suggested that Goya’s son, Javier, might have actually painted them. The argument is that Goya’s contemporary descriptions of the house don't mention the murals.
Most experts at the Prado, however, have debunked this. The brushwork, the psychological depth, and the sheer genius of the compositions are "Goya" through and through. Javier Goya was a decent painter, but he wasn't this good. Nobody was.
👉 See also: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
How to Experience These Works Today
If you’re heading to Madrid, the Museo del Prado is the only place to see them. Don't rush. Most tourists sprint through the museum to see Las Meninas and then leave. Don't do that. Give the Black Paintings time to breathe.
- Start with the early Goya: See the tapestries. See the bright, sunny scenes of Spanish life. It makes the transition to the Black Paintings much more jarring.
- Look at the eyes: Goya was a master of the "thousand-yard stare." The eyes in these paintings often look past the viewer, into a void we can’t see.
- Read the history of the Spanish Inquisition: Context matters. Knowing Goya lived in fear of being persecuted for his "liberal" views explains a lot of the paranoia in the brushstrokes.
The Black Paintings Goya left behind are a testament to the resilience—and the fragility—of the human spirit. They remind us that even in total silence and isolation, the mind never stops working. It creates. Sometimes it creates beauty, and sometimes it creates Saturn.
To truly understand these works, you need to look beyond the "horror" label. They are a deeply philosophical meditation on the failure of the Enlightenment. Goya lived through the "Age of Reason," but his paintings tell us that reason is a very thin veneer over a very chaotic world.
Actionable Insights for Art Lovers
- Visit the Prado on a weekday morning. The Goya rooms get crowded, and these paintings require a bit of personal space to process.
- Compare Goya to his contemporaries. Look at the neoclassical artists of the same era (like David). You'll see just how radical and "punk rock" Goya was for his time.
- Watch the "Goya in Bordeaux" film or read Robert Hughes' biography. It gives you the gritty details of his physical decline and how that fueled his artistic output.
- Don't look for a "happy" ending. These paintings don't offer one. They offer truth, and sometimes the truth is just a dog drowning in a brown void.
The legacy of the Black Paintings is found in every horror movie, every psychological thriller, and every piece of modern art that dares to be ugly. They are uncomfortable because they are true. Goya didn't paint them for us, but in a weird way, we are the only ones who can finally see them for what they are: a map of the human shadow.
To explore the physical reality of these works, your best bet is to study the high-resolution infrared scans provided by the Museo del Prado online. These scans reveal the underlying sketches and the "first versions" of some figures, showing how Goya’s vision evolved from standard scenes into the nightmare fuel we see today. If you want to dive deeper into the technical side, look for research papers on the "Martínez Cubells restoration" to see exactly how much of the paint on the wall made it onto the canvas. It’s a fascinating look at how we preserve—and sometimes accidentally alter—history.