Everyone thinks they know Christmas. You've seen the movies. You've heard "Jingle Bells" approximately four million times since November 1st. But then the annual family party hits, and someone pulls out a deck of cards or a printed list of good christmas trivia questions, and suddenly, the room goes silent. Nobody actually knows which reindeer is mentioned first in the song, or which US President was the first to put a tree in the White House.
Trivia is a weirdly competitive sport during the holidays. It's not just about facts; it's about the "gotcha" moments that make Uncle Larry feel like a genius and make you realize you’ve been watching Elf on repeat without actually paying attention to the details. Honestly, most trivia lists are pretty lazy. They ask the same three questions about Rudolph’s nose or where Jesus was born. If you want to actually host a game that doesn't put people to sleep, you have to dig into the weird, the historical, and the slightly obscure stuff that makes people go, "Wait, really?"
The "War" Over the First Christmas Tree
There’s a massive debate that usually ruins at least one dinner every December: who actually started the Christmas tree tradition? If you’re looking for good christmas trivia questions, this is the holy grail. Most people will scream "Germany!" and they’re mostly right, but the specifics are messy.
The 16th-century preacher Martin Luther is often credited with being the first to put lights on a tree. Legend says he was walking through a forest, looked up at the stars twinkling through the branches, and tried to recreate it for his kids using wax candles. It sounds dangerous. It probably was. But the first documented tree? That’s a fight between Tallinn in Estonia (1441) and Riga in Latvia (1510). Both cities claim they had the first public tree put up by the Brotherhood of Blackheads.
In America, it took a long time to catch on. The Puritans in New England actually hated Christmas. They thought it was a rowdy, pagan-adjacent mess. In 1659, the General Court of Massachusetts Bay Colony made it a criminal offense to celebrate December 25th in any way that wasn't working. You’d get fined five shillings just for being festive. It wasn't until the mid-19th century, when Queen Victoria and Prince Albert (who was German) were sketched in the Illustrated London News standing around a decorated tree, that the trend finally exploded in the UK and the US.
Pop Culture Trivia That Actually Challenges People
Movies are the easiest category, right? Wrong. People misremember details constantly.
Take Home Alone. A classic. But do you know the name of the movie Kevin is watching to scare off the burglars? It’s Angels with Filthy Souls. Here’s the kicker: it’s not a real movie. It was filmed specifically for Home Alone as a parody of the 1938 film Angels with Dirty Faces. People spend years trying to find the full version of that gangster flick, but it literally doesn't exist outside of the McCallister house.
Then there’s the Grinch. Dr. Seuss’s creation is iconic, but the 1966 animated special added a detail that wasn't in the original book. In the book, the Grinch is just... there. In the cartoon, he’s green. Before that, he was usually depicted in black and white with some hints of pink or red. The director, Chuck Jones, allegedly chose that specific shade of "Grinch Green" because it reminded him of the color of some ugly rental cars he used to drive.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
Music and the Royalties Game
If you want to talk about good christmas trivia questions regarding music, skip the easy "All I Want for Christmas is You" stats. Everyone knows Mariah Carey is the queen of December. Instead, look at "White Christmas."
Irving Berlin wrote it, and the Bing Crosby version is the best-selling single of all time. Not just the best-selling Christmas song—the best-selling anything. We’re talking over 50 million copies. But did you know Berlin was a Jewish immigrant who didn't even celebrate Christmas as a religious holiday? He wrote it in a hotel in California (or Arizona, accounts vary) during a heatwave. He reportedly told his secretary, "Grab your pen and take down this song. I just wrote the best song I’ve ever written — heck, I just wrote the best song that anybody’s ever written!"
He wasn't wrong.
The Weird History of Food and Drink
What do we eat? Fruitcake? Nobody actually eats fruitcake. It’s a brick of sugar and preserved fruit that survives nuclear winters. But the history of the "Christmas Pickle" is even weirder because it’s basically a marketing lie.
There’s a popular belief that hiding a glass pickle ornament in the tree is an old German tradition. It’s not. If you go to Germany and ask about the Weihnachtsgurke, most people will look at you like you have three heads. It’s widely believed that a company started selling these ornaments in the US in the 1880s (possibly Woolworths) and made up the "ancient tradition" story to sell more glass vegetables.
And then there's the Coca-Cola / Santa Claus myth.
Did Coke Invent the Red Suit?
Basically, no. But sort of yes.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
People love to say that Santa wears red only because of Coca-Cola’s 1930s ad campaigns by artist Haddon Sundblom. That’s a bit of an exaggeration. Santa had appeared in red coats in political cartoons by Thomas Nast back in the 1800s. However, before the Coke ads, Santa was a bit of a shapeshifter. Sometimes he was a tall, thin man; sometimes he looked like a spooky elf in a green or tan robe. Sundblom’s paintings for Coke standardized the "Jolly Fat Man" look we have today—the grandfatherly face, the specific shade of crimson, and the heavy black belt.
Technical Trivia: The Science of Snow and Reindeer
Let's get nerdy. If you want to stump the kids, ask them about the reindeer.
Scientific fact: Male reindeer drop their antlers in early December. Female reindeer keep theirs until the spring when they give birth. So, every single one of Santa’s reindeer—Rudolph, Dasher, Dancer, the whole crew—is technically female, or they’re all very young males.
Also, why a red nose? Biologically, reindeer have a massive concentration of blood vessels in their noses to help regulate their body temperature in the freezing Arctic. If a reindeer actually had a glowing red nose, it would just be an incredible amount of microcirculation happening to prevent frostbite.
The Astronaut Factor
Christmas has even made it to space. In 1965, the crew of Gemini 6, Wally Schirra and Tom Stafford, decided to play a prank on Mission Control. They reported seeing a "UFO" in a low polar orbit. They described it as having eight smaller modules in front and a pilot wearing a red suit. Then, they pulled out a smuggled harmonica and a set of bells and played "Jingle Bells."
It was the first musical instrument ever played in space. That harmonica is now in the Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum.
How to Win Your Next Trivia Night
To actually use these good christmas trivia questions effectively, you have to lean into the nuances. Don't just ask "What is the best-selling song?" Ask "Which Christmas classic was written by a man who didn't celebrate the holiday and was convinced he’d written the greatest song in human history?"
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
It changes the vibe. It makes people think.
Here are the specific bits of info that usually catch people off guard:
- The First Eggnog: It likely descended from a British medieval drink called "posset," which was hot ale mixed with curdled milk and spices. It was a drink for the wealthy because milk and eggs were expensive.
- The Statue of Liberty: It’s technically the largest Christmas gift ever given. France gave it to the US in 1886.
- The Mistletoe Paradox: The word "mistletoe" literally translates from Old English as "dung on a twig." This is because the plant is spread through bird droppings. Not so romantic now, is it?
- The NORAD Santa Tracker: This started because of a typo in a 1955 Sears Roebuck ad. A newspaper printed the "hotline" to Santa, but it was actually the number for the Continental Air Defense Command (CONAD) operations center. The colonel on duty, Harry Shoup, told his staff to give the kids "radar updates" on Santa’s location instead of hanging up.
Moving Beyond the Basics
If you're organizing a game, vary your formats. Don't just do multiple choice. Try a "Real or Fake" round where you make up a ridiculous holiday tradition and see if people believe it. For instance: "In Norway, people hide their brooms on Christmas Eve so witches won't steal them." (That’s actually real).
Or try: "In Japan, the traditional Christmas dinner is a bucket of KFC." (Also real. It’s so popular you have to book your bucket months in advance).
The best trivia isn't just a test of memory; it’s a way to tell stories that people haven't heard. We get so used to the tinsel and the repetitive playlists that we forget how weird and interesting the history of this holiday actually is.
To make your trivia night actually work:
- Stop using the easy stuff. If the answer is "Jesus," "Rudolph," or "The North Pole," throw the question out.
- Focus on the "Why." Instead of asking when the first tree was, ask why the Puritans banned them.
- Use visual cues. Show a picture of a 19th-century "Santeclaus" and ask the group to identify what’s missing (usually the red suit).
- Incentivize the weirdest facts. Give extra points for someone who can name more than three of the 13 Yule Lads from Icelandic folklore (like "Spoon-Licker" or "Door-Sniffer").
Start your prep by verifying your sources. Don't trust the first "Top 10" list you see on a random blog. Check historical archives or museum sites like the Smithsonian or the Victorian and Albert Museum to get the real stories. Most "facts" about Christmas are actually urban legends that have been repeated so often they’ve become accepted as truth. Breaking those myths is where the real fun is.
Focus on the stories of the people behind the traditions—the tired illustrators, the prankster astronauts, and the business owners trying to sell glass pickles. That’s how you turn a boring quiz into something people actually remember.